Dispute Resolution Flashcards
What is the legal test required for a judge to grant a summary judgment?
a) There is no real prospect of the respondent successfully defending/bringing the claim; and
b) There is no other compelling reason why the matter should move to trial.
Is the judge’s power in relation to granting summary judgment discretionary or mandatory?
Discretionary
What is the legal test required for a judge to set aside a default judgment?
a) The defendant has a real prospect of successfully defending the claim; or
b) There is some other good reason why the judgment should be set aside and the defendant be allowed to defend the claim; AND
c) The defendant must have acted promptly.
In what circumstances is it mandatory for a judge to set aside a default judgment?
a) The judgment was entered too early;
b) The application was made after the defendant had made an application to strike out;
c) The claim has already been settled; or
d) The defendant has already submitted a request for time to pay which has not been considered.
What is the legal test required for a judge to grant a freezing injunction?
The court has a power to grant a freezing injunction if it is just and equitable.
The just and convenient test is used:
a) The claimant has a good and arguable case;
b) The defendant has assets within the jurisdiction; and
c) There is a real risk the defendant may dispose or dissipate those assets before judgment can be enforced.
Who can grant freezing injunctions?
Only High Court judges.
What is usually required alongside a freezing injunction?
An undertaking from the solicitor to pay consequential damages.
What can the defendant do if they wish to apply to discharge a freezing injunction?
Offer to pay security for the claim (e.g. into court).
What are the grounds for applying for a search order?
a) There must be a strong prima facie case on the merits of the underlying claim;
b) The defendant’s activities must cause very serious harm to the claimant’s interests; and
c) There must be clear evidence that the defendant holds the property and there is a real possibility the property might be destroyed before an application can be made on notice.
What will the court appoint in the event they grant a search order?
A supervising solicitor who will explain the meaning of the order to the defendant, explain the possibility of applying to discharge it, and to prepare a report on the execution of the order.
What are the grounds for an application for a security for costs?
The defendant must show:
a) The claimant is resident outside the jurisdiction;
b) The claimant is a company and there is reason to believe it will not be able to pay its costs if ordered to do so;
c) The claimant has changed address since the proceedings to avoid costs consequences; or
d) The claimant supplied the wrong address on the claim form.
What are the grounds for an application for an interim payment?
a) The defendant has admitted liability;
b) The claimant has obtained judgment and damages have not yet been assessed;
c) The court is satisfied that if the action were to proceed to trial the claimant would obtain judgment for a substantial amount; or
d) If 2 defendants, as (c) and both carry insurance.
What are the grounds for an application to strike out a statement of case?
a) There is no legal basis for the claim detailed in the statement of case;
b) It is an abuse of the court’s process; or
c) The claimant has failed to follow a rule or practice direction.
What are the consequences if a party fails to follow the relevant Pre-Action Protocol or Practice Direction?
There can be costs consequences, time consequences or restricted/higher interest order on damages.
When can pre-action disclosure be applied for?
When the documents would be disclosed under standard disclosure and doing so now could assist in disposing of the claim without the need to issue proceedings.
After the claim has been issued, how long does the claimant have to serve the claim form on the defendant?
4 months (6 if serving outside the jurisdiction, although permission is required).
After serving the claim form, how long does the claimant have to serve the Particulars of Claim if not served with the claim form?
14 clear days.
What are “clear days”?
The day that the document is sent is not included and, if in reference to an event at the end of the period, the day of the event is not included.
When is service deemed effectuated?
The second business day after having posted it. If by hand, service is immediate.
To whom should the claim form/PoC be served?
If the claimant is an individual and has nominated solicitors, it must be served on them. If the claimant is a company, then the registered office would also suffice.
How should the defendant challenge service?
Indicate it on the acknowledgement of service form and issue an application to set aside service within 14 days.
How long does a defendant have to respond to a claim?
The defendant has 14 days from when they receive the PoC to respond. They can acknowledge service via the acknowledgement of service form which grants them an additional 14 days.
What is the maximum amount of time the parties may agree to for a defence to be served without the court?
56 days.
When can the claimant make an application for summary judgment and/or for an interim payment?
After the defendant has acknowledged service.
How should the defendant dispute jurisdiction?
By ticking the relevant box on the acknowledgement of service form and filing an application with evidence in 14 days.
What is the overriding objective?
a) To ensure the parties are on an equal footing;
b) To save expense;
c) To deal with cases proportionately and expeditiously;
d) To allot the appropriate share of court resources; and
e) To enforce compliance with rules, practice directions and orders.
How long do the parties have to return the Directions Questionnaire?
28 days.
What are standard directions in a small claims hearing?
a) Documents are exchanged 14 days before a hearing; and
b) No expert may be used without the court’s permission.
When does the trial take place in a fast track claim?
Within 30 weeks of allocation.
How does expert evidence work in a fast track case?
The use of single joint experts is encouraged. A party seeking to rely on it will need to prove it is justified and provide an estimate of costs.
What are the standard directions in a fast track case?
Disclosure: 4 weeks
Witness statement exchange: 10 weeks
Expert report exchange: 14 weeks
Pre-trial checklist: 20 weeks
Pre-trial checklist returned: 22 weeks
Date of trial: 30 weeks
How long does a party have to apply to vary any directions?
14 days.
How should an innocent party respond if a party defaults on directions/a court order?
They should apply for an unless order.
What will the court consider if a party is applying for relief from sanctions?
a) The seriousness of the breach; and
b) The reasons for the breach.