Ethics Flashcards
What is ‘Duty to Protect’?
refers to protecting the community. First obligation is to protect the community
Q: you get a subpoena from court: What do you do
1. Tell the client to try to mediate with husband so I don’t have to include notes in subpoena
1.2. Include divorce notes in subpoena but not anything else
1.3. Tell client I must release all the information I have
1.4. Talk to an expert about advice about what to release
1.5. Tell client to talk to court about her concerns
- Tell client I must release all the information I have
You treated someone 2 years ago and they were depressed and suicidal. You treated them 6 sessions. Client test results back to normal, not suicidal anymore and discharged. 1 year has passed. Get a call from an employer wanting report about client going for job but client doesn’t know they are calling. Do you:
1. call client to inform them of employer request
2. tell employer you can’t say anything and to contact client directly
3. contact client about breach of privacy
4. send employer consent form
5. arrange session with client to see how he’s going.
- tell employer you can’t say anything and to contact client directly
Having peer supervision and having lunch with a number of colleagues from different professions. NDIS group practice. Principal / director / consultant / guru / specialist psychologist. Having meeting with multidisciplinary meeting. One colleague starts to discuss case they want to refer to you about emotional reg strategies with 4 yr old non verbal. Do you:
1. Ask colleague to talk to practice manage to triage client
2. Ask colleague for written referral once back at work
3. Ask colleague to get referral from GP
4. Thanks for referral and start discussing after lunch in the restaurant
5. Tell colleague will discuss back at office due to confidentiality reasons.
- Tell colleague will discuss back at office due to confidentiality reasons.
You are seeing someone with gambling issue. Struggling to take care of son. Mother trying to help with care. You have some concerns with mum and sometimes she struggles to take care of the child. What are the limits of confidentiality.
- No limits to confidentiality
- You have an obligation to protect this child that will override client treatment
- Need to report mother to child protection
- Confidentiality needs client consent
- Too hard and need to move to Bahamas.
- You have an obligation to protect this child that will override client treatment
What are the APS cope of ethics principles?
A. Respect for the rights and dignity of people
B. Propriety (competence / protect people)
C. Integrity
What is the ethical decision making model
a systematic way of arriving at an ethical decision that supports the best interest of the client
What are the steps in the ethical decision making model?
- Are my individual characteristics, or perceptions of the client interfering with an objective evaluation of the situation?
2.Are there any legal obligations? (They usually must be complied with, trying to take are of wellbeing of clients and ethical obligations as much as possible) - Is there clear and non conflicting advice in the Code of Ethics?
- Seek advice form experts, senior psychologists and the literature (this is usually the answer wanted)
- Consider potential actions and outcomes
- Consider previous decisions to the one in progress
- Evaluate options and act
- Review the decision made
WHAT DO WE DO IF CLIENT PRESENTS WITH COMPLEX ISSUES
AND WE DON’T HAVE TRAINING IN THAT AREA?
IF RURAL (and nobody with the knowledge and skills nearby)
you can see them with some conditions
IF URBAN refer!!!
Confidentiality:
What 3 circumstances apply to psychologists breaking confidentiality?
- having consent from client or legal authority to act on behalf of client (ie parent)
- Where there is a legal obligation (supeana)
- when consulting colleagues / in supervision (need to conceal identity of clients and obtains clients consent
Working with Multiple Clients
´Psychologists who agree to provide psychological
services to an individual, group of people, or
organisation at the request of a third party, at the
outset explain to all parties concerned 5 things. what are they?
(a) the nature of the RELATIONSHIP with each of them;
(b) the psychologist’s ROLE(such as, but not limited to,
case manager, consultant, counsellor, expert witness,
facilitator, therapist);
(c) the probable USES of the INFORMATION obtained;
(d) the limits to CONFIDENTIALITY; and
(e) the FINANCIAL arrangements relating to the
provision of the service where relevant
What is informed consent?
Psychologists ensure consent is informed by:
´ (a) explaining the nature and purpose of the procedures they
intend to use;
´ (b) clarifying the reasonably foreseeable risks, adverse effects,
and possible disadvantages of the procedures they intend
using;
´ (c) explaining how information will be collected and
recorded;
´ (d) explaining how, where, and for how long, information will
be stored, and who will have access to the stored information;
´ (e) advising clients that they may participate, may decline to
participate, or may withdraw from methods or procedures
proposed to them;
´ (g) clarifying the frequency, expected duration, financial and
administrative basis of any psychological services that will be
provided;
´ (h) explaining confidentiality and limits to confidentiality
Who is the client when working with a child 0-8 years?
the parent is the client in relation to the
psychological service. All rights and responsibilities lie with the parent.
Parent consents and psychologist owes their obligations (e.g.
confidentiality) to parent. Psychologist still explains to young child what is
going to happen and get some consent from child.
Who is the client when working with a child 8-14 years
This is more complex
The parent is still the client in the therapeutic setting
Psych and parent need to have agreement regarding confidentiality for relationship with child
What is the situation with confidentiality and consent when working with mature minors 14+
psychologist needs to consider if young person
is capable of making their own decisions or if
legal guardian is still needed to consent to the
service provision.
´ It would be an unusual situation where anyone
under the age of 14 could be considered a
mature minor and more likely that those aged
over 16 are considered mature enough to make
their own decisions (APS 2011).
´ The complexity of the presenting issue and the
client’s decision-making that led to this situation
may give the psychologist key information
about the client’s maturity.
You are seeing someone with gambling issue. Struggling to take care of son. Mother trying to help with care. You have some concerns with mum and sometimes she struggles to take care of the child. What are the limits of confidentiality.
1. No limits to confidentiality
2. You have an obligation to protect this child that will override client treatment
3. Need to report mother to child protection
4. Confidentiality needs client consent
5. Too hard and need to move to Bahamas.
- You have an obligation to protect this child that will override client treatment
You’re a supervisor and walk into room in community centre and one supervisee has left client notes in staff room. They are prov psych. What do you do?
1. Call meeting with all psychs in team and blast them
2. Call board and report supervisee
3. Move notes into cabinet and don’t mention anything to prov psych
4. Call supervisee and have discussion about confidentiality
5. Call uni to report psych behaviour
- Call supervisee and have discussion about confidentiality
Seeing client through EAP scheme and manager call to discuss some issues that are happening with client. What can you disclose to manager:
1. Disclose the Number of sessions your seen client for
2. Whether they are making progress
3. Can’t disclose anything
4. Send employer consent form
5. Organise meeting between client and employer
- Can’t disclose anything
What do you disclose to insurers / workcover about client you are seeing for workcover?
only allowed to tell how many sessions, what goals are, what capacity is now compared to where they started, what is the progress.
What do you include in treating psycholgists report?
don’t ever include your opinion. Just symptoms, treatment plan assessment score results etc. only include factual information!!! THIS WILL BE ASKED IN THE EXAM
Having peer supervision with friend and friend tells you they have continued seeing person that they started with EAP for several months after they successfully completed treatment goals with EAP. Client wanted to keep seeing for other issues
What is the most important ethical issue to discuss here?
1. Whether client presentation allow for client to get mental health plan
2. Can client get reimbursement from EAP for these sessions
3. Are you fostering clients dependence and / or counter transference issues
4. Consider all ethical issues
5. Whether you are using strategies that are going to lead to successful treatment and terminations.
- Consider all ethical issues
When do muliple relationships occur? (4)
Multiple relationships occur when a psychologist, rendering a psychological service
to a client, also is or has been:
a) in a non-professional relationship with the same client;
b) in a different professional relationship with the same client
c) in a non-professional relationship with an associated party; or
d) a recipient of a service provided by the same client. (APS 2008a, p. 98)
Is it ok to provide psych services to family or friends.
It is only in the absence of other feasible options and when harm is imminent if action is not taken, that psychologists provide a psychological service to family or friends’ (p. 95)
You are seeing a 13 yr old who is bullied at school. She feels pressured by her peers to have sex with a boy she knows who is 15. She feels stuck and alone. She is starting to get abusive messages from peers. She doesn’t know how to make things better. Also, a friend of hers is self-harming and she sometimes feels like doing the same thing. She doesn’t want you telling her parents.
- Do a risk assessment and refer the young person to lifeline.
- Do a risk assessment and refer to the Kids Helpline.
- Do a risk assessment and get her consent to contact her school.
- Do a risk assessment and tell her you must talk to her parents.
- Do a risk assessment and get consent to talk to her teacher
- Do a risk assessment and tell her you must talk to her parents.
Rationale: A 14 yr old at risk is not considered to be a mature minor.
A client comes to your practice. They say they have lost hope, there is no point in living anymore. They have a plan to suicide but won’t tell you what it is. What actions should you include (3)
- Don’t leave the client. Don’t allow them to leave without calling 000. Provide their name, phone #, address, they are suicidal. Ask them to do a welfare check.
- If the client leaves then call 000.
- It’s not enough to do a risk assessment.
If client gets angry with you and leaves you then call 000 but only if there is an immediate risk of harm. The psychologist should also follow-up the next day.
Student presents to the university counselling service where you are a counsellor. He tells you that his girlfriend has left him. He doesn’t see the point of living anymore. You do a suicide risk assessment, and his risk is high. You tell him to go to the hospital, but he says he’s fine. He says he’d rather go home and have a rest. What do you do?
1. Let him go home to rest.
2. You take him to the Emergency Dept yourself. (Never do this - rather call an ambulance.)
3. Talk to a senior psych and discuss the next steps with this student.
4. Call the parents and let them know.
5. Call his girlfriend and explain the situation. Ask her to come in a d have a session.
- Talk to a senior psych and discuss the next steps with this student.
Rationale: If they give you the option to consult with a senior psych then go that for a complicated question.
Duty of care with suicidal client
You work in a private practice. A client texts you at 10pm on a Sunday night and says, ‘Thank you for helping me but I’m about to kill myself.’ What do you do?
1. ____________?
2. Make it clear to the client that I am not emergency service and ask what time they can call me to prevent this?
3. Call 000.
4. Go to Bahamas.
5. Go to client’s place and make sure they are ok.
- Call 000.
Rationale: As a health professional we have an obligation to do something to prevent the person suiciding. If the risk is high, we need to act sooner.
Client who has access to weapons
Your client who lives on a farm is depressed. He has access to weapons (with a licence). What do you need to do?
1. Report to the police.
2. Do a risk assessment. If the risk is high, then report.
3. Wait for signs of suicidality then report.
4. Do nothing.
5. Talk to his wife and ask her to keep the weapons in a locked cabinet.
- Do a risk assessment. If the risk is high, then report.
(The fact that he has weapons is not enough to report him.)
You are working with a client who has disclosed his anger with his case (insurance) manager who shares this with you. The client has access to weapons and has said he will hurt her. The threat is specific.
1. Mediation re the violent threats.
2. Respect the insurance manager’s decision to tell no-one.
3. Tell him you need to talk to her organisation and do a report.
4. Tell her to move to another location.
5. Work with your client to teach him non-violent ways of communicating.
- Tell him you need to talk to her organisation and do a report.
Rationale: If someone tells you they will blow up something then if you think there is a real threat you need to protect the community.
What are the three reasons for filing mandatory reports with AHPRA re other professionals
- Inappropriate relationships with clients, including sexual misconduct or gross boundary violations (e.g., taking clients out to a nightclub, or for coffee)
- Working with clients while impaired (e.g., drugs and alcohol, or psychological problems)
- Working outside of the realm of accepted psychological practices (this is a grey area because this guideline applies to people working outside of the evidence base).
What are the legal requirements for mandatory reporting for older people and vulnerable groups
There are no legal requirments. Mandatory reporting relates to children. However there is ethical obligations to report.
You see a son and his elderly father whos 82 and son tells you he’s concerned about dad and he’s not functioning well. Concerned and wants you to do cog assess. Father says he’s doing fine and assessment shows no difficulties.
1. Concerned about elderly abuse
2. Recommend further assessment
3. Father should listen to son and do what son wants him to do
4. Can’t see any neuro cog difficulties and father can make decisions for himself
5. Condo in Bahamas
- Can’t see any neuro cog difficulties and father can make decisions for himself
Most of the time the answer is in the question. If they want you to think of elder abuse they will mention something about bruises / changes in behaviour etc.
How long do you keep client records for adults and children
7 years for adults
Children: 7 years after they turn 18 yrs