Educational policy and inequality Flashcards
What is the tripartite system (Butler Act)?
- where children in their final year of primary school had to take the 11+ exams, an intelligence test based on which they were selected and allocated to three different types of secondary school, supposedly according to their abilities
What are the features of grammar schools?
- offered an academic curriculum and access to non manual jobs and higher education
- they were for pupils with academic ability who passed the 11+, usually MC
What are the features of secondary modern schools?
- offered a non academic, ‘practical’ curriculum and access to manual work for pupils who failed the 11*, mainly WC
What are the features technical schools (polytechnic)?
- existed only in a few areas, so in practise it was more a bipartite than a tripartite system
- intended to focus on technical work
Was the tripartite system argued to be fair or unfair?
- was argued to be fair and meritocratic because it tested pupils based on ability rather than making judgements based on backgrounds or social class
What did critics say about the tripartite system? [2]
- they say it is u fair because girls had to get a higher score than boys in order to attend a grammar school
- others have highlighted multiple problems with schools selecting pupils based on ability
What is wrong with schools selecting pupils by ability at age 11 due to some children being late bloomers?
- some children may only start to show signs of progression after the age of 11, therefore it is too early to decide their future career path
What is wrong with schools selecting pupils by ability at age 11 due to testing may benefit MC children?
- MC pupils have the right speech code, they have cultural capital and can afford resources to better prepare themselves for the 11+ exams
- exams are just a snapshot of ability not day to day ability
What is wrong with schools selecting pupils by ability at age 11 due to those who fail being labelled?
- if a pupil fails the 11+ and goes to a secondary modern, they may see themselves as failures and lack self esteem = lack motivation to learn
What is the comprehensive school system in response to the tripartite system?
- introduced by the labour government to overcome the class divide of the tripartite system and make education more meritocratic
- 11+ exams were to be abolished
- grammar and secondary modern schools were replaced by comprehensive schools that would be attended by all schools in the area with the same experiences regardless of social class or background
How would functionalists view the comprehensive school system?
- in favour of comprehensive schools as it brings pupils together from different social classes = social solidarity
- meritocratic: all pupils are taught equally based on level and difficulty
How would marxists view the comprehensive school system?
- believe education is based on class division and capitalist exploitation so reject these schools for creating a myth or meritocracy
- comprehensive schooling cannot stop labelling or introducing streaminf
What is a limitation of the comprehensive schools system?
- did not exclude steaming and could not prevent labelling in schools which means that the achievement gaps still existed amongst different social classes
What is marketisation?
- policies that create competition between schools, meaning they are ran more like businesses
- these policies have created an educational market which has driven up standards
What is the education reform act?
- embraced neoliberal values and the new right ideas about competition and choice as ways of raising educational standards
- schools have to attract customers (parents/carers) by competing with eachother in the market
- those that provide customers with hat they want such as success in exams will thrive and those that do not will go out of business
What is the publication of league tables within the educational policy?
- publication of league tables rank each school according to its exam performance and give parents the information they need to choose the right school
- students will compete for better grades
What is open enrolment policy within the educational policy?
- meant that pupils could apply to go to any school within their area rather than being restricted by catchment areas
- this gave parents/carers greater choice over which school to send their child to
- parentocracy meant parents can influence how schools operate and ultimately become customers
What is introduction of the national curriculum within the educational policy?
- meant that all schools had to teach the same subjects between ages of 5-16
- all students had to study maths, english and science and some subjects became optional such as history, art and photography
What is standard assessment tests (SATS) within the educational policy?
- targets were set for children aged 7,11 and 14
- the O level and CSE examinations became combined into GCSE qualifications
What is formula funding within the educational policy?
- based on the number of enrolled pupils and a set amount of finances allocated to schools for each pupil
- schools will enroll more pupils to gain the school money / gain attraction to the school through exam results
What are OFSTED reports within the educational policy?
- schools inspected every 6 years to ensure the educational standards are met by every provider
- any areas for improvement have to be addressed by set deadline and improvements made to ensure high quality education for all pupils and continued by the central government
- made sure schools have specific standards and ensure they are being met
Why do the New Right support the introduction of marketisation policies?
- it drives up standards and creates a ‘fair choice’
Why do Marxists criticise the introduction of marketisation policies?
- say that parentocracy is a myth
What did David argue about parentocracy?
- argued that the move towards marketisation of education creates power shift from teachers and schools to parents, resulting in parentocracy (meaning ‘rule by parents’)
- david said this would lead to a fall in the amount of revenue for the unpopular schools and allow the successful and popular schools to expand
- this would result in schools being forced to raise their cane for fear of being left without any customers which would rise education standards
What is Bartletts idea of cream skimming and how does it reproduce inequality?
- where the best schools find ways to enroll the best pupils (eg MC ideal pupils)
- makes it unfair as these schools will out perform others in league tables and continue to be more popular
What is Bartletts idea of silt shifting and the spiral of decline and how does it reproduce inequality?
- where successful schools find ways of pushing less able pupils towards lower performing standards
- faith schools might focus on pupils who have been baptised as a requirement
- lower performing schools take on less able pupils which means results get worse and less people want to go = shut down which affects the WC pupils
What did Gewirtz say about parental choice in marketisation policies?
- claimed that marketisation policies benefit the MC parents whose economic and cultural capital puts them in a better position to choose the best schools for their children compared to WC parents
What was Gewirtz research into parental choice in marketisation policies and what did she find?
- 14 secondary schools in London
- identified 3 types of parents who make choice over their children’s education: privileged skilled choosers, disconnected local choosers and semi skilled choosers
What are privileged skilled choosers according to Gewirtz?
- well informed parents who have sufficient cultural capital to get their child into the chosen school
- usually MC
What are disconnected local choosers according to Gewirtz?
- tend to judge where their child should go to school on other factors (eg is it local?)
- usually WC
- avoid schools in other areas due to travel costs, choose school that offers free uniform
What are semi skilled choosers according to Gewirtz?
- they know what school they would like their child to go to but unsure how to achieve this
- usually upwardly mobile MC
- choose mid to high schools
What did Tough and Brooks say about covert selection?
- use the term covert selection to describe the process whereby schools try to discourage parents from lower socio economic backgrounds from applying by doing things such as:
- making school literature difficult to understand
- having lengthy application forms
- not publicising the school in poorer neighbourhoods
- requiring parents to buy expensive school uniforms
Why might MC parents be more able to manipulate the education system to their advantage? [5]
- they have a more sufficient cultural capital
- they are more financially stable
- can afford transport to schools in other areas
- can afford to live in houses where good schools are local
- more likely to be well educated so know how it works