Con Law Flashcards
What are the requirements for case and controversy?
Ripeness, Mootness, and Standing
When does a court opinion constitute an advisory opinion?
there has to be an actual controversy (no controversy between the parties) or the court can’t legally bind either of the parties
Can a court review a law or policy before it takes effect?
Yes, if P. can show the issue is fit for a judicial desicion AND the plantiff would suffer substantial hardship abest review
What is mootness?
P. must be suffering from an ongoing injury at all stages of the case
What are the exceptions to the mootness rule:
if a P. has a controversy that is capable of repetition b/c of inherently short duration OR cases where D voluntarily stops behavior but can resume at any moment
What are the req for Standing?
An injury in fact, which req both a particularied injury that affects P in a personal and individual way AND a concrete injury (not hypothetical)
Who can’t sue for general standing?
Standing solely based on citizenship or taxpaying status (unless a tax liability issue)
Can any person sue on congressional spending grounds?
Yes, but only for first amendment establishment clause (religious establishment clause) grounds, and only for spending power
For Standing, when must injury occur?
already occurred or imminent
How does one claim standing for a third party?
ONLY if it is difficult for the third party to assert their own rights OR if there is a close relatiohshop between the claimant and the third party
How do you determine standing for organizations?
if there is an injury to a member, the members injury is related to the organizations purpose AND the individual members participation in the lawsuit is not req (they are not seeking individualized damages)
What is the free speech exception for standing?
one can claim a free speech violation on behalf of a group of which they are a part even if their own speech is unprotected, so long as the speech of the members of that group is protected. Rule does NOT apply to commercial speech
Do people have standing to sue states?
No, UNLESS states consent. Can sue local governments
What is a political question?
Ones inherently incapable of judicial relief or are constitutionally vested with the other branches
What are the elements of constitutional conditions on Congress’ spending power?
- clearly stated 2. serves the purpose of the program 3. not unduly coercive on state (rare) 4. not otherwise unconstitutional
Are taxes generally valid?
Yes, so long as they are reasonably related to revenue production and not a penalty (CAN be labelled as a penalty but still permissibile)
What is Congress’ Commerce power?
congress has the enumerated power to regualte interstate commerce. the three parts are 1. Channels 2. Insrtumentalities 3. activity that substantially affects interstate commerce (can includ epurely intrastate activity
Can Congress regulate non-economic activity that substantially effects interstate commerce>
NO, key on NON-economic activity
True/False: congress cannot compel states to act for insterstate commerce
True
Rights of Aliens controlled by congress
resident aliens: right to notice and hearing for deport
non-resident aliens: no right to enter US
Basic outline for presidential actions
if authorized by statute or Congress: likely to be upheld
if congress is silent: balance of history. Unlikely to be upheld if it usurps power from a branch or prevents another branhc from performing tasks
Rank treaties against other laws
Treaties trump state and local law, are on par with federal law, and are inferior to the constitution
What is the anti-commandeering principle?
Congress can’t compel states to pass state law OR enforce federal law through use of enumerated powers (tax, spending)
What is implied preemption of state law by federal law?
when state law makes following a federal law impossible OR when state law prevents achievement of a federal objective, state law is impliedly preemepted through supremecy clause
What is the privileges and immunities clause?
prevents states from discriminating against non-residents
- does not include corporations and aliens
- ONLY protects important commercial activities and fundamental rights
Can a state discriminate against a non-resident for important commercial activities?
Yes, BUT ONLY if there is and importnat govt purpose AND there is no less restrictive method available