Exam 2 Flashcards
phenotypic plasticity
single genotype can lead to multiple different phenotypes depending on the environment
developmental plasticity
fixed, often irreversible, happens during early development
acute plasticity
short term, reversible
genotype norm of reaction
a curve that relates the contribution of environmental variation to observed phenotypic variation
three types of phenotypic distribution
continuous variation, polymorphism/polyphenism, canalization
polymorphism/polyphenism
discontinuous genetic variation resulting in the occurrence of several different forms or types of individuals among the members of a single species. opposite of genetic fixation
canalization
fixed trait, same phenotype regardless of environmental variation
four major types of phenotypic plasticity
shifts in phenology, acclimation/acclimatization, polyphenism, transgenerational plasticity
phenology
timing of life history events, such as flowering time or clutch laying
acclimation
physical adjustment to a controlled change in one specific environmental variable, occurs in a lab
acclimatization
physical adjustment to changes in multiple environmental variables in nature
transgenerational plasticity
initiated in past generations, but has consequences in current and future generations, such as maternal effects and epigenetic inheritance. Often genetic, but driven by environmental effects
maternal effects
phenotype of the offspring is influenced by the environment experienced by the mother (and thus her phenotype)
proximate drivers of phenotypic plasticity
gene expression and allelic sensitivity
gene expression (relative to phenotypic plasticity)
upregulation or downregulation by transcription factors of specific genes in response to environmental stimuli, often through the action of regulatory genes
can influence allelic sensitivity, and can be heritable
allelic sensitivity
the downstream product (protein or messenger RNA) of a particular allele responds directly to environmental stimuli. For example: in response to an environmental change, a protein changes its binding site to no longer allow binding
Not as important as gene expression. Allelic sensitivity is rare because homeostasis is good.
why aren’t all traits plastic?
plasticity has costs
3 costs of phenotypic plasticity
It costs energy to synthesize new proteins, to break down those proteins when they are not needed, and to maintain the cellular machinery that detects environmental stimuli.
Trade-offs whereby plasticity in a particular trait increases survival but reduces fecundity, or vice versa
The plastic response might “misfire” in response to the wrong environmental cue.
under what conditions should developmental plasticity be expected?
non-mobile organisms, environmental variation that is high, predictable, and occurs within the lifespan of the organism
under what conditions should acute plasticity be expected?
unpredictable changes and stable environments
climatic variability hypothesis
thermal tolerance (climate niche) correlates with latitude
is behavior considered plasticity?
we don’t know
behavioral drive
Behavioral flexibility leads to the exploitation of new niches and faster evolutionary diversification
behavioral inertia
Behavioral flexibility causes individuals to track their niche and “hide” from selection, reducing evolutionary diversification. Example: behavioral thermoregulation - changing micro-environment (dark rocks, shade, etc.)
how to determine if behavioral inertia?
track ancestral niche
three ways plasticity enhances or reduces evolution?
- Plasticity can reduce rates of genetic change through a process analogous to behavioral inertia
- Plasticity can (indirectly) enhance rates of genetic change by reducing mortality and increasing population sizes—leading to a greater chance for beneficial mutations to arise
- Plasticity can enhance genetic change by exposing cryptic genetic variation that is then acted on by selection via the processes of genetic accommodation and genetic assimilation
genetic accommodation
Any adaptive change in the environmental
regulation of a phenotype, can be positive or negative
genetic assimilation
The complete loss of plasticity through genetic canalization, is a subtype of genetic accommodation
An organism evolves extreme behavioral flexibility to deal with a variable and unpredictable environment. Is that organism now more or less likely to evolve other forms of plasticity such as high acclimation capacity?
less likely, because it would be very costly for an organism to have both extreme behavioral flexibility AND high acclimation capacity, especially considering they really only need one or the other. Behavioral flexibility would allow the organism to avoid the stresses of the environmental changes (example, by relocating to a different microclimate, or exploiting a new niche entirely) while high acclimation capacity would allow the organism to adapt to the environmental changes without avoiding it. It cannot use both strategies at the same time, so it would not be worth the cost of maintaining both.
Can genetic assimilation occur with standing genetic variation only or does the process require new mutations?
genetic assimilation can occur with standing genetic variation, the trait already exists, even though it arises by plasticity in response to the environment. Assimilation just fixes it, so it is no longer plastic.
Under what conditions would you expect plasticity to be non-adaptive?
more likely to be non-adaptive in novel environmental stress, such as environmental conditions that are outside of the range of environments they have experienced before and impose a particular challenge to the organism’s homeostasis. Anthropogenic contaminants, such as herbicides, are novel stressors that are not present in the evolutionary history of most species.
cryptic genetic variation
build up of genes expressed in new environment, giving rise to novel phenotypes, which selection can then act on
how might plastic responses to environmental variation influence the process of natural selection?
reduce: genotype can “hide” under plastic phenotypes
enhance: indirectly, more individuals to act on
enhance: cryptic genetic variation arising in new environments leads to new phenotypes
enhance: genetic assimilation/canalization
role of plasticity in macroevolution?
genetic assimilation leads to reproductive isolation leads to speciation or adaptive radiation, especially if canalized trait has anything to do with mating choice, habitat choice, or reproduction
how might plasticity influence genetic variation, genetic architecture, and molecular evolution?
genetic variation: plasticity can both decrease (hide genes) and increase genetic variation (cryptic genetic variation)
genetic architecture: plasticity can influence the expression of the gene itself or the regulators of the gene
molecular evolution: when loci don’t affect the trait until its in a novel environment, then it affects the phenotype, leading to a relaxation of selection, allowing mutations to accumulate, can end up with a surprise product
*do we need a theory of forms?
?
describe the guppy experiment
field experiment to manipulate agents of selection, guppies with predators in lower elevation, guppies without predators in higher elevation, showed phenotypic differences such as color, fin size, behavior (shyness, schooling), life history (growth rate, clutch size). Reciprocal transplants were done and trait evolution was tracked
describe anole experiments
introduced brown anoles on islands, and curly-tailed lizards to half of the islands, which influenced their behavior (more shy) and eventually limb length (shorter)
anoles on islands with different vegetation in Panama Canal, limb length in offspring evolved in one generation (some plasticity, but mostly evolutionary change), showing rapid evolution - also an example of behavioral drive
scientist who explored link between genotype and environment, experimented on field mice
Hopi Hoekstra
if evolution can be this rapid, what are the implications?
speciation can occur more quickly, macro and micro-evolution should not be considered so separate, climate change and conservation (evolution is relevant to conservation)
eco-evolutionary dynamics
how ecology and evolution influence each other, and are tightly linked on time scales, heritable variation among individuals in a population can be as or more important than traditional ecological drivers of population dynamics (e.g. predation, competition, climate)
dynamics
feedback between levels (genes, phenotypes, populations, communities, ecosystems)
evolutionary rescue
occurs when occurs when a population recovers from environmental change due to increases in the frequencies of advantageous alleles (independent of gene flow). AKA The recovery and persistence of a population through natural selection acting on heritable variation
contemporary evolution
the study of evolution on shorter timescales than originally thought, often dealing with research in climate change, habitat loss, etc.
how has contemporary evolution influenced invasion biology?
evidence is mounting that rapid evolution may be a key to the success of invasive species, even when extreme bottlenecks occur
how has contemporary evolution influenced ecosystem ecology?
recent work has shown that evolution can affect nutrient and energy flow through ecosystems, among other processes
how can we reconcile the observation that evolution can be extremely rapid with the observation of stasis in the fossil record?
evolution does not necessarily cause clear morphological change, can also be cryptic evolution, sampling issue/snapshots not necessarily realistic, could be multiple reasons
does the persistence and stability of ecological communities depend on evolution? Or is evolution trivial?
negative feedback of evolution creates stability/persistence