Evidence Flashcards
What makes evidence relevant?
Makes any pertinent fact more or less probable.
Habit distinguished from character
Habit describes a regular response
Character describes disposition
FRE 406
habit admissible to prove someone acted in accordance with habit on a particular occasion
“Jeff is a carless driver.”
habit or character?
character
“Jeff never slows down for the yield sign at the end of the street.”
habit or character?
habit
Liability insurance permissible?
Not for negligence or ability to pay (public policy)
Yes for ownership/control, impeachment, liability admission
Settlement offers permissible?
Not to prove/disprove validity/amount of disputed claim, or to impeach a witness by prior inconsistent statement/contradiction.
Subsequent remedial measures permissible?
Not for negligence, design defect, need for warning (public policy)
Yes for ownership/control, rebutting a claim that precaution wasn’t feasible, opposing party destroyed evidence
When are settlement offers permissible?
In a criminal case, when addressing statements made during compromise negotiations regarding a civil dispute with a government authority.
(D admissions during civil settlement with SEC are admissible in his criminal trial)
Are offers to pay medical expenses admissible?
No, but accompanying statements of fact are.
Does taking the stand put a D’s character at issue?
No, but it puts his credibility at issue.
When is evidence of prior acts of misconduct admissible?
MIMIC: motive intent mistake (absence of) identify common plan/scheme
ancient document provision
document may be authenticated by evidence that it is:
at least 20 years old
condition doesn’t leave authenticity suspect
found in a place where such a writing would be kept
x-ray authentication
accurate process
machine was in working order
qualified operator
who may identify a voice?
anyone who has heard the voice at any time
best evidence rule
To prove the terms of a writing, if the terms are material, must produce the original writing. Secondary evidence (oral testimony, etc.) admissible only if the original writing is unavailable.
handwritten copies–what type of evidence and when admissible?
secondary evidence
admissible only when originals unavailable
when are leading questions permitted?
on cross
to intro new material
when witness needs aid b/c of memory loss, immaturity, physical/mental weakness
hostile witness
when a past recorded recollection is read into evidence and heard by the jury, is it admitted into evidence as an exhibit?
only when offered by an adverse party
present recollection refreshed and past recollection recorded–hearsay?
present recollection refreshed: not HS b/c not offend into evidence
past recollection recorded: HS, but falls w/in an exception
when is lay witness opinion testimony admissible?
rationally based on witness perception
helpful to a clear understanding of testimony or determination of a fact at issue
not based on scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge
May lay witnesses testify whether one acted as an agent?
No
May lay witnesses testify whether an agreement was made?
No
When may an expert not give an opinion on the ultimate issue?
When the defendant’s mental state is an element of a crime or defense, an expert may not state an opinion whether the accused had that mental state.
Per federal rules, what are the limits on impeachment?
Anybody may impeach anybody.
Per FRE, does an opportunity to explain or deny need to precede the introduction of a prior inconsistent statement?
No
What discretion does a court have to bar impeachment by evidence of past crimes concerning dishonesty?
None
What convictions are inadmissible?
Those for which conviction or release from jail (whichever later) is more than ten years passed
Does FRE permit an impeaching witness to speak to the character for truthfulness of another witness?
Yes