Electoral Systems Flashcards
What is AMS
- Additional Member System
- Have two votes, one for a constituency rep elected using FPTP, second is a party (Proportional rep)
- The Westminster-style ballot papers are counted first. The candidate with the most votes in the constituency wins.
- The second ballot papers are then counted.
- The people counting look at how many seats a party won on the first ballot paper.
- They then add ‘additional members’ from the party lists to make parliament match how the country voted.
Where is the AMS voting system?
Scotland, Wales, London Assembly
What are the two votes for in AMS?
- Constituency vote (FPTP)
- regional vote (proportional rep)
which system uses the d’hont formula?
AMS
Advantages of AMS
- Gives minor parties a chance
- More representative - get 2 representatives
- proportional result
- Gov with broad popularity
Disadvantages of AMS
- party control - Can’t pick the MP which will hold a seat
- Unlikely single party gov
- Some disadvantages of FPTP
- more complicated
What are the advantages of FPTP?
- Clear winner and mandate
- strong gov (reduced chance of coalition)
- Simple
- MP constituency link
- clear choice/ voters are familiar and understand the system
What are the disadvantages of FPTP?
- lack of voter choice
- Unequal vote value
- Lack of a majority
- Two party System
- Disproportionate result
- concentrated support advantage
- encourages tactical voting
- Winners bonus
What are the implications of Marginal seats ?
- campaigns will be focused on there’s areas
- receive more attention than safe seats
What is a winners bonus ? Give an example.
Over rewarding the winning party
2019, Cons got 44% of popular vote but 56% of seats
What is STV?
Single Transferable Vote
voters rank their preferences in numerical order
to win, a candidate must obtain a quota ‘droop quota’
candidates with least votes are eliminated and their votes are transferred
candidates with excess votes above the quota also have votes transferred
Where is STV used ?
Northern Ireland
What does STV require voters to do ?
Ordinal voting/ ranking candidates
Through STV, what do they need to win?
‘A droop quota’
What are advantages of STV?
- proportional result
- voter choice
- greater representation
What are disadvantages of STV?
- complicated
- unlikely single party gov
- extremists can be elected
- no accountability