Evidence Flashcards
what are some reasons for a Rule 403 relevance ruling against evidence
undue prejudice, misleading th ejury undue delay, cumulative evidence
what is the rule 403
allow evidence unless prejudice outweighs probative value
is prior accident history or filing a similar tort claim admissible
no, just shows carelessness
what’s the relevance rule for prior accidents involving D
generally inadmissible but if happens under similar circumstances can be used to show existence of dangerous condition 2 condition caused accident 3 D had notice of condition
what is habit evidence
frequency of particular conduct
what words should you look for to denote habit evidence
always, automatically, instinctively
liability insurnace
can show ownership, impeach, as part of an admission of liablity
cant show wrongful conduct or negligence
subsequent remedial efforts
cant use to show negligence, defect, need for warning, culpability
can show ownership, rebut non-feasability arguemnt (you can fix it), prove party destryed evidence
is evidence of settlement grounds for impeach on bias
yes, ONLY to impeach for bias
what is the exception to exclusion of civil and settlement negotiation
settlement w/ govt in civil suit can be used in criminal suit
plea discussions
inadmissible including offers to plead guilty withdraw guilty please no conest statements of fact made during plea discussions
HOWEVER, an actual guilty plea is admissible as statement of an opposing party
what is admissible if accompanying an offer to pay medical expenses
any voluntary accompanying facts, EXCEPT an offer to settle the case. Offer to pay medical bills is not admissible!!!!
what is the rule for character evidence in criminal cases
prosecution: can’t intro evidence of D bad character UNLESS D intro evidence of good character.
D can intro opinon or reputation evidence of good character
is a D character at issue when they testify for themselves in a criminal case
No, their credibility is at issue, or if they testify to their own good character then P can rebut
How can P rebut D character witnesses
with specific “did you know” acts of bad character (shows lack of knowledge). Can include prior arrests of D
P can call own character witnesses for rep and opinion testimony
How can a D challenge a victims character in a criminal case
opinion or reputation evidence ( usually only relevant in self defense cases)
is character evidence admissible in civil cases
no, not to show conformity can be used to show an essential element of case in -defamation -negligent hiring -child custody all three forms admissible
when is character evidence relevant if independantly relevant in a civil case OR a criminal case
to prove
- motive
- intent
- mistake
- identity
- common plan scheme
what are the method of authentication
opponents admission
eyewitness
verified handwriting (opinion of a lay witness is fine, jury can compare, or expert)
ancient documents (over 20 years)
photos and videos must be id by a witness saying they are fair and representative
how do you authenticate oral statement
voice id (anyone that’s heard the voice, uncluding after trial began)
what is the best evidence rule
to prove content of a writing, the orginal doc msut be produced if the terms are material
when does best evidence rule apply
when writing is legally operative or dispositive instrument OR where the knowledge of a witness converning a facet results from having read it (recorded recollection)
Are duplicates admissible for originals according to best evidence rule
yes, so long as it is not unfair to use duplicate and no genuine question raised to authenticity
are there valid excuses for non-production of original in best evidence rule
yes
- destruction
- can’t be obtained by judicial process
- in poss of adversary who fails to produce
what are exceptions for best evidecen rule
voluminous records (summary fine)
collateral materials
testimony of opponent
how do you authnticate real evidence
witness testimnoy OR unbroken chain of custody
are witnesses presumed comptent
yes