Element 1 - Why we should manage workplace health and safety Flashcards
What are the 3 main societal drivers for managing H&S
**Moral reasons- doing the right thing. Morals are the codes of conduct, or rules of behaviour of what is right and what is wrong. it is morally right to ensure workers return home safe and healthy. When worker is injured it is their family, friends and coleague that also suffer.
Financial reasons - Avoid unecessary cosys and fees. Better H&S means better worker retention. Clients prefer businesses that have a good H&S record. Healthy workers are more productive.
Legal - Avoid criminal prosecution or civil case.
What are the three methods to estimate the uninsured costs of accidents
- On average, uninsured costs of accidents amount to 10x the insurance premiums paid
- Uninsured losses from accidents in smaller firms add up to £315 per employee per year
- The average uninsured cost of an accident causing absence from work of approximately £2100
Discuss the HSE’s 2 methods for measuring uninsured costs.
- The simple cost calculator.
Works out the total cost of accidents per year by applying an average uninsured cost per accident type and multiplying it by the number of accidents per year. Types of accidents include:
- Those causing absence from work = £2097 per occurance
- Those only requiring first aid = £33 per occurance
- Those causing damage to plant, equipment, but not people £141 per occurance - The incident cost calculator
Records the main costs relating to an incident unising a comprehensive form. It records the time spend and cost for items such as dealing with the incident, investigating it, getting back to business, business costs, actions to manage reputation damage, sanctions and penalties etc.
What type of insurance must all businesses have, what does it cover and what doesn’t it cover.
All employees must have Employers Liability Insurance so they can pay compensation for illness, injury or damage.
This is only a small part (iceberg tip) of the cost:
Insured costs =
* Injury
* ill health
* damage
Uninsured costs =
* Lost time
* extra wages/vertime
* sick pay
* production delays
* fines
* loss of contracts
* legal costs
* damage to product, plant, building & equipment
* clearing the site
* investigation time
* excess on insurance claims
* loss of business reputation
HSE estimate that in Great Britain during 2017 / 18, new cases of occupa
The cost of work-related ill-health to organisations can be categorised across five main areas. What are these?
- Sick pay
- Insurance premiums - EL insurance and private health insurance
- Production disturbance - costs for work reorganisation, recruitment, induction/replacement staff to maintain output
- Administrative costs: dealing with sickness/insurance/compensation claims and conducting health surveilance.
- Investigations & prosecutions: internal and legal costs from investigations and prosecution by HSE/local authority.
In a series of case studies the HSE aimed to develop a way to accurately identify the full costs of accidents, what 2 categories did they use to identify the various costs.
Financial costs - basic costs incurred to return the business to the situation it was in before an accident happened. This covers both material and labour costs.
Opportunity costs (or lost opportunity costs) include those incurred through people stood idle or being unproductive as a result of dealing with the consequences of an accident, and energy costs from plant running idle and buildings being lit and heated.
Describe the 2 branches of UK law
Criminal law:
* where the individual or organisation commits a crime that poses a threat to the H&S of others - ie breach of Act or Regulations
* it is an offence against society
* prosecution is by the enforcing authority/ Crown prosecution sevice
* tried in the criminal courts.
* determines guilt
* Loss is not necessary for action
* Seeks to punish for breach of law
* Guilt proven beyond unreasonable doubt
* Can’t be insured against
* punishment includes fines & imprisonment
Civil Law
* if an individual suffers loss (injury / ill-health or death) the victim, or their dependants, may instigate legal proceedings (sue) for damages in the civil courts.
* where the individual or organisation is held responsible for the harm of others due to negligence
* Injured person may sue under the tort of negligence or under the rort of breack of statutory duty.
* Civil wrongs
* wrong to an individual
* action taken by injured party
* determines liabilitiy
* loss is necessary for action
* seeks compensation for loss
* liability proved on the balance of probabilities - one argument needs to be more convincing than the other.
* Can be insured against
In civil courts, a claimant may sue under the tort of negligence or under the tort of breach of statutory duty.
For the injured party (claimant) to succeed in a negligence claim, what 3 things must they must prove?
Negligence may be explained as ‘careless conduct injuring another’, or a ‘breach of the common law duty of care’.
- that the defendant (usually the employer) owed the aclimant a duty of care. The requirements for duty of care to exist are;
* A reasonable person would have foreseen the damage
* There is a ‘neighbour’ relationship between the defendant and the claimant. includes, Employer to employee, emploer to contractors and contracotrs to employees and occupiers to authorised visitors.
* It must be fair, just and reasonable to impose the duty. - that this duty was breached - DOC is breached if the defendance has not exercised the reasonable care expected of a reasonable person.
- the breach is the cause of the injury/loss. The claimant must prove on the balance of probabilities that the defendants breach caused the harm and that the harm wouldn’t have occured otherwise.
In civil courts, a claimant may sue under the tort of negligence or under the tort of breach of statutory duty.
What 5 conditions must be met in order for a claimant to sue due to breaching a relevant statute?
- the statute must have been breached
- the statute must apply to the claimant, i.e. an employee can only sue if the statute applies to employees
- the statute must have been designed to prevent the type of injury incurred by the claimant
- The statute must state that a person can sue due to a breach of it.
- the injury/loss must have been caused by the breach of statute.
The law is made in two different ways, i.e. there are two sources of law – what are they?
Common law: historically this meant law that was not local but was common to all of England. More usually the phrase means law that is not the result of legislation. Court decisions establish law through a system of precedents. Employers Duty of Care is an example.
Statute law: or legislation is law made by Parliament as an Act of Parliament, or a statutory instrument (e.g. Regulations) made under powers within an Act of Parliament.
Statute law takes priority over common law and may be enacted to address a perceived inequity in the common law. Common law often aids the interpretation of statute law as terms are debated in the courts based on the facts of a real case.
Civil Law
The damages (compensation payments) that can be recovered as a result of a successful personal injury claim via the civil courts fall into two categories - what are they?
In principle the claimant is entitled to full compensation for any losses incurred. The intention is to put the complainant in the same position as if the tort had not been committed.
General damages – Actual / probable loss of future earnings, to be incurred after the case, including costs for physical pain, suffering, impairment, disfigurement, mental anguish, loss of companionship and reduced quality of life. The amount of compensation available for general damages is dependent on the type and severity of the injury or illness, and the duration of the effects.
Special damages – Quantifiable losses incurred before the case, mainly loss of earnings, earning capacity and medical expenses.
Civil Law
What 3 factors may affect the level of damages incurred as a result of a civil injury claim?
Contributory negligence
When the claimant’s own carelessness contributes to the injury or loss. It is partly the claimant’s own fault and partly the fault of another (the defendant).
Damages will be reduced to the extent that the court think is fair, having regard to the claimant’s share of responsibility
Vicarious liability
Makes a person liable for the acts or omissions of another person.
It is useful to remember that there are three parties involved in cases involving vicarious liability at work: the employer, the employee, and an injured person.
Therefore, if an employee, injures another person, the employer will be held vicariously liable for the losses incurred by the injured person.
Limitations Act 1980
Sets a time limit of 3 years from the date of the negligence or in the case of
disease three years from the date of diagnosis for starting proceedings for claiming compensation for personal injury.
This limit may be extended if the injured person is suffering from mental disability, for minors (under 18 years of age on the date that they were injured) the three year period does not start until the eighteenth birthday.
Criminal Law
In H&S, what are the 4 main sources of information regarding criminal law?
- Acts of Parliament - a law passed by government.
The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (HASAWA / the Act) is the main health and safety legislation in the UK. Failure to comply = fines/imprisonment. - Regulations - Section 15 of HASAWA enables the Secretary of State to make health and safety Regulations. Breach of a regulation is a criminal offence.
Regulations are usually:
* more detailed than the general duties of HASAWA
* specific to particular hazards
* prompted by European Directives
* intended to protect employees at work. - Approved Codes of practice - give practical advice and examples of good practice on how to comply with the law.
- Following advice in a CoP ensures compliance with relevant regulations.
- If an organisation doesn’t comply via an ACoP and a suite is filed against them, the org would have to prove they complied with the regulations in another way. If they cannot prove this they may be found at fault. - Guidance - aids understanding of the law to help compliance. Not compulsory but following guidance will often ensure legal compliance.
Criminal law
What are the 3 Levels of statutory duty?
Duties in health and safety law may be absolute, ‘practicable’ and ‘rea
Absolute Duty
Must be comploed with. ‘shall’
Practicable
If it can be done, then it must be done. No consideration of cost/risk.
Reasonably practicable
Degree of risk should be balanced against the cost of controlling it. greater risk = greater controls. Onus is on the duty holder to prove they are doing all that is reasonably practicable.
List 2 enforcement agencies and the type of workplace/activity they would operate in
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and Environment Agency enforces at higher risk workplaces such as construction sites and factories.
Local Authorities (Usually Environmental Health Officers – EHOs) enforce at lower risk premises such as retailers, offices and warehousing.