Ethics - Truth Telling and Whistle Blowing

Question 1

What is the legal duty of honesty

Answer 1

No duty to volunteer truth but if asked, must be truthful

Human Rights Act - Article 10

Question 2

What is the professional duty of honesty

Answer 2

Listen to patients and respond to concerns
Give patients info they need
Honest, open, integrity

Question 3

What is the deontological argument for honesty

Answer 3

Tell truth at all times in all circumstances no matter the consequences
Only way to respect autonomy

Question 4

What is the utilitarian argument for honesty

Answer 4

Weigh up each situation to see which action brings about greatest good + least suffering

Question 5

What are the types of deception

Answer 5

Involuntary = misunderstanding
Voluntary = When you know misunderstanding has occurred but dont clear it up 
Intentional = I tell you what I presume not to be true 
Unintentional = I communicate info I believe is true but is not

Question 6

When should you whistle blow

Answer 6

Inadequate clinical care
Failure to keep up to date
Failure to monitor & maintain quality
Failure to maintain trust

Question 7

What is the Public INterest Disclosure Act of 1998

Answer 7

Legal protection if dismissed
Appoint senior manager to protect whistle-blower
Clinical governance depends on it