Domestic Violence Flashcards
How does one obtain an injunction for protection against domestic violence?
The petitioner must be the victim of domestic violence or have reasonable cause to believe they are in imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence. The fear of imminent danger must be objectively reasonable
When is an incident too remote in time to support the issuance of an injunction for protection against domestic violence?
There is no bright line rule but courts seem to agree that one year is too remote in time if there are no current allegations.
What is the standard of review of a domestic violence injunction?
Abuse of discretion.
Who has standing to bring to seek an injunction for protection against DV?
Any family or household member who is either a victim of domestic violence or has reasonable cause to believe they are in imminent danger of becoming a victim of act of domestic violence has standing to seek a domestic violence injunction.
What is domestic violence?
Any assault, aggravated assault, battery, aggravated batter, sexual assault, sexual batter, stalking, aggravated stalking, kidnapping, false imprisonment or any criminal offense resulting in physical injury or death of one family or house member by another family or house member.
Who is a “family or house member” for purposes of DV?
- spouse
- former spouse
- persons related by blood or marriage
- persons who are presently residing together as if a family or who have resided together in the past as if a family
- persons who are parents of a child in common regardless if they were ever married
What is the one exception to the rule that family or house members must currently reside together or resided together in past for purposes of DV?
Parents who share a child in common.
Is an aunt who lived with kids and cared with them for one week while mom was in the hospital fit the definition of a household member within domestic violence?
Yes.
Could maternal grandfather who had temporary custody of grandchild seek domestic violence injunction against the child’s biological father?
No, maternal grandfather did not constitute a person having a child in common with bio daddy
BF & GF sleep over on occasion but have separate houses, can GF seek DV injunction against BF?
No, they are not household members under DV
How can a child seek injunction against a parent?
By and through a parent as “next friend”
Is there a residency requirement to seek DV
741.30(1)(j)
No minimum residency requirements - DV can be filed in a circuit where:
-petitioner currently or temporarily resides;
-where respondent resides;
- or where the DV occurred
Where can DV action be brought?
- Circuit where petitioner currently or temporarily resides
- where respondent resides, or
- where the DV occurred
When must objection to standing in a DV matter be raised?
Prior to entry of FJ - standing is waived if not raised at time of hearing.
If there is a DV action pending and a subsequently entered order in a family action is entered, what happens?
Subsequent orders in Chapter 61 take precedence over any inconsistent provisions of a DV injunction.
Is a bond required by petitioner for entry of an injunction?
NO - 741.30(2)(b)
Is a petitioner prevented from seeking an injunction if they leave the household ?
No - not penalized for leaving to avoid DV
If a Petitioner filed petition for injunction, can court make the injunction reciprocal?
No - no mutual orders. Each have to have their own separate petition for injunction
Is there a privilege between a victim and a domestic violence advocate?
90.5036
Yes - communication between DV advocate and DV victim is confidential if it is related to the incident of DV for which victim is seeking assistance and if it is not intended to be disclosed to a 3rd person other than:
1. someone who is going to further interest of victim in consult
2. persons whom disclosure is necessary to accomplish purpose for which dv advocate is consulted
In determining if whether petitioner has a reasonable cause to believe they are in imminent danger of becoming a victim of DV, what factors must court consider?
The court must consider all factors alleged in petition for injunction for protection against DV including, but not limited to:
1. history of parties - threats, harassment, stalking and physical abuse
2. if Respondent has attempted to harm Petitioner or family members or people close to Petitioner
3. if Respondent has threatened to conceal, kidnap or harm Petitioner’s kids
4. If Respondent has used or threaten to use weapons against Petitioner.
5. If Respondent has intentionally injured or killed family pet
6. If Respondent has physically restrained Petitioner from leaving home or calling cops
7. If Respondent has criminal history involving violence or threat of violence
8. existence of DV injunction in other jurisdictions
9. if Respondent has destroyed Petitioner’s personal property
10. If Respondent has engaged in any other conduct that would lead Petitioner to reasonably believe they are in imminent danger of becoming victim
COURT IS NOT LIMITED TO THESE FACTORS WHEN DETERMINING IF PETITIONER HAS REASONABLE CAUSE
What happens if court denies a temporary injunction without a hearing?
The court can deny a temp hearing but it must state legal grounds i.e. there is no basis for injunction and it must be memorialized by written order noting grounds of denial.
When / why will court deny a temp injunction on an ex parte basis?
Because it finds no appearance of immediate and present danger but court can set a full hearing
When can court consider ex parte temp injunction
When it appears to court that an immediate and present danger of DV exists.
What is the procedure if a temp ex parte injunction is granted?
- stays in place for no more than 15 days
- full hearing shall be set no later than when injunction expires
- court may grant continuance before or during hearing if good cause shown by either party - even to obtain service of process
- service shall be made by law enforcement
- any injunction shall be extended in event of continuance
Who must serve injunction?
Law enforcement. No private process servers.
What relief is possible under an ex parte temp injunction?
1.Restrain Respondent from committing any acts of DV against Petitioner or members of Petitioner’s family
2. no contact with Petitioner or family members
3. Award Petitioner temp exclusive use and possession of a shared home or exclude Respondent from Petitioner’s home
4. specify distance Respondent must stay away from Petitioner, the home,. school, work, kid’s school, places Petitioner goes,
5. Temporary custody of kids
6.Order Respondent to surrender fire warms
7. order any other relief necessary
What MUST occur for a final hearing on injunction?
- must be recorded
- court shall allow advocate from SAO to be present with Petitioner or Respondent
3.upon proper notice, when it appears to court that Petitioner is a victim of DV or has reasonable cause, court can grant relief as court deems necessary whether Respondent appears in court or not - may be granted whether Respondent shows up or not
How long can a final judgment of injunction for protection be effective?
- indefinitely until modified or dissolved by judge at either party’s request, upon notice and hearing or
- expire on a date certain at judge’s discretion
What MUST the FJ of Injunction for Protection provide?
- That Respondent cannot have firearms
- If they violate, it’s a misdemeanor
- Doesn’t apply to active officers (that would conflict with fed law)
Can a FJ of Injunction for Protection establish temporary support for child?
Yes, until injunction expires.
Can FJ of Injunction for Protection order counseling for children?
Yes
Can FJ of injunction order substance abuse or mental health evaluation for Respondent and order Respondent to seek treatment?
Yes
Can FJ of Injunction for Protection establish a Parenting Plan?
Yes.
Can FJ of Injunction for Protection establish alimony?
Yes
When SHALL court ordered Respondent to attend batter intervention program?
- finds Respondent willfully violated ex parte injunction
- Respondent has been convicted or had adjudication withheld plead no contest to a crime involving violence
- any time in past an injunction has been entered against Respondent with notice
UNLESS COURT MAKES WRITTEN FACTUAL FINDINGS BASED ON SUB COMP EVIDENCE AS TO WHY IT’ NOT ORDERING THIS RELIEF
What must all temp and FJ indicate?
- That the injunction is valid in all counties in FL
- law enforcement may use arrest powers
- court retains jurisdiction over parties and matters
- reasonable notice and opportunity to be heard was given to Respondent sufficient to protect due process
- date Respondent was served
- if FJ issued, terms of temporary extended until Respondent is served with FJ.
How can court enforce violation of injunction?
civil or criminal contempt and state can prosecute criminally
Can court impose monetary fine for noncompliance with injunction?
yes, pursuant to F.S. 741.30(9)(a)
What is the favored method of enforcing compliance with injunction?
Criminal prosecution.