Evidence Flashcards
PRESENTATION OF EVIDENCE
TOPICS:
Witnesses
Judge & Jury
Objections & Offers of Proof
Burden of Persuasion & Production
Impeachment
Lay Witnesses
(1) Who can be a lay witness
(2) What can/cannot lay witnesses testify about?
- Anyone, including children, can be a lay witness (except judge or jury)
- Can testify as to knowledge/perception, but not expert opinions.
Expert Witnesses
(1) What must the lawyer do?
(2) Is outside evidence permissible?
(3) What can/cannot expert witnesses testify about?
1) Must lay foundation/qualify expert
2) Expert can use outside evidence
3) Expert can give opinion on conclusions; Expert cannot give opinion on mental state of defendant if element of crmie
Control of Witnesses
The Court can take steps to keep “reasonable control”
Leading Questions
(1) When are they not allowed?
(2) When are they allowed
(1) Not allowed on Direct
(2) Allowed:
- Cross Exam
- Hostile witness
- Adverse party,
- Shy witness/child
- Jog memory
- Lay foundation
Refreshing Memory/Recollection
(1) What can you show?
(2) Can it be read into evidence?
(1) May show anything to a witness
(2) Cannot be read into evidence
Judge & Jury
(1) What does the Judge handle?
(2) What does the jury handle
(1) Judge: rules of law + admissibility
vs
(2) Jury: questions of fact + weight of evidence
Objections and Offers of Proof
(1) What is an Objection to Admission?
(2) What is an Offer of Proof?
(1) Objection to admission: must be timely and lawyer states grounds for objection
(2) Offer of proof: evidence was actually excluded and lawyer preserves for appeal
Burden of Persuasion & Production
(1) What is the Burden of Production?
(2) What is the Burden of Persuasion?
(1) Burden of Persuasion: P must prove each element
vs
(2) Burden of Production:
- Civil: Preponderance
- Criminal: BaRD
Presumptions
(1) What is a presumption?
(2) What is a rebuttable presumption?
(3) What is a conclusive presumption?
(1) Presumption: A conclusion a judge must come to once a party meets its burden
(2) Rebuttable Presumption:
* If prsmpt WAS rebutted - Jury MAY conclude
- If prsmpt NOT rebutted - Jury MUST conclude
(3) Conclusive Presumption: Jury MUST conclude
Character vs Impeachment
Character Evidence:
1) WHO is Character Evidence about?
2) WHAT is Character Evidence
3) Is Character Evidence generally admissible?
Impeachment:
4) WHO is Impeachment about?
5) WHAT is Impeachment about?
6) Is Impeachment generally admissible?
Character Evidence:
1) Character evidence is about the DEFENDANT.
2) Character evidence is about bad things D did in the past.
3) Character evidence is generally NOT ADMISSIBLE.
Impeachment:
1) Impeachment is about WITNESS ON THE STAND (including the Defendant, if he takes the stand).
2) Impeachment is about attacking W’s CREDIBILITY.
3) Impeachment evidence is GENERALLY ADMISSIBLE.
Impeachment
When may you impeach by:
(1) Prior Felony Convictions?
(2) Prior F or M Convictions regarding Honesty/Truthfulness?
(3) Prior NON-Convictions (Bad Acts)?
(1) You may impeach by Prior Felony CONVICTION if it occurred within 10 years and passes balancing test.
(2) You may ALWAYS impeach by Prior F or M CONVICTION regarding honesty/truthfulness, and it may be proved by rep/op/acts.
(3) You may ONLY impeach by prior NON-Conviction (Bad Acts) if it relates to honesty/truthfulness, and you may NOT use extrinsic evidence
When may a statement be used as Impeachment AND Substantive Evidence?
ONLY if (1) admissible impeachment AND (2) not hearsay.
RELEVANCY & EXCLUDING RELEVANT EVIDENCE
TOPICS:
Relevant Evidence
Authentication
Character Evidence
Habit Evidence
Relevant Evidence
(1) What makes evidence relevant?
(2) When may relevant evidence nonetheless be excluded?
(1) Any tendency to make a fact more or less probable. Generally admissible.
(2) Unfairly prejudicial, misleading or confusing, causes delay.
Authentication
(1) What must be shown?
(2) How do you authenticate?
(3) What evidence is self-authenticating?
(1) Must show “the evidence is what it purports to be”
(2) By direct testimony, by special markings, by testimony with PERSONAL KNOWLEDGE
(3) Official/Notarized Documents, NEWSPAPERS, Seals
Character Evidence
What is Character Evidence?
Character evidence: bad things DEFENDANT did in the past. Generally NOT admissible, too prejudicial.
Character Evidence
Character ADMISSIBLE in CIVIL CASES When?
(1) _______________; (1), (2), (3), (4)
(2)
If ADMISSIBLE, how may it be proved?
(1) When at issue; (1) Defamation, (2) Child Custody, (3) Negligent Entrustment, (4) Misrep/Fraud
(2) To show MIMIC (not propensity)
Motive
Intent
Mistake (absence of)
Identification
Common Plan or Scheme