Elections and Electoral Systems Flashcards
What are elections?
- Elections are the mechanism by which expressed preferences of citizens in democratic states are aggregated into a decision regarding who will govern
- Elections provide the link between rulers and the ruled
Why do we need elections?
- Elections provide a way of changing rulers without bloodshed and are the basis of democratic legitimacy
- The opportunity to participate in choosing rulers confers the obligation to obey the laws made by those who are chosen
What three conditions must be present regarding elections in a democracy?
- Periodic elections - usually in the constitution
- Wide opportunity to run for office
- High degree of political freedom
What is Rep by Pop?
The principle suggesting that the allocation of seats should occur in a manner that encourages equal division across electoral districts to ensure each vote is of equal weight
What are the two types of democracy?
- Direct democracy: a system of government where public decisions are made by citizens meeting in an assembly or voting by ballot
- 5th Century City-State of Athens, Referendum,
- Representative Democracy: a system of government based on the election of decision makers by the people
- USA, Australia
What are the different electoral systems?
- Single-Member Plurality
- Preferential or Alternative Vote
- Proportional Representation
- List System
- Mixed-Member-Proportional
What is Single-Member Plurality?
- SMP is an electoral system in which the candidate with the most votes wins, even though that win may not represent 50 per cent + 1 of the votes
- First Past the Post
- Plurality not majority of votes
- Canada, USA
What is Preferential or Alternative Vote?
- Voters rank the candidates (STV)
- If no candidate obtains a majority, the second preferences of the last place person are transferred to the remaining candidates until one candidate receives a majority of the votes
- Australia
What is Proportional Representation?
- The share of seats won closely matches the share of popular votes received
- If party gets 15% of populate vote - 15% of the seats in house
- All PR systems use multi-member district (more than one representative)
What is the List System?
- The elector votes not for an individual but for parties, who have lists of people running for office
- If part gets 15% of the vote, the party selects the 15% of the list to sit in the legislature
- Israel, Switzerland
- Often a minimum threshold (5%?)
What is an issue with the List System?
- Celebrities etc. declare themselves running on the list but may/will never have an obligation to be active should the party win
What is the Mixed-Member Proportional System and what does it result in?
- Voters cast 2 ballots: one for the local candidate and the other for a list of candidates put forward by the party
- Proportionality carries the local election, while the list evens up members to reflect national totals
- New Zealand
- 2 tier system of MP’s
- Those elected
- Those that were picked off list
In the most general sense how can Electoral Systems be divided?
- Proportional systems
* Majoritarian systems
What are Proportional Systems and what are the pros/cons?
- Party lists, STV
- Many parties in parliament
- Coalition governments the norm
- Wider range of viewpoints represented
- Easier for fringe parties to be elected
- Parties win seats in proportion to the votes they received
- Citizens do not have a single regional representative
- Widely dispersed interests are better represented
What are Majoritarian Systems and what are their pros/cons?
- Plurality or preferential voting
- Fewer parties in parliament
- Majority governments the norm
- Fewer viewpoints represented
- One party usually wins a majrity of seats
- Every citizen has a local member of parliament
- Regional interests are better represented