Evaluation of Raine

Question 1

Why quasi is weakness

Answer 1

• IV not manipulated so uncontrolled CV’s - give examples.

- can’t establish c + e (dangers)

Question 2

Strength 1 and why

Answer 2

Pet scans - objective

also weakness as difficult to interpret

Question 3

Weakness 2 and why

Answer 3

Lacks pop validity only uses NGRI

Question 4

Rain support

Answer 4

Yang and Raine - meta analysis 43 brain imaging studies found reduced prefrontal linked to violence and antisocial

Question 5

Ethic issues

Answer 5

• consent
• psych harm
• Physical harm
• Social effects (self fulfilling prophecy)