exam 2 Flashcards
Origins of the Bill of Rights, 1 of 2
Origins of the Bill of Rights, 1 of 2
The Constitutional Convention concluded without a bill of rights.
The Federalists, led by Alexander Hamilton, argued that a bill of
rights was unnecessary.
Antifederalists argued that the lack of a bill of rights was a
major imperfection in the Constitution.
* The Federalists realized that to gain ratification they
would have to add a bill of rights.
* Ten of the amendments were ratified on December 15,
1791; from the start, these 10 were called the Bill of
Rights.
Civil Liberties
Civil liberties are the personal rights and freedoms that the federal
government cannot abridge, either by law, constitution, or judicial
interpretation.
These are limitations on the power of government to restrain or
dictate how individuals act.
* Examples:
* Freedom of speech
* Freedom of the press
* Freedom of assembly
* Freedom to worship
* Freedom from quartering soldiers
* Freedom to bear arms
Amendment 1
protects the freedom of speech, religion, the press, assembly, and petition.
amendment 2,3,4
Second Amendment
Protects the right to keep and bear arms
Recognizes that the armed citizenry should be regulated
Protects the right to possess weapons for self-defense and protection of property and rights
Third Amendment
Prevents the government from forcing homeowners to allow soldiers to use their homes
Reflects the idea that homes are a “zone of privacy”
Fourth Amendment
Protects against unreasonable search and seizure
Ensures that police have good reason before searching people or their property
Allows some searches to be reasonable without a warrant, such as searching a car stopped for speeding
Balances individual freedoms with the rights of those suspected of crimes
amendment 5, 6, 7, 8
5th Amendment
Protects against self-incrimination, meaning that people cannot be forced to testify against themselves in a criminal case
Ensures due process
Protects against being tried twice for the same crime
Protects against the seizure of property under eminent domain
6th Amendment
Guarantees the right to a speedy trial
Guarantees the right to a trial by jury
Guarantees the right to the services of a lawyer
7th Amendment
Guarantees the right to a trial by jury in civil cases involving a certain amount of money.
The Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution protects against excessive bail, fines, and cruel and unusual punishment. It was ratified on December 15, 1791, along with the rest of the Bill of Rights.
amendment 9 and 10
Ninth Amendment
States that listing certain rights in the Constitution doesn’t mean that other rights aren’t retained by the people
Intended to address ambiguity around rights that weren’t explicitly addressed in the Constitution
Has been used to support arguments for civil rights like abortion, marital privacy, and anti-discrimination
Tenth Amendment
States that the federal government only has the powers that are delegated to it in the Constitution
Reserves powers that aren’t delegated to the federal government to the states or to the people
Intended to limit the federal government’s power and to balance the federal government with state governments
Nationalizing the Bill of Rights
Do the provisions of the Bill of Rights other than the First Amendment
put limits only on the national government?
* In 1833, – SC says yes.
* Over time, more liberties expanded through incorporation.
Today, only the Third and Seventh amendments remain
unincorporated.
* It should be noted that almost every state voluntarily complies with
the Seventh Amendment’s requirement of jury trials.
States retain some ability to restrict individual freedoms.
* Ex: the power of the government to require citizens to wear masks
or submit to vaccinations.
* State governments can take emergency actions so long as they are
not prohibited by the federal or state constitutions.
The First Amendment
The First Amendment
* 5 freedoms: speech, religion, press, assembly, and the right to
petition the government
* –> make the people of the US the freest in the world.
* no “legal age” to exercise your First Amendment freedoms.
* guaranteed to you the day you’re born.
* no citizenship requirement for First Amendment protection.
neither protects against government limits on our freedom of
expression,
* Does NOT prevent a private employer from setting its own
rules.
* prevents government from requiring you to say something you
don’t want to or keeping you from hearing or reading the words
of others
* (even if you never speak out yourself, you have the right to
receive information).
The First Amendment: Freedom of Religion
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion,
or prohibiting the free exercise thereof . . .”
* The establishment clause
* the First Amendment clause that says “Congress shall make no
law respecting an establishment of religion”
* A “wall of separation” exists between church and state
* The free exercise clause
* the First Amendment clause that protects a citizen’s right to
believe and practice whatever religion they choose
The Establishment Clause
The establishment clause: 3 different interpretations
1. it prevents the government from establishing an official church.
2. government cannot favor one religion over another.
* It is not prohibited from providing funds to religious institutions,
but funding or other assistance cannot show favoritism.
3. must be a “wall of separation” between church and state.
* Disagreement over the height of the wall.
* Many of the founding fathers believed that the spiritual purity and
sanctity of religion would be ruined if it mixed with the worldly
realm of politics.
Religious Freedom
The Supreme Court has shifted from a strict wall to a
trend of expanding free expression claims.
* In the early 1960s, the Court ruled that official lead
prayer and bible reading is unconstitutional.
* nondenominational prayer can not be required
* 1992-saying of prayer at a middle school graduation
unconstitutional
* 2014 -government cannot compel a closely-held
business to provide birth control for employees against
the owners’ religious beliefs.
* 2022 – coach may pray on the field
Free Exercise Clause
“Congress shall make no law…..prohibiting the free
exercise thereof (religion)”
* designed to prevent the government from
interfering with the practice of religion.
* This freedom is not absolute.
Several religious practices have been ruled
unconstitutional including:
* snake handling
* use of illegal drugs
* Polygamy
The First Amendment: Political Speech
Political speech is the most consistently protected of all forms
of speech.
* Highly protected by strict scrutiny and legal standards
* Courts must establish “compelling reasons” for limitations
* Protection extends to actions expressing political ideas.
* Examples: financial contributions to causes, protests
* clear and present danger to society vs. Imminent lawless
action
* Speech prohibited when directed at inciting or producing
imminent lawless action/ likely to do so
* Speech protected when speech advocates a viewpoint
without encouraging people to act on it, or when speech
encourages people to act in a way that they could not be
expected to act.
Campaign donations are also seen as political speech.
Student Speech
There is conditionally protected speech for high school students in public
schools.
* (1969) USSC –students who came to school wearing black armbands to
protest the Vietnam War.
* School punishment for sexually suggestive speech is permissible.
* The Court has also restricted students’ speech by defining their speech
and journalism as part of their education and not protected like adult
speech.
* (2007)–school could suspend a student, Joseph Frederick, for displaying a
banner that read “Bong Hits 4 Jesus.”
15
A Balance: Freedom of Speech & the Press
Prior Restraint – a government action that prevents
material from being published.
* USSC Generally rules that press may publish
Symbolic speech–symbols, signs, and other methods of
expression. The Supreme Court has upheld as constitutional a
number of actions including:
* wear armbands to protest the Vietnam War (Tinker v. De
Moines Independent Community School District, 1969).
* flying a communist red flag
* burning the American flag
The Second Amendment
“A well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state,
the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”
The Second Amendment right to bear arms applies to states and localities.
* Types of arms can be restricted.
* Laws cannot ban the possession of a firearm in a home.
* District of Columbia v. Heller (2008)
* 2nd Am provides a constitutional right to keep a loaded handgun at
home for self-defense.
* States and local governments can regulate firearms.
* This includes waiting periods, registration, types of arms allowed, and
other aspects related to access.
Rights of the Accused: Due Process
Due Process of law
* This refers to the right of every individual against arbitrary
action by national or state governments.
* Together, the Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, and Eighth amendments are
the essence of the due process of law.
The Fourth Amendment: Unlawful Searches and Seizures
The Fourth Amendment guarantees the security of citizens against
unreasonable (i.e., improper) searches and seizures.
* Requires search warrants-probable cause
* Allows “Stop and Frisk”-warrant less searches only with
reasonable suspicion
* interpreted the 4th to allow the police to search
* The person arrested
* Things in plain view of the accused
* Places or things that the person could touch or reach, or
which are otherwise in the arrestee’s “immediate control.”
* The exclusionary rule: the ability of courts to exclude illegally
obtained evidence (Mapp v. Ohio, 1961).
Mandatory drug testing also falls under the Fourth Amendment as
does the use of drug-sniffing dogs (requires consent or a warrant).
The Fifth Amendment
Rights in the court
* Right to a grand jury
* determines whether sufficient evidence is available to justify a
trial; they do not rule on the accused’s guilt or innocence.
* “No person shall be …compelled in any criminal case to be a
witness against himself.
* criminals cannot be required to take the stand in a trial.
* Protection against double jeopardy -protects from being tried
twice for the same crime.
* “Miranda rights” and the Miranda rule (Miranda v. Arizona [1966])
* must be informed prior to police interrogation of their rights to
remain silent & benefit of legal counsel.
* Eminent domain
* Government can take private property for public use but must
show a public purpose.
* fair payment.
Miranda Rights
right to remain silent, anything you say and do can be used against you in a court of law, right to a lawyer, if you can’t get a lawyer you’ll be given one before being questioned.
The Sixth Amendment
The Sixth Amendment is crucial for running fair trials. It includes:
* The right to a speedy trial
* The right to confront witnesses before an impartial jury
* The right to counsel
* Gideon v. Wainwright (1963): Anyone facing imprisonment
has the right to an attorney, even if they are unable to afford
one (public defender).
The Eighth Amendment: Cruel and Unusual Punishment, 1 of 2
The Eighth Amendment prohibits:
* Excessive bail
* Excessive fines -
* Cruel and unusual punishment
The death penalty is allowed, but it requires due process.
* The states decide whether to allow the death penalty.
* If allowed states determine the method.
USSC HAS limited when/how the death penalty may be used.
* Furman v. GA (1972) – application of the death penalty in GA is cruel & unusual
(all states suspend death penalty for four years)
* 1980’s and 1990’s cases made it harder to overcome bad applications of the
sentence.
* 2000’s saw more restrictions –
* death was too harsh a penalty for the crime of rape of a child.
* prohibition based on IQ and the age of defendant.
Cruel and unusual punishment goes beyond the death penalty.
The Right to Privacy
The right to privacy is the right to be left alone from government
interference in personal areas.
Not explicitly mentioned in the Bill of Rights;
this right has been interpreted as resting in the
* 4th Amendment
* 9th Amendment
* The right to privacy covers matters such as:
* eminent domain (the right of government to take private
property for public use)
* birth control
* Abortion - (Roe v. Wade in 1973 and overturned by Dobbs v. Jackson
in 2022)
* sexual orientation - (Bowers v. Hardwick in 1986 and overturned
by Lawrence v. Texas in 2003)
federalism
a system of government in which power is divided between central government and regional governments