ESG Flashcards
Sources of pressure for ESG
▶Money flowing into sustainable investment funds.
▶ Shareholders sponsoring ESG-related proxy proposals.
▶ Institutional investor activism (e.g., BlackRock, Vanguard,
State Street).
▶ Employee activism.
▶ Third-party activism and NGOs.
Association btw CSR and cost of capital
Negative,
▶Investors respond strongly negatively to negative CSR
events
▶weakly negatively to positive (voluntary) CSR
events
▶ Financial analysts also downgrade their estimates in the
short- and long-run due to negative ESG news
Advantages of ESG
▶Reduce ESG risk
▶Increase cash flows in the future
▶Decrease cost of capital
▶Forecast Horizon: ESG is long term so benefits may exist not seen in an explicit forecast period
▶TV: Esg factors e.g. oil and gas could cause investors to believe a company will not exist forever
SRI Style: Positive screening
Pick stocks that perform well in ESG relative to peers
SRI Style: Engagement/active ownership
the use of shareholder power to influence corporate behavior through direct corporate engagement
SRI Style: Full Integration
is the explicit inclusion of ESG factors into traditional financial analysis of individual stocks (e.g., as inputs into cash flow forecasts and/or cost-of-capital estimates).
SRI Style: Negative Screening
the exclusion of certain sectors, companies, or practices from a fund or portfolio on the basis of specific ESG criteria.
SRI Style: Overlay / Portfolio tilt
tilting a portfolio towards a emissions goal or other ESG aspiration
SRI Style: Relative / Best in class screening
Pick stocks that perform well in ESG relative to peers
SRI Style: Thematic Investment
Invest in themes such as clean energy
SRI Style: Risk Factor/ Risk Premium Investing
Including ESG into risk analysis
How to integrate ESG into valuation
Sales: Integrate esg factors into forecasts by inc or dec company’s sales growth rate by an amount that reflects investment opportunities or risk
OPEX : Make assumptions about ESG effect on future operating costs and adjust them directly or before EBIT
Forecast horizon: ESG investments tend to be long, so longer forecast period
Terminal value: Esg factors could cause company to believe company or busines line will not exist forever
Beta or discount rate: Adjust when theres appearent ESG risk to company
Problems with board of directors?
- Prioritize their own utility instead of shareholders
- Agency Problem: take self-interested actions that are not in the interests of other stakeholders
- Agency Costs: shareholders bear the cost of bad actions from the board
Board of Directors Mandate
Effective boards satisfy both
i. Advisory: consult with management regarding the strategic and operational direction of the company.
ii. Oversight: monitor company performance and reduce agency costs.
Board Independence
- Act solely in the interest of the firm.
- Free from conflicts that compromise judgment.
- Able to take positions in opposition to management