exam 2 Flashcards

1
Q

Origins of the Bill of Rights, 1 of 2

A

Origins of the Bill of Rights, 1 of 2
The Constitutional Convention concluded without a bill of rights.
The Federalists, led by Alexander Hamilton, argued that a bill of
rights was unnecessary.
Antifederalists argued that the lack of a bill of rights was a
major imperfection in the Constitution.
* The Federalists realized that to gain ratification they
would have to add a bill of rights.
* Ten of the amendments were ratified on December 15,
1791; from the start, these 10 were called the Bill of
Rights.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Civil Liberties

A

Civil liberties are the personal rights and freedoms that the federal
government cannot abridge, either by law, constitution, or judicial
interpretation.
These are limitations on the power of government to restrain or
dictate how individuals act.
* Examples:
* Freedom of speech
* Freedom of the press
* Freedom of assembly
* Freedom to worship
* Freedom from quartering soldiers
* Freedom to bear arms

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Amendment 1

A

protects the freedom of speech, religion, the press, assembly, and petition.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

amendment 2,3,4

A

Second Amendment
Protects the right to keep and bear arms
Recognizes that the armed citizenry should be regulated
Protects the right to possess weapons for self-defense and protection of property and rights
Third Amendment
Prevents the government from forcing homeowners to allow soldiers to use their homes
Reflects the idea that homes are a “zone of privacy”
Fourth Amendment
Protects against unreasonable search and seizure
Ensures that police have good reason before searching people or their property
Allows some searches to be reasonable without a warrant, such as searching a car stopped for speeding
Balances individual freedoms with the rights of those suspected of crimes

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

amendment 5, 6, 7, 8

A

5th Amendment
Protects against self-incrimination, meaning that people cannot be forced to testify against themselves in a criminal case
Ensures due process
Protects against being tried twice for the same crime
Protects against the seizure of property under eminent domain
6th Amendment
Guarantees the right to a speedy trial
Guarantees the right to a trial by jury
Guarantees the right to the services of a lawyer
7th Amendment
Guarantees the right to a trial by jury in civil cases involving a certain amount of money.
The Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution protects against excessive bail, fines, and cruel and unusual punishment. It was ratified on December 15, 1791, along with the rest of the Bill of Rights.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

amendment 9 and 10

A

Ninth Amendment
States that listing certain rights in the Constitution doesn’t mean that other rights aren’t retained by the people
Intended to address ambiguity around rights that weren’t explicitly addressed in the Constitution
Has been used to support arguments for civil rights like abortion, marital privacy, and anti-discrimination
Tenth Amendment
States that the federal government only has the powers that are delegated to it in the Constitution
Reserves powers that aren’t delegated to the federal government to the states or to the people
Intended to limit the federal government’s power and to balance the federal government with state governments

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Nationalizing the Bill of Rights

A

Do the provisions of the Bill of Rights other than the First Amendment
put limits only on the national government?
* In 1833, – SC says yes.
* Over time, more liberties expanded through incorporation.
Today, only the Third and Seventh amendments remain
unincorporated.
* It should be noted that almost every state voluntarily complies with
the Seventh Amendment’s requirement of jury trials.
States retain some ability to restrict individual freedoms.
* Ex: the power of the government to require citizens to wear masks
or submit to vaccinations.
* State governments can take emergency actions so long as they are
not prohibited by the federal or state constitutions.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

The First Amendment

A

The First Amendment
* 5 freedoms: speech, religion, press, assembly, and the right to
petition the government
* –> make the people of the US the freest in the world.
* no “legal age” to exercise your First Amendment freedoms.
* guaranteed to you the day you’re born.
* no citizenship requirement for First Amendment protection.
neither protects against government limits on our freedom of
expression,
* Does NOT prevent a private employer from setting its own
rules.
* prevents government from requiring you to say something you
don’t want to or keeping you from hearing or reading the words
of others
* (even if you never speak out yourself, you have the right to
receive information).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

The First Amendment: Freedom of Religion

A

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion,
or prohibiting the free exercise thereof . . .”
* The establishment clause
* the First Amendment clause that says “Congress shall make no
law respecting an establishment of religion”
* A “wall of separation” exists between church and state
* The free exercise clause
* the First Amendment clause that protects a citizen’s right to
believe and practice whatever religion they choose

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

The Establishment Clause

A

The establishment clause: 3 different interpretations
1. it prevents the government from establishing an official church.
2. government cannot favor one religion over another.
* It is not prohibited from providing funds to religious institutions,
but funding or other assistance cannot show favoritism.
3. must be a “wall of separation” between church and state.
* Disagreement over the height of the wall.
* Many of the founding fathers believed that the spiritual purity and
sanctity of religion would be ruined if it mixed with the worldly
realm of politics.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Religious Freedom

A

The Supreme Court has shifted from a strict wall to a
trend of expanding free expression claims.
* In the early 1960s, the Court ruled that official lead
prayer and bible reading is unconstitutional.
* nondenominational prayer can not be required
* 1992-saying of prayer at a middle school graduation
unconstitutional
* 2014 -government cannot compel a closely-held
business to provide birth control for employees against
the owners’ religious beliefs.
* 2022 – coach may pray on the field

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Free Exercise Clause

A

“Congress shall make no law…..prohibiting the free
exercise thereof (religion)”
* designed to prevent the government from
interfering with the practice of religion.
* This freedom is not absolute.
Several religious practices have been ruled
unconstitutional including:
* snake handling
* use of illegal drugs
* Polygamy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

The First Amendment: Political Speech

A

Political speech is the most consistently protected of all forms
of speech.
* Highly protected by strict scrutiny and legal standards
* Courts must establish “compelling reasons” for limitations
* Protection extends to actions expressing political ideas.
* Examples: financial contributions to causes, protests
* clear and present danger to society vs. Imminent lawless
action
* Speech prohibited when directed at inciting or producing
imminent lawless action/ likely to do so
* Speech protected when speech advocates a viewpoint
without encouraging people to act on it, or when speech
encourages people to act in a way that they could not be
expected to act.
Campaign donations are also seen as political speech.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Student Speech

A

There is conditionally protected speech for high school students in public
schools.
* (1969) USSC –students who came to school wearing black armbands to
protest the Vietnam War.
* School punishment for sexually suggestive speech is permissible.
* The Court has also restricted students’ speech by defining their speech
and journalism as part of their education and not protected like adult
speech.
* (2007)–school could suspend a student, Joseph Frederick, for displaying a
banner that read “Bong Hits 4 Jesus.”
15

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

A Balance: Freedom of Speech & the Press

A

Prior Restraint – a government action that prevents
material from being published.
* USSC Generally rules that press may publish
Symbolic speech–symbols, signs, and other methods of
expression. The Supreme Court has upheld as constitutional a
number of actions including:
* wear armbands to protest the Vietnam War (Tinker v. De
Moines Independent Community School District, 1969).
* flying a communist red flag
* burning the American flag

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

The Second Amendment

A

“A well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state,
the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”
The Second Amendment right to bear arms applies to states and localities.
* Types of arms can be restricted.
* Laws cannot ban the possession of a firearm in a home.
* District of Columbia v. Heller (2008)
* 2nd Am provides a constitutional right to keep a loaded handgun at
home for self-defense.
* States and local governments can regulate firearms.
* This includes waiting periods, registration, types of arms allowed, and
other aspects related to access.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Rights of the Accused: Due Process

A

Due Process of law
* This refers to the right of every individual against arbitrary
action by national or state governments.
* Together, the Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, and Eighth amendments are
the essence of the due process of law.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

The Fourth Amendment: Unlawful Searches and Seizures

A

The Fourth Amendment guarantees the security of citizens against
unreasonable (i.e., improper) searches and seizures.
* Requires search warrants-probable cause
* Allows “Stop and Frisk”-warrant less searches only with
reasonable suspicion
* interpreted the 4th to allow the police to search
* The person arrested
* Things in plain view of the accused
* Places or things that the person could touch or reach, or
which are otherwise in the arrestee’s “immediate control.”
* The exclusionary rule: the ability of courts to exclude illegally
obtained evidence (Mapp v. Ohio, 1961).
Mandatory drug testing also falls under the Fourth Amendment as
does the use of drug-sniffing dogs (requires consent or a warrant).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

The Fifth Amendment

A

Rights in the court
* Right to a grand jury
* determines whether sufficient evidence is available to justify a
trial; they do not rule on the accused’s guilt or innocence.
* “No person shall be …compelled in any criminal case to be a
witness against himself.
* criminals cannot be required to take the stand in a trial.
* Protection against double jeopardy -protects from being tried
twice for the same crime.
* “Miranda rights” and the Miranda rule (Miranda v. Arizona [1966])
* must be informed prior to police interrogation of their rights to
remain silent & benefit of legal counsel.
* Eminent domain
* Government can take private property for public use but must
show a public purpose.
* fair payment.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Miranda Rights

A

right to remain silent, anything you say and do can be used against you in a court of law, right to a lawyer, if you can’t get a lawyer you’ll be given one before being questioned.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

The Sixth Amendment

A

The Sixth Amendment is crucial for running fair trials. It includes:
* The right to a speedy trial
* The right to confront witnesses before an impartial jury
* The right to counsel
* Gideon v. Wainwright (1963): Anyone facing imprisonment
has the right to an attorney, even if they are unable to afford
one (public defender).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

The Eighth Amendment: Cruel and Unusual Punishment, 1 of 2

A

The Eighth Amendment prohibits:
* Excessive bail
* Excessive fines -
* Cruel and unusual punishment
The death penalty is allowed, but it requires due process.
* The states decide whether to allow the death penalty.
* If allowed states determine the method.
USSC HAS limited when/how the death penalty may be used.
* Furman v. GA (1972) – application of the death penalty in GA is cruel & unusual
(all states suspend death penalty for four years)
* 1980’s and 1990’s cases made it harder to overcome bad applications of the
sentence.
* 2000’s saw more restrictions –
* death was too harsh a penalty for the crime of rape of a child.
* prohibition based on IQ and the age of defendant.
Cruel and unusual punishment goes beyond the death penalty.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

The Right to Privacy

A

The right to privacy is the right to be left alone from government
interference in personal areas.
Not explicitly mentioned in the Bill of Rights;
this right has been interpreted as resting in the
* 4th Amendment
* 9th Amendment
* The right to privacy covers matters such as:
* eminent domain (the right of government to take private
property for public use)
* birth control
* Abortion - (Roe v. Wade in 1973 and overturned by Dobbs v. Jackson
in 2022)
* sexual orientation - (Bowers v. Hardwick in 1986 and overturned
by Lawrence v. Texas in 2003)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

federalism

A

a system of government in which power is divided between central government and regional governments

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Unitary system
contrast with federalism in which lower levels of government have little independent power and primarily just implement decisions made by the central government.
26
central element to americas constitution of 1787
federalism, which assigned specific powers to the national government and left others to the states.
27
United states was..
the first nation to adopt federalism at its governing framework by granting expressed powers to the national government and reserving the rest to the states. the original constitution recognized two authorities state and federal
28
most likely to have federalism
diverse ethnic, language, or regional groupings, like switzerland , the US, and canada
29
states give opportunities
citizens to express their preferences, promising to maximize democratic participation, taxing, spending, and policy making powers , policy experimentation and innovation, tailors to policy to local preferences
30
american federalism
state and local governments have even more policy -making responsibilities than in most federal systems. The result is wide variation in policies and a centuries long tug of war between national and state gov
31
intergovernmental relations
the federal structures division of labor across the levels of government -the processes by which those levels of government negotiate and compromise over policy responsibility- one of the most characteristic aspects of American government
32
political ramifications of federalism
age based boundaries that are state dependent, used to advance conservative policy goals, Patriot Act-increased serveillence by the government-department of homeland security, no child left behind- dems also had power to make change obama reveresed nclb and gave the power back to the states
33
fed ramifications
federalism concerns individuals democratic participation and the accountability of government to the people. provide opportunities for ordinary citizens to vote
34
Venue shopping
seeking policy change at a different level of government if stymied at first
35
federalism can demobilize individuals
the overlapping policy responsibilities facilitated by federalism make it difficult for individuals to figure out which government is responsible for the problem that concerns them and they may give up. its hard to make demands when you don't know who's in charge
36
powers of the national gov
the expressed powers granted to the national gov be Article I section 8 of the constitution . collect taxes, coin money, declare war, and regulate commerce. The implied powers that enable congress " to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the foregoing powers. " the supreme court allowed the the implied powers through the necessary and proper clause - national gov power became more broad - supremacy clause " supreme law of the land"
37
powers of state government
tenth amendment- powers of the constitution do not delegate to the national government or prohibit to the states are "reserved to the the states respectively these are the reserved powers amendment
38
concurrent powers
states and the national government share powers to regulate commerce and the economy - where ever there is a direct conflict of laws between the federal and state levels , the issue will most likely be resolved in favor of national supremacy
39
state control
voting rights and process of elections, draw congressional district boundaries, establish voter registration requirements, decide whether absentee voting is allowed, organize the casting and counting of ballots
40
the police power
power of coercion- the power to develop and enforce criminal codes, administer health and safety rules , and regulate family through marriage and divorce laws . regulate livelihoods - private property because of laws also under eminent domain the state may seize property but compensate the owner for their loss
41
states obligation to one another
aimed to make states less independent countries and more unified nation Article IV , section 1, calls for full faith and credit among states , meaning that each state is normally expected to honor the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of the other states.
42
exception to the full faith and credit clause
if one states law is against the strong public policy of another state, that state may not be obligated to recognize it
43
privileges and immunities
Article IV section 2 known as the comity clause seeks to promote national unity. the immunities of one state should be entitled to similar treatment in other states . This has come to mean that a cannot discriminate against someone from another state or give special privileges to its own residents .
44
local government and the constitution
it has no status in the U.S. constitution instead state constitutions define local government structures and responsibilities thus local government is controlled by the state
45
Home rule
the imbalance of power means that state gov could legally dissolve local governments or force multiple governments to consolidate into one. Most states have amended their larger cities a guarantee of noninterference in various areas of local affair
46
How does the U.S constitution establish the authority of the national government and state governments
The U.S. Constitution establishes expresses powers for national government in Article 1 section 8 , and it establishes reserved powers to the states in the tenth amendment
47
How does the distribution of national and state power in a unitary system compare to that of a federal system of government
In a unitary system, the national government holds most policy making authority, and in a federal system, policy making authority is shared among national government and regional or state government
48
federal and state relationship evolution
federal framework is not static , changes as competitions pursue their own interests, The passage discusses how the federal framework of government evolves over time due to competing forces. Initially, states held more power than the federal government, especially in economic and social regulation. Over time, Supreme Court decisions and major events, such as the New Deal in the 1930s, expanded federal authority. However, states have continued to assert their influence in certain policy areas. Crises, such as the 9/11 attacks, the 2008 financial crisis, and the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic, have historically shifted power back to the federal government.
49
What were the responsibilities of local governments (1789–1937)?
Adaptation of state laws to local conditions Public works Contracts for public works Licensing of public accommodation Zoning and other land-use regulation Basic public services
50
What were the main policy areas managed by state governments (1789–1937)?
Property, estate, and inheritance laws Commerce and banking laws Corporate, occupation, profession, and insurance laws Family, morality, public health, and education laws Penal and criminal laws Eminent domain, construction, land use, water, and mineral laws Local government, election, and civil service laws
51
What were the primary domestic policies of the national government (1789–1937)?
Internal improvements Subsidies Tariffs Public land disposal Patents Currency
52
restraining national power with dual federalism
dual federalism historically has meant that states have done most of the fundamental governing . We call this state centered federalism the traditional system because it prevailed for much of american history. Under this system, the national government was quite small and very narrowly specialized in its functions
53
functions of the national government
The functions of the national government in the 19th century were primarily aimed at assisting commerce, such as building roads or protecting domestic industries with tariffs on imported goods. There was little direct coercion of citizens, and the emphasis was on promotion and encouragement, such as providing land or capital needed for economic development. State legislatures were also actively involved in economic regulation, 1 with state laws and court decisions regarding contracts, markets, credit, banking, incorporation, and insurance shaping American capitalism. Until the Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery, property law extended to slavery, and the fugitive slave clause of the Constitution required even "free states" without slavery to return freedom-seeking enslaved people to the states from which they had escaped
54
What were the two main characteristics of the national government's functions in the 19th century?
Primarily aimed at assisting commerce (e.g., building roads, tariffs). Virtually no direct coercion of citizens; emphasis on promotion and encouragement (e.g., providing land or capital).
55
Besides the national government, who else was actively involved in economic regulation during the 19th century?
State legislatures.
56
What areas of economic regulation were state legislatures involved in?
State property and trespass laws, contracts, markets, credit, banking, incorporation, and insurance.
57
How did property law relate to slavery in the 19th century?
Until the 13th Amendment, property law extended to slaves. The Constitution's fugitive slave clause (Article IV, Section 2) required even "free states" to return escaped slaves.
58
What was the significance of the 13th Amendment regarding property law?
It abolished slavery, thus ending the legal concept of slaves as property.
59
Describe the role of government (both national and state) in the American economy during the 19th century.
Both national and state governments played active roles. The national government focused on promoting commerce through assistance and encouragement, while state governments regulated various aspects of the economy through laws and court decisions. Slavery was a key factor influencing property law until the 13th Amendment.
60
What was the Supreme Court's general approach to federal power in the first decades after the Founding?
The Supreme Court made several critical decisions that expanded federal powers, especially when there was conflict between the states and the federal government.
61
What specific impacts did the Supreme Court's early decisions have on the economy?
They removed interstate barriers to trade and laid the groundwork for a national economy.
62
What part of the Constitution did the Supreme Court rely on to expand federal power in these early cases?
Article I, Section 8.
63
What does Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution enumerate?
The powers of Congress, including: the power to tax raise an army declare war establish post offices regulate commerce with foreign nations, among the states, and with Indian tribes.
64
Which specific clause within Article I, Section 8 would later be used to significantly expand federal control over the economy?
The Commerce Clause ("regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian tribes").
65
What was the initial understanding of the scope of the Commerce Clause?
Its scope was initially unclear.
66
How did the Supreme Court influence the development of federal power and the national economy in the early years of the United States?
Through key decisions based on a pro-national interpretation of Article I, Section 8 (particularly the Commerce Clause), the Supreme Court expanded federal power, removed interstate trade barriers, and paved the way for a national economy. The Commerce Clause, though initially vague in scope, became a crucial foundation for future expansion of federal authority over the economy.
67
What was the landmark Supreme Court case that significantly addressed the scope of federal power and the relationship between state and federal law?
McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)
68
What was the central question in McCulloch v. Maryland?
Whether Congress had the power to charter a national bank, considering this power is not explicitly mentioned in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution.
69
How did Chief Justice John Marshall answer the question regarding Congress's power to charter a national bank?
He asserted that the power could be "implied" from other powers expressly granted to Congress, such as the power to regulate commerce.
70
What specific clause of the Constitution did Marshall's decision rest upon?
The Necessary and Proper Clause (Article I, Section 8), which allows Congress to enact laws "necessary and proper" for carrying out its delegated powers.
71
Besides the Necessary and Proper Clause, what other constitutional principle did Marshall invoke in his decision?
The Supremacy Clause, stating that the "Laws of the United States... shall be the supreme Law of the Land," meaning any state law conflicting with federal law is invalid.
72
What was the overall significance of McCulloch v. Maryland for the balance of power between the federal government and state governments?
It affirmed and expanded the implied powers of the federal government (through the Necessary and Proper Clause) and reinforced the supremacy of federal law over state law when there is a conflict.
73
Explain the key holdings and principles established in McCulloch v. Maryland.
In McCulloch v. Maryland, the Supreme Court, under Chief Justice John Marshall, determined that Congress has implied powers beyond those explicitly listed in the Constitution, as long as they are related to enumerated powers. This was based on the Necessary and Proper Clause. The Court also asserted the supremacy of federal law over state law, solidifying the federal government's authority. This case significantly shaped the interpretation of federal power and its relationship with the states.
74
What Supreme Court case further reinforced the nationalist interpretation of the Constitution and solidified federal power over interstate commerce?
Gibbons v. Ogden (1824)
75
What was the specific issue in Gibbons v. Ogden?
Whether New York State could grant a monopoly to Robert Fulton's steamboat company for an exclusive service between New York and New Jersey.
76
What was Chief Justice Marshall's role in Gibbons v. Ogden, and what key question did he address?
He argued that the state lacked the power to grant such a monopoly and had to define "commerce among the several states" as used in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution.
77
How did Marshall define "commerce among the several states"?
He defined it as "comprehensive," extending to "every species of commercial intercourse."
78
What was the limit Marshall placed on the comprehensiveness of "commerce among the several states"?
It was limited "to that commerce which concerns more states than one."
79
What is the significance of Gibbons v. Ogden?
It established the supremacy of the national government in all matters affecting what later came to be called "interstate commerce."  
80
Explain the key holding and principle established in Gibbons v. Ogden.
In Gibbons v. Ogden, the Supreme Court, under Chief Justice Marshall, defined "commerce among the several states" broadly, encompassing all forms of commercial interaction that concern more than one state. This established the federal government's supremacy in regulating interstate commerce, significantly impacting the balance of power between states and the national government.
81
What was the Supreme Court's stance on federal regulation of commerce for 70 years after the Civil War?
It largely sided with business interests, allowing them to benefit from national policies promoting commerce while shielding them from policies regulating commerce that protected consumers and workers.
82
When did this stance change, and what led to the shift?
After 1937. The Supreme Court issued a series of decisions that laid the groundwork for a much stronger federal government.
83
What was the most significant change made by the Supreme Court in this period?
The dramatic expansion of the interpretation of the Commerce Clause.
84
How did the Court's interpretation of the Commerce Clause change?
It abandoned the distinction between interstate and intrastate commerce, converting the clause from a limitation on federal power to a source of broad power for the national government.
85
What kinds of Congressional acts did the Court begin to uphold after this shift?
Acts that: Protected the rights of employees to organize and engage in collective bargaining. Regulated the amount of farmland in cultivation. Extended low-interest credit to small businesses and farmers.   Restricted the activities of corporations dealing in the stock market.  
86
What broader impact did these rulings have on American governance?
They contributed to the construction of the modern safety net of social programs (created in response to the Great Depression) and signaled the end of the era of dual federalism.  
87
What is the significance of the shift in the Supreme Court's view of the Commerce Clause for the balance of power between the federal government and the states?
It gave Congress very broad powers to regulate activity in the states, significantly increasing the federal government's power at the expense of state power.
88
Describe the evolution of the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Commerce Clause and its impact on federal power.
For decades after the Civil War, the Supreme Court used the Commerce Clause to protect business interests from federal regulation. However, a significant shift occurred after 1937. The Court broadened its interpretation of the clause, eliminating the interstate/intrastate distinction and transforming it into a major source of federal power. This allowed for greater federal regulation of the economy and led to the expansion of social programs, fundamentally altering the balance of power between the federal government and the states.
89
What event signaled a new era of federalism in the United States?
The economic crisis of the Great Depression and the government's response to it.
90
Before the Great Depression, who was primarily responsible for assisting people in poverty?
States and localities, usually through private charities.
91
What impact did the Depression have on the capacity of state and local governments to provide aid?
It quickly exhausted their capacities due to the widespread need and severity of the crisis.
92
What was President Herbert Hoover's approach to the federal government's role in alleviating the effects of the Depression?
He maintained that the federal government could do little and that it was a matter for state and local governments to handle.
93
How did Franklin Delano Roosevelt respond to the Depression when he took office in 1933?
He energetically involved the federal government in combating the Depression through a series of programs known as the New Deal.
94
What were the key characteristics of Roosevelt's New Deal programs?
They included temporary relief and work programs, largely financed by the federal government but administered by the states. Additionally, several federal programs were created to provide future economic security.
95
What was the significance of the New Deal for the role of the national government?
It signaled the rise of a more active national government in addressing economic and social issues.
96
Describe the shift in federalism brought about by the Great Depression and the New Deal.
The Great Depression overwhelmed the capacity of state and local governments to provide aid. President Hoover initially resisted federal intervention. However, under President Roosevelt, the federal government took a much more active role through the New Deal, providing relief, work programs, and social security initiatives. This marked a significant shift towards a more active national government and a new era of federalism in the United States.
97
What funding mechanism did the Roosevelt administration programs often utilize to provide aid to states?
Grants-in-aid.
98
What is a grant-in-aid?
Money provided by the federal government to states on the condition that it be spent for a particular purpose defined by Congress.
99
What are some examples of areas where Congress provided grants-in-aid after World War II?
Providing school lunches and building highways.
100
What is the typical matching requirement for grants-in-aid?
Sometimes state or local governments were required to match the national contribution dollar for dollar.
101
What was the matching arrangement for the development of the interstate highway system?
Congressional grants provided 90 percent of the cost, highlighting the significant financial support from the federal government for large-scale projects.
102
What are these types of federal grants-in-aid called, and why?
They are called categorical grants because the national government determines the purposes or categories for which the money can be used.  
103
What is one of the most important and expensive examples of a categorical grant program?
The federal Medicaid program.
104
What does the Medicaid program provide grants for?
To pay for medical care for people in poverty, disabled people, and many nursing home residents.
105
How has the value of categorical grants changed over time?
It has risen dramatically, increasing from $54.8 billion in 1960 to an estimated $1,111 billion in 2022.
106
Explain the concept of cooperative federalism using categorical grants as an example.
Cooperative federalism involves the federal and state governments working together to achieve shared goals. Categorical grants exemplify this by providing federal funds to states for specific, federally-defined purposes, like infrastructure or healthcare (Medicaid). This mechanism allows the federal government to influence state-level policy in desired areas while providing crucial financial support. The significant increase in categorical grant spending over time highlights the growing interdependence and collaboration between levels of government in the U.S. federal system.
107
What kind of federalism did the growth of categorical grants create?
A new kind of federalism, often called cooperative federalism.
108
What is the traditional system of federalism, where the federal government and states have distinct functions, called?
Dual federalism.
109
What term did political scientist Morton Grodzins use to describe the shift from dual to cooperative federalism?
He characterized it as a move from "layer cake federalism" to "marble cake federalism."
110
How does "layer cake federalism" describe dual federalism?
It represents dual federalism because the responsibilities of the national and state governments are clearly separated, like distinct layers of a cake.
111
How does "marble cake federalism" describe cooperative federalism?
It represents cooperative federalism because national, state, and local policies overlap and are intermingled, like the swirls in a marble cake, making it hard to distinguish where one level of government begins and another ends.
112
What is the key characteristic of cooperative federalism?
Intergovernmental cooperation and sharing of responsibilities have blurred the lines between the national, state, and local governments.
113
What is the significance of Figure 3.2 (the image in your prompt)?
It visually illustrates the difference between dual (layer cake) and cooperative (marble cake) federalism, showing the clear separation of powers in the former and the overlapping, integrated powers in the latter.
114
Explain the transition from dual to cooperative federalism and how categorical grants played a role.
Dual federalism, with its distinct separation of federal and state responsibilities, transitioned to cooperative federalism, where collaboration and shared authority are key. This shift is exemplified by the growth of categorical grants, which are federal funds given to states for specific, jointly-defined purposes. The increasing interdependence blurs the lines between governmental levels, moving us from a "layer cake" to a "marble cake" system, as described by Grodzins.
115
While states were important in the new system of grants, what change occurred with some new federal grants, particularly during the War on Poverty in the 1960s?
Some grants bypassed the states and went directly to local governments and even local nonprofit organizations.
116
What was one of the reasons for this shift in grant distribution?
Discriminatory treatment of African Americans in the South.
117
How did the civil rights movement influence this change?
As the movement gained momentum, the southern defense of segregation on the grounds of states' rights reinforced the belief in Washington that states could not be trusted to carry out national purposes fairly and equally.
118
What was the federal government's perspective on state governments in the South regarding civil rights?
The federal government increasingly viewed Southern state governments as untrustworthy in ensuring the fair and just implementation of federal objectives, especially concerning civil rights.
119
Why did the federal government sometimes bypass state governments when distributing grants during the War on Poverty?
The federal government's concern over racial discrimination in the South, particularly regarding segregation, led them to believe that Southern states couldn't be relied upon to administer funds fairly for national programs like the War on Poverty. This distrust led to direct funding of local governments and non-profits to ensure these programs reached and benefited all members of the community, including African Americans.
120
What questions arise when states are given policy responsibilities?
Questions arise about the acceptable extent and areas in which states can differ from one another in their policies.
121
How have Supreme Court decisions typically addressed these questions?
They have generally pushed for greater uniformity across the states.
122
Besides Supreme Court decisions, how else has the national government fostered uniformity across states?
By offering incentives or imposing rules.
123
What new tool did Congress begin to use in the 1970s as it enacted legislation in new areas like environmental policy?
Regulations on states and localities, known as regulated federalism.
124
What is regulated federalism?
A system where the national government sets standards of conduct for the states, often through mandates or conditions attached to funding.
125
When does the federal government sometimes take over areas of regulation from state or local governments?
When state or local standards are less strict or inconsistent with federal ones.
125
What policy areas have become more uniform across states due to regulated federalism?
Environmental protection, social services, and education.
126
What is this federal takeover of regulation called?
Preemption.
127
What areas saw increased federal preemption in the 1970s, requiring states to abide by tougher federal rules?
Air and water pollution, occupational health and safety, and access for disabled people.
128
Explain the concept of regulated federalism and how it impacts state policy.
Regulated federalism is a system where the federal government sets mandates or standards that states must follow, resulting in greater uniformity across states in areas like environmental protection, social services, and education. This often involves federal preemption, where the federal government takes over regulatory areas from states if their standards don't align with federal objectives. This approach contrasts with other methods like incentives, and represents a significant expansion of federal power over state decision-making.
129
Why did regulated industries often oppose preemptions?
Because they increased the cost of doing business.
130
How did the federal government use its preemption power after Republicans took control of Congress in 1994?
To limit the ability of states to tax and regulate industry.
131
What action did the Trump administration take regarding vehicle emissions standards?
It moved to prohibit any state from setting standards different from federal ones, even if stricter, attempting to eliminate California's stricter emissions standards.
132
What was the outcome of the lawsuit brought by California and 22 other states against the Trump administration's action?
The suit was unsuccessful; the court sided with the Trump administration's preemption.
133
What action did the Biden administration take in 2022 regarding vehicle emissions standards?
It restored the rights of states to set their own emission standards, even if these were stricter than federal standards, reversing the Trump-era policy.
134
Describe how the use of federal preemption has shifted in recent decades, particularly concerning environmental regulation.
Regulated industries often opposed federal preemption due to increased costs. After 1994, federal preemption was used to limit state taxation and regulation of industry. Under the Trump administration, preemption was used to prevent states from setting stricter environmental standards, specifically regarding vehicle emissions. This was challenged unsuccessfully in court. However, the Biden administration reversed this policy, allowing states to set stricter standards, showcasing the changing political landscape and its impact on the balance of power between federal and state governments.
135
which of the following statements regarding states' rights is true
since the 1970s states have taken a much more active role in administering large scale programs with the federal government providing states with block grants that have fewer conditions on how the funds should be spent
136
Federalism often gives rise to controversies concerning whether the national government or state governments have authority over various issues . When national-state conflicts have arisen how have these conflicts been resolved
the supreme court has tended to side with the national government , but it can vary depending on the issue
137
What continues regarding the roles of different levels of government (national, state, and local)?
Debates about the appropriate role for each level of government continue.
138
What has happened to intergovernmental tensions?
Intergovernmental tensions have shifted and even increased.
139
What important questions are raised by the significant role of states?
Several questions, including: Might states be sources of experimentation and innovation ("laboratories of democracy")? Which responsibilities are states capable of managing and financing? Does interstate competition enhance or impede efficiency? Who prefers national rather than state control? Do multiple levels of government promote citizen engagement?
140
Who suggested that states could be "laboratories of democracy"?
Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis.
141
What are some key questions to consider about the capabilities of states in the context of federalism?
Their capacity to manage and finance various responsibilities, and whether interstate competition helps or hinders efficiency.
142
What are some key questions to consider about citizen engagement in the context of federalism?
Who prefers national vs. state control, and whether multiple levels of government actually promote citizen engagement.
143
What are the key themes and questions raised about federalism today?
Federalism remains a relevant and debated topic. Questions persist about the appropriate roles of national, state, and local governments, and intergovernmental tensions are present. The role of states as potential "laboratories of democracy" and their capacity to handle various responsibilities are important considerations. The impact of interstate competition and the preferences for national versus state control are also key issues, as is the fundamental question of whether federalism promotes citizen engagement.
144
What is the Tenth Amendment and how has it been used over time?
The Tenth Amendment reserves powers not specifically delegated to the national government to the states. It has been used to bolster the role of states in the federal system, particularly during the 19th century when federal power was more limited.
145
What is nullification?
Nullification is an extreme version of the states' rights position. It claims that states do not have to obey federal laws they believe exceed the national government's constitutional authority.
146
What historical event led to nullification arguments, and who was a key figure in articulating them?
Differences between the North and South over tariffs and slavery led to nullification arguments. John C. Calhoun, a South Carolina senator, was a key figure in articulating these arguments.
147
What was John C. Calhoun's stance on slavery, and how did it influence his political positions?
Calhoun was a slaveowner and white supremacist. His support for the expansion of slavery heavily influenced his political positions.
148
How did the Civil War affect nullification arguments?
Such arguments were voiced less often after the Civil War.
149
How did the Supreme Court use the Tenth Amendment in the 19th century?
The Supreme Court used the Tenth Amendment to strike down laws it believed exceeded national power, including the Civil Rights Act of 1875.
150
What did the Civil Rights Act of 1875 aim to do, and what was its fate?
The Civil Rights Act of 1875 aimed to eliminate discrimination against African Americans in public accommodations and transportation. However, the Supreme Court struck it down.
151
Explain the concept of states' rights and its evolution, including the role of the Tenth Amendment and nullification.
States' rights is the belief that states possess powers independent of the federal government. The Tenth Amendment, reserving undelegated powers to the states, has been central to this argument. Nullification, an extreme version of this doctrine, asserted a state's right to invalidate federal laws it deemed unconstitutional. This idea was prominent before the Civil War, particularly concerning slavery, but diminished afterward. Despite this, the Supreme Court continued to use the Tenth Amendment to limit federal power, even striking down early civil rights legislation.
152
What was the state of federal power by the late 1930s, and how did it affect the Tenth Amendment?
Federal power had expanded significantly, making the Tenth Amendment appear irrelevant.
153
Despite the expansion of federal power, what idea persisted?
The idea that some powers should be reserved to the states.
154
How was the idea of states' rights revived in the 1950s?
Southern opponents of the civil rights movement used it to try to maintain racial segregation.
155
What was the "Southern Manifesto" of 1956?
A declaration by 96 southern members of Congress stating that southern states were not constitutionally bound by Supreme Court decisions outlawing segregation.
156
What impact did the association with racial inequality have on the slogan "states' rights"?
It became tarnished.
157
What happened in the 1990s regarding the Tenth Amendment?
There was a revival of interest in the Tenth Amendment and important Supreme Court decisions limiting federal power.
158
159
What was the motivation behind this revival of interest in the Tenth Amendment in the 1990s?
Conservatives, believing the federal government encroached on individual liberties, favored returning more power to the states (devolution).
160
What was the significance of the Supreme Court case United States v. Lopez (1995)?
It was the first time since the New Deal that the Court limited congressional power under the commerce clause, striking down a federal law that barred handguns near schools.
161
Describe the evolution of the Tenth Amendment's relevance and the concept of states' rights from the 1930s to the 1990s.
Despite the Tenth Amendment seeming irrelevant due to federal power expansion by the late 1930s, the idea of states' rights persisted. It was revived in the 1950s by segregationists but became tarnished. In the 1990s, conservatives, concerned about federal overreach, led to a renewed interest in the Tenth Amendment and Supreme Court decisions limiting federal power, as seen in United States v. Lopez. This case marked a significant moment where the Court reined in Congress's use of the commerce clause, signaling a potential shift towards empowering states.
162
What is devolution?
Devolution is the transfer of responsibility for policy from the federal government to states and localities.
163
What are the arguments made by proponents of devolution?
They argue that: States are potential innovators and experimenters ("laboratories of democracy"). Governments closer to the people can better tailor policies to local needs.
164
What is a block grant?
A block grant is federal funding that states have considerable leeway in spending.
165
Who led the first major push for block grants, and when?
President Nixon in the early 1970s, as part of his New Federalism initiative.
166
What areas were programs consolidated into three large block grants under Nixon?
Job training, community development, and social services.
167
What new form of federal assistance to state and local governments did Congress provide, alongside block grants?
General revenue sharing, which had no strings attached and allowed recipients to spend the money as they wished.
168
What was President Reagan's approach to block grants in the 1980s?
Like Nixon, he used them to reduce the national government's control and return power to the states. However, unlike Nixon, he also used them to cut federal spending.
169
What was the key difference in the use of block grants between Nixon and Reagan?
Nixon used them for consolidating programs and providing flexibility, while Reagan primarily used them as a tool for budget cuts.
170
Explain the concept of devolution and how block grants fit into this approach.
Devolution is the process of shifting power from the federal government to state and local governments. Block grants are a key mechanism in this process, providing federal funds to states with few strings attached, allowing states to tailor spending to their specific needs. This approach is supported by arguments that states can be more innovative and responsive to local needs than the federal government. While Nixon initiated the modern use of block grants, Reagan expanded their use, particularly as a tool for reducing federal spending.
171
Who led the first push for block grants?
President Nixon.
172
When did Nixon push for block grants?
The early 1970s.
173
What was Nixon's initiative called?
New Federalism.
174
What areas were consolidated into block grants under Nixon?
Job training, community development, and social services.
175
What other form of federal assistance was provided?
General revenue sharing.
176
What was special about general revenue sharing?
It had no strings attached.
177
What did Reagan use block grants for?
To reduce national government control and return power to the states, and to cut federal spending.
178
How did Reagan's use of block grants differ from Nixon's?
Reagan used them to cut federal spending as well as shift power to the states, while Nixon focused on consolidating programs and flexibility.
179
What state health care reform became a template for the Affordable Care Act?
Massachusetts' health care reform of 2006.
180
What are unfunded mandates?
Requirements on states imposed by the national government without accompanying funding.
181
What is an example of an unfunded mandate?
A 1973 federal law prohibiting discrimination against disabled people, requiring accessible public transit but providing no funding for it.
182
What concerns exist regarding state responsibility in policy?
Variation in policy outcomes and questions of who benefits or suffers from government action or inaction.
183
What major change did Congress enact regarding welfare in 1996?
Welfare reform that changed it from a combined federal-state program into a block grant, giving states more responsibility.
184
What did supporters hope to achieve with welfare reform?
Reduce welfare spending and allow states to experiment with different approaches.
185
What approach did Minnesota adopt for welfare?
An incentive-based approach offering extra assistance to families that take low-wage jobs.
186
What approach did six other states adopt for welfare?
Very strict time limits on receiving benefits, shorter than the federal five-year lifetime limit.
187
What is the shortest lifetime limit for welfare benefits mentioned in the text?
12 months in Arizona.
188
Explain how states can act as policy innovators but also how concerns arise regarding unfunded mandates and policy variations.
States can be sources of policy innovation, as seen with Massachusetts' health care reform inspiring "Obamacare." However, unfunded mandates, like requiring accessible transit without providing funding, pose challenges. Additionally, shifting responsibility to states, as with welfare reform, leads to variations in policy outcomes. While some see this as an opportunity for experimentation, others worry about disparities and the impact on vulnerable populations, highlighting the complexities and trade-offs inherent in federalism.
189
What is an unfunded mandate?
A requirement placed on states by the federal government without providing the necessary funds for implementation.
190
Give an example of an unfunded mandate.
A federal law requiring accessible public transit without providing funding for the necessary modifications.
191
What is a potential concern with giving states more responsibility for policy?
Variation in policy outcomes across different states.
192
What is a block grant?
Federal funding given to states with flexibility in how it is spent within a general area.
193
What happened to welfare programs in 1996?
They were changed from a combined federal-state program to a block grant system, giving states more control.
193
What were the hopes of those who supported welfare reform?
Reduced welfare spending and increased state experimentation with different approaches.
194
Describe Minnesota's approach to welfare.
It offers incentives, like extra assistance, to families taking low-wage jobs.
195
What did six other states do regarding welfare time limits?
They imposed stricter time limits than the federal five-year guideline.
196
What is the shortest welfare lifetime limit mentioned in the text?
12 months (in Arizona).
197
Under the Obama administration, what happened to many of the undocumented immigrants being detained?
Many had not committed a crime.
198
When did the Obama administration soften its deportation policy?
2011
199
What program did the Obama administration end in 2014?
The Secure Communities program.
200
When did the Obama administration replace the Secure Communities program, and with what?
2015, with a program containing a more limited deportation policy.
201
What did the individual who campaigned on promises for more rigorous immigration enforcement do shortly after their inauguration?
Signed an executive order restarting Secure Communities and expanding the types of immigrants considered a priority for deportation.
202
How did the categories of immigrants prioritized for deportation change?
They expanded from those convicted of felonies or multiple misdemeanors to also include those accused or convicted of minor crimes.
203
What was the response of a growing number of cities, counties, and states to the changes in immigration enforcement?
They declared themselves "sanctuaries" that limit their cooperation with federal enforcement of immigration law.
204
What did the individual pledge to do regarding federal grants to sanctuary jurisdictions?
Withhold them.
205
What prevented the withholding of federal grants initially?
A federal judge's ruling.
206
What did a federal appeals court rule in 2019?
That the administration did have authority to withhold Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) grants from sanctuary cities.
207
What did President Biden promise regarding immigration policies?
A thorough overhaul.
208
What has President Biden done regarding some policies from a previous administration?
Ended several of them.
209
What are some major categories of federal grants to state and local governments in 2022 (estimated)?
Health, Income Security, Transportation, Education, and Other.
210
What was the estimated total federal grants to state and local governments in 2022?
$1.229 trillion.
211
How have federal outlays for grants to state and local governments changed from 1960 to 2022?
They have grown significantly, from $68.2 billion in 1960 to $1.229 trillion in 2022.
212
What is a common misconception Americans have about federal taxes?
That they pay a lot in federal taxes but don't receive much in return.
213
What do Americans receive in return for federal taxes?
Federal money for state and local programs.
214
What is included in the broad category of federal spending?
Grants to state and local governments, spending on military bases, and federal procurement.
215
Do all states receive the same amount from the federal government?
No, the amount varies per state.
216
What does the map show regarding federal spending and taxes?
How much federal spending each state received for each dollar paid in federal taxes in 2019.
217
What is the highest category of federal spending per tax dollar shown on the map?
$2.00+
218
What does the text imply about the relationship between federal taxes paid and federal spending received by states?
That it's not directly proportional; some states receive more in federal spending than they pay in federal taxes, while others receive less.
219
Summarize the key points about federal grants to state and local governments.
Federal grants to state and local governments have significantly increased over the past decades. These grants cover various categories like health, income security, transportation, and education. Despite common misconceptions, Americans benefit from these grants, which fund state and local programs. However, the amount of federal spending received by each state varies, with some receiving more than they contribute in federal taxes.
220
What has been the stance of the courts regarding federal authority over marijuana policy?
Federal authority has been upheld.
221
What happened in 2005 regarding medical marijuana?
The Supreme Court upheld the right of Congress to ban medical marijuana, even though 11 states had legalized it.
222
What constitutional clause did the Court cite in upholding the federal ban on medical marijuana?
The commerce clause.
223
By 2022, how many states and the District of Columbia had legalized medical marijuana?
37 states and the District of Columbia.
224
Besides medical marijuana, what else had several states legalized by 2022?
Recreational use of marijuana.
225
What is the consequence of the mismatch between federal and state marijuana laws?
Federal raids on marijuana dispensaries and growers, even in states where it is legal.
226
Describe the conflict between federal and state laws regarding marijuana.
Despite many states legalizing medical and/or recreational marijuana, federal law still prohibits it. The Supreme Court has upheld the federal government's authority to regulate marijuana use under the commerce clause. This conflict has led to federal actions against marijuana businesses operating legally under state laws.
227
According to the text, what is the federal status of buying, selling, and possessing marijuana?
It remains a federal crime.
228
What action have states taken regarding marijuana policies?
States have adopted policies that conflict with federal laws.
229
What are the three categories of state marijuana laws depicted in the map?
Marijuana legalized for recreational and medical use. Marijuana legalized only for medical use. No broad laws legalizing marijuana.
230
What is the central question posed in the text regarding conflicting federal and state marijuana policies?
"Should this be allowed?" (referring to the conflict between state and federal laws).
230
What does Figure 3.3 illustrate about the challenges of federalism in the context of marijuana policy?
It highlights the tension between state and federal authority. While marijuana remains federally illegal, many states have chosen to legalize it in some form, creating a conflict that raises questions about states' rights, federal supremacy, and the role of public opinion in policy-making.
231
What Supreme Court decision overturned Roe v. Wade?
Dobbs v. Jackson (2022)
232
What did the Dobbs decision do regarding abortion rights?
It did not outlaw abortion federally but left individual states free to restrict (or not restrict) abortion as they saw fit.
233
What was the immediate impact of the Dobbs decision on state laws?
13 states enacted nearly total bans on abortion and 5 imposed significant restrictions.
234
In how many states did abortion remain fully legal after the Dobbs decision?
12 states.
235
In how many states was abortion legal but with some limitations after the Dobbs decision?
9 states
236
What other actions did states take regarding abortion after the Dobbs decision?
In several states, constitutional amendments were proposed either guaranteeing abortion rights or restricting abortions.
237
What potential conflicts does the patchwork of state abortion policies create?
Conflicts between the federal government and the states, and conflicts between states that permit abortion and those that prohibit it.
238
What actions have Democrats proposed at the federal level regarding abortion rights?
Legislation that would establish a federal guarantee of abortion rights.
239
What actions have some Republicans proposed at the federal level regarding abortion rights?
Federal legislation that would severely restrict abortion rights.
240
What is an example of potential conflict between states regarding abortion?
Legislation introduced in Missouri (a state that has outlawed abortion) that would penalize Missouri residents who obtain abortions in other states.
241
Summarize the legal landscape of abortion in the US after the Dobbs v. Jackson decision.
The Dobbs decision overturned Roe v. Wade, leaving abortion legality up to individual states. This resulted in a patchwork of state laws, with some states enacting near-total bans, others imposing significant restrictions, and others maintaining legal abortion. This has led to potential conflicts between states and the federal government, as well as between states themselves, particularly regarding cross-state access to abortion. Furthermore, efforts have been made to codify abortion rights or restrictions through federal legislation and state constitutional amendments.
242
What is a potential area of conflict between states regarding abortion?
States that permit abortion and those that prohibit it.
243
What action was proposed in Missouri regarding out-of-state abortions?
Legislation was introduced that would penalize state residents who traveled outside the state to obtain an abortion.
244
What constitutional clause might such legislation violate?
The Constitution's full faith and credit clause.
245
What established right might such legislation violate?
The long-established right of Americans to travel from state to state.
246
Is there precedent for states enforcing laws beyond their boundaries?
Yes, there are precedents (e.g., Skiriotes v. Florida).
247
What could become a major area of conflict in the federal system?
The question of out-of-state abortions.
248
Explain the potential legal conflicts related to states prohibiting their residents from traveling to other states for abortions.
States that ban abortions may attempt to penalize residents who travel to other states for the procedure. This raises legal questions regarding the Constitution's full faith and credit clause and the right to interstate travel. While there's legal precedent for states enforcing laws beyond their borders, the issue of out-of-state abortions has the potential to become a significant point of contention within the federal system, testing the balance of power and individual rights.
249
What did the Charlotte City Council ordinance prohibit?
Sex discrimination in public facilities
250
What allowed the North Carolina legislature to pass the "Charlotte bathroom bill"?
State preemption.
251
What did the "Charlotte bathroom bill" do?
It undid the provisions originally set out by the Charlotte City Council's ordinance.
252
What is state preemption?
A doctrine that allows a higher level of government to limit or even eliminate the power of a lower level of government to regulate a specific issue. In this case, the state government overriding a local (city) ordinance.  
253
What does the "Charlotte bathroom bill" example illustrate about the relationship between state and local governments?
: It demonstrates the power of state governments over local governments. Even if a city passes an ordinance, the state legislature can use its power of preemption to overturn that local law, highlighting the hierarchical nature of government power within a state.
254
What is a notable trend in the recent politics of federalism regarding state governments and local policy?
State governments are increasingly willing to preempt local policy.
255
What is an example of cities making policy in areas where states haven't or where city preferences differ from state preferences?
Cities setting higher minimum wages, requiring paid sick leave, regulating the "sharing economy," prohibiting gender-based discrimination in public facilities, and attempting to establish public broadband services.
256
What is one of the most contentious areas in the relationship between state and local governments today?
Regulation of firearms.
257
What have many states done regarding local ordinances restricting firearm ownership?
Enacted laws preempting them.
258
Which six states recently repealed their preemption laws concerning firearm regulation?
Colorado, New York, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Hawaii.
259
What did the repeal of preemption laws in those six states allow for?
Stricter local gun control ordinances.
260
What does this text illustrate about the balance of power between state and local governments, and how is it similar to the balance between federal and state governments?
Just as states assert power over the federal government, they also assert power over local governments through preemption. This creates tension and highlights the ongoing negotiation of power in a federal system. The ability of some cities to push back and influence state-level decisions, as seen with the repeal of preemption laws in some states, shows that the balance of power is dynamic and responsive to local pressures.
261
What action have some state legislatures taken regarding local laws or authority?
Responded with laws preempting (limiting or prohibiting) them.
262
As of 2019, how many states preempt local minimum-wage ordinances?
25 states.
263
How many states prohibit local paid-leave ordinances?
23 states
264
How many states limit local authority to regulate ride-sharing?
44 states
265
How many states ban local regulation of e-cigarettes?
10
266
What specific ban does Michigan have regarding local ordinances?
Bans cities from banning plastic bags.
267
What specific ban does Texas have regarding local ordinances?
Bans them from banning fracking.
268
How many states prohibit localities from establishing municipal broadband service?
20
269
Which state famously preempts local antidiscrimination ordinances?
North Carolina
270
What is the overall trend described in this text regarding state versus local power?
The trend is towards state legislatures increasingly using their power to preempt local control over a wide range of issues, from wages and leave policies to environmental regulations and social policies. This highlights the tension between state and local authority and the power of states to standardize or limit local policies.
271
What are civil rights?
Civil rights are obligations of the government to guarantee equal citizenship and protect individuals from discrimination by government officials or individuals.
272
What do civil rights include?
Civil rights include the right to vote, attend desegregated schools, and for people with disabilities to be free from discrimination.
273
How do civil rights differ from civil liberties?
Civil liberties prevent government action, while civil rights require government action to ensure equal citizenship.
274
What is the focus of civil rights law?
Granting equal rights of citizenship to members of groups who have historically faced discrimination.
275
What are some key dimensions of civil rights?
Citizenship, race, gender, religion, ethnicity, disabilities, LGBTQ rights, voting, criminal justice, education, marriage, housing, healthcare, and employment.
276
What are the Civil War Amendments, and what did they establish?
13th Amendment: Abolished slavery. 14th Amendment: Guaranteed equal protection and due process. 15th Amendment: Granted voting rights to African American men.
277
What was the significance of the Emancipation Proclamation?
Issued by President Lincoln in 1863, it declared the freedom of slaves in Confederate states, but compliance required the Confederate army's surrender.
278
What did the 14th Amendment establish regarding citizenship?
It redefined citizenship, ending the 3/5 compromise, and established the Equal Protection Clause.
279
What is the Equal Protection Clause?
“No State shall make or enforce any law which shall … deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.”
280
How did the 14th Amendment become a vehicle for civil rights?
Although not used immediately, nearly 100 years later it was interpreted to create societal equality and protect disadvantaged groups.
281
What were key court cases and laws regarding voting rights?
Smith v. Allwright (1944): Ended white primaries. 24th Amendment: Eliminated poll taxes in federal elections. Harper v. Virginia Board of Elections (1966): Banned all poll taxes. Voting Rights Act of 1965: Removed barriers to voting for minorities.
282
What was the impact of the Shelby v. Holder (2013) decision?
It substantially weakened the Voting Rights Act of 1965, leading to a decline in minority voting participation.
283
hy have civil rights been a source of conflict in the U.S.?
The struggle for equal rights has often been met with resistance from privileged groups reluctant to give up their advantages.
284
What are some amendments to know regarding civil rights?
13th, 14th, 15th, 19th, 24th, and 26th Amendments.
285
What is the relationship between civil rights and the expansion of government power?
Civil rights often require an expansion of government power to take positive action, such as desegregating public schools and enforcing anti-discrimination laws.
286
Why was the Bill of Rights added to the Constitution?
Federalists initially argued it was unnecessary, but Antifederalists demanded it to protect individual rights.
287
When were the first ten amendments ratified?
December 15, 1791.
288
What are civil liberties?
Personal rights and freedoms the government cannot abridge.
289
Give three examples of civil liberties.
Freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and freedom of religion.
290
What did the Supreme Court rule in 1833 regarding the Bill of Rights?
It applied only to the national government.
291
What is incorporation?
The process of applying the Bill of Rights to states through the Fourteenth Amendment.
292
Which amendments are not incorporated?
The Third and Seventh Amendments.
293
What five freedoms does the First Amendment guarantee?
Speech, religion, press, assembly, and petition.
294
Can private employers limit First Amendment rights?
Yes, it only restricts government action.
295
What does the Establishment Clause state?
The government cannot establish an official religion.
296
What does the Free Exercise Clause guarantee?
The right to practice any religion, with some legal limitations.
297
What type of speech is most protected?
Political speech.
298
What is "clear and present danger"?
Speech can be restricted if it incites immediate illegal action.
299
Are campaign donations considered free speech?
Yes.
300
Can schools limit student speech?
Yes, especially if it disrupts education or is inappropriate.
301
What was the ruling in "Bong Hits 4 Jesus"?
Schools can discipline students for speech promoting illegal drug use.
302
What is prior restraint?
Government action preventing material from being published.
303
Is symbolic speech protected?
Yes, including flag burning and wearing armbands.
304
What does the Second Amendment protect?
The right to keep and bear arms.
305
Can states regulate gun ownership?
Yes, through waiting periods, registration, and firearm restrictions.
306
What was the ruling in District of Columbia v. Heller (2008)?
Individuals have the right to own firearms for self-defense at home.
307
What is the exclusionary rule?
Illegally obtained evidence cannot be used in court (Mapp v. Ohio).
307
What amendments protect due process rights?
The Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, and Eighth Amendments.
308
What is double jeopardy?
Being tried twice for the same crime.
309
What are Miranda Rights?
The right to remain silent and have legal counsel (Miranda v. Arizona).
310
What is eminent domain?
The government's right to take private property for public use with compensation.
311
What does the Sixth Amendment guarantee?
The right to a speedy trial, an impartial jury, and legal counsel.
312
What was the ruling in Gideon v. Wainwright (1963)?
Defendants have a right to an attorney, even if they can't afford one.
313
What does the Eighth Amendment prohibit?
Excessive bail, excessive fines, and cruel and unusual punishment.
314
Can states decide on the death penalty?
Yes, but due process must be followed.
315
Is the right to privacy explicitly mentioned in the Constitution?
No, but it is inferred from the Fourth and Ninth Amendments.
316
What are key privacy cases?
Roe v. Wade (abortion rights, overturned in Dobbs v. Jackson), Lawrence v. Texas (sexual orientation rights).
317
What is federalism?
A system of government where power is divided between a central government and regional governments.
318
How does federalism differ from a unitary system?
In a unitary system, lower levels of government have little independent power, while in federalism, power is shared between national and regional governments.
319
What are expressed powers?
Powers specifically granted to the national government by the Constitution.
320
What are implied powers?
Powers derived from the necessary and proper clause, allowing the federal government to assume more authority over time.
321
What are reserved powers?
Powers given to the states through the Tenth Amendment, including regulating health, safety, welfare, and morals.
322
What are concurrent powers?
Powers shared by both the national and state governments, such as levying taxes.
322
What is police power?
A state's authority to regulate health, safety, welfare, and morals.
323
What is the full faith and credit clause?
A constitutional requirement that states must honor the public acts, records, and judicial decisions of other states.
324
What is the privileges and immunities clause?
A constitutional provision preventing states from discriminating against citizens of other states.
325
What role does local government play in the Constitution?
Local governments have no status in the U.S. Constitution; they are created by state legislatures.
326
What is home rule?
A provision in state constitutions granting cities a degree of self-governance.
327
What was the traditional system of federalism?
Dual federalism, where states performed most governing responsibilities.
328
How did the commerce clause impact federalism?
Initially limited federal power, but later Supreme Court decisions expanded federal authority.
329
What was the significance of McCulloch v. Maryland and Gibbons v. Ogden?
These cases expanded the power of the federal government through interpretations of the Constitution.
330
How did the New Deal affect federalism?
Expanded federal government power through programs and grants-in-aid.
331
What are grants-in-aid?
Federal funds provided to state and local governments for specific purposes.
332
What are categorical grants?
Federal funds given to states with strict limitations on how they can be used.
333
What is cooperative federalism?
A system where the national and state governments work together to achieve policy goals.
334
What is regulated federalism?
A system where the federal government imposes regulations on states, sometimes without funding.
335
What is preemption?
The national government’s ability to override state and local policies.
336
What is devolution?
Transferring responsibility for programs from the federal government to the states.
337
What are block grants?
Federal funds given to states with fewer restrictions on their use.
338
What are unfunded mandates?
Federal requirements imposed on states without accompanying funding.
339
What are some modern challenges of federalism?
Differences in state policies on issues like immigration and marijuana legalization.
340
How has the Supreme Court influenced federalism in recent years?
By issuing decisions that limit federal power and return authority to the states.
341
What are civil rights?
Civil rights are guarantees of equal opportunity and protection for all citizens through obligations imposed on government power.
342
How are civil rights achieved?
Primarily through social movements that enable individuals to engage in collective action.
343
What amendment established civil rights protections in the Constitution?
The Fourteenth Amendment (1868) through the "equal protection of the laws" clause.
344
What role does the equal protection clause play in civil rights?
It provides a legal foundation for challenging discriminatory practices and laws.
345
What are the three levels of judicial scrutiny? Back:
Rational Basis (Lowest) – Government must show a rational reason for discrimination. Intermediate Scrutiny – Applied mainly in gender discrimination cases. Strict Scrutiny (Highest) – Applied in cases involving race and fundamental rights, requiring a compelling government interest.
346
How did enslaved people resist their treatment?
Through methods such as: Destroying tools Slowing down work Organizing open revolts
347
When did the abolitionist movement gain traction?
In the 1830s, with White Northerners using speeches and antislavery literature to sway public opinion.
348
What did Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) establish?
The “separate but equal” doctrine, allowing racial segregation as long as facilities were deemed equal.
348
What was the significance of Dred Scott v. Sanford (1857)?
It ruled that: Enslaved people and all Black individuals were not U.S. citizens. The federal government could not regulate slavery in territories.
349
What were Jim Crow laws?
Laws enacted by Southern states after Reconstruction that enforced racial segregation, such as: Banning interracial marriage Segregating public facilities and schools
350
What strategy did the NAACP use to fight for civil rights?
Political pressure and litigation to challenge discriminatory laws in court.
351
What three constitutional amendments were passed after the Civil War?
Thirteenth Amendment (1865): Abolished slavery. Fourteenth Amendment (1868): Guaranteed equal protection under the law. Fifteenth Amendment (1870): Guaranteed voting rights for African Americans.
352
How did Brown v. Board of Education (1954) impact segregation?
It ruled that racial segregation in public schools was unconstitutional, overturning Plessy v. Ferguson.
353
What was the immediate reaction to Brown v. Board of Education?
Massive resistance in the South, where even 10 years later, less than 1% of Black children attended integrated schools.
354
How did Brown v. Board of Education change constitutional law?
It established that racial discrimination violates the Constitution and strengthened strict scrutiny in discrimination cases.
355
What did Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 accomplish?
It outlawed job discrimination for employers with more than 15 workers, including private businesses and government agencies.
356
How did the Voting Rights Act of 1965 strengthen voting protections?
Banned literacy tests and discriminatory voting barriers. Increased minority political participation, reshaping American politics.
357
What are the two types of segregation?
De jure segregation – Legally enforced (e.g., Jim Crow laws). De facto segregation – Occurs through social or economic factors (e.g., modern school segregation).
358
What other groups benefited from African American civil rights protections?
Women, Latinos, Asian Americans, Native Americans, disabled individuals, and LGBTQ+ people.
359
When was the women's suffrage movement formally launched?
1878, with the introduction of a constitutional amendment for women's voting rights.
360
What did the Nineteenth Amendment do?
It granted women the right to vote in 1920.
361
How did gender discrimination become a major civil rights issue?
In the 1970s, the Supreme Court: Refused to equate gender discrimination with racial discrimination. Applied intermediate scrutiny to gender discrimination cases.
362
What were the two main Latino civil rights strategies?
Ethnic-group political mobilization (voter registration, ethnic voting). Legal action (civil rights laws for fair access).
363
How did Asian Americans face discrimination in the early 20th century?
Citizenship and immigration restrictions. Japanese American internment during World War II.
364
What did the Civil Liberties Act of 1988 accomplish?
Provided a formal apology and monetary reparations to Japanese Americans interned during World War II.
365
How did Native American rights evolve in the 20th century?
1924: Congress granted U.S. citizenship to Native Americans. Reservation sovereignty became a foundation for further rights expansion.
366
What did the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990 achieve?
It guaranteed: Equal employment rights. Access to public businesses for disabled individuals.
367
What was the impact of Romer v. Evans (1996)?
It extended fundamental civil rights protections to gays and lesbians.
368
What did Lawrence v. Texas (2003) rule?
It struck down a Texas law criminalizing same-sex intimate conduct.
369
What was the significance of Obergefell v. Hodges (2015)?
It ruled that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry in all states.
370
What is affirmative action?
A policy designed to address past discrimination by providing opportunities to historically marginalized groups.
371
Why is affirmative action controversial?
Opponents argue it creates group-based quotas. Proponents argue it compensates for systemic discrimination.
372
How have immigration issues affected civil rights?
Discrimination against legal immigrants continues. Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA): Protects undocumented immigrants brought as children.
373
What civil rights issues arose after 9/11?
Increased Islamophobia and profiling of Arab, Middle Eastern, and Muslim Americans.
374
What led to the rise of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement?
Claims of systemic racism in the criminal justice system. 2020 protests after George Floyd's death highlighted ongoing racial inequality.
375
How will civil rights movements continue evolving?
Activists will use past and new strategies to address modern racial and social justice issues.