Differential Diagnosis Flashcards
Differential diagnosis –
the process of narrowing possibilities and reaching conclusions about the nature of a deficit.
When doing a speech evaluation, should you always try to make a diagnosis?
Yes
Reasons for not being able to make a diagnosis include (2):
o Noncooperative patient
o Equivocal/uncertain findings
Why is it helpful to state what it is not in a diagnosis?
– i.e. if it is not ataxic – implies that there isn’t cerebellar involvement
- if it is not hypokinetic or hyperkinetic – there is no basal ganglia involvement
*can state these things
Is it helpful to establish that a dysarthria is present but that can’t specify the type?
Yes, if you cannot give a definitive diagnosis
If you can’t make a definitive diagnosis what should you do?
You must describe what you find, and state why a definitive diagnosis can’t be made
If a diagnosis is not determined should you offer a diagnosis?
No
You can state that the diagnosis is undetermined. Also using words such as “equivocal, probably, possible” give indications of how confident you are in your diagnosis
Make the speech diagnosis relate to:
- the suspected neurological diagnosis
- or suspected site of lesion
*It is helpful to the neurologist if the speech signs are not consistent with suspected diagnosis or site of lesion as well as when they are consistent with suspected diagnosis
Is it possible for more than one speech disorder to exist at the same time?
Yes,
*so just identifying a single disorder isn’t always sufficient.
- You must be able to account for all of the deviant characteristics – if the disorder you identified does not do this, then another disorder may be present
Does an evaluation always have to find deviant speech?
No.
it may indicate normal speech or speech within normal range
By providing a label for the diagnosis, you are providing:
a composite of information associated with that label
It is a kind of shorthand for communicating information about disorders
Is there is overlap among dysarthrias in terms of certain characteristics?
Yes
For example, many have imprecise articulation as a characteristic, so the presence of imprecise articulation DOESN’T HELP you in distinguishing between dysarthrias.
Are there also some characteristics that are unique to certain dysarthrias?
Yes
and these CAN be used to distinguish between dysarthrias.
Why might an evaluation come up with speech WNL but the patient still has a disorder (2)?
In the initial stages of some diseases, speech may have changed but not significantly enough to be judged deviant
It is also possible that the person may be incorrectly identifying a developmental problem of articulation as related to a neurological disease.
Etiologies (10):
1 Vascular
2 Degenerative disease
3 TBI
4 Surgical trauma
5 Toxic and metabolic conditions
6 Infectious and inflammatory conditions rarely cause dysarthrias
7 Demyelinating diseases
8 Anatomic malformations such as Arnold-Chiari (malformations of the brain)
9 Neuromotor junction disorders, muscle disease and neuropathies
10 OR in the absence of a neurologic diagnosis
Vascular –
can cause any type of dysarthria
Most often it causes spastic, UUMN, and ataxic dysarthia.
Hemorrhagic stroke is the most common cause of dysarthrias
Degenerative disease -
- also can cause any type of dysarthria
- Most often it causes spastic, ataxic, hypokinetic and flaccid dysarthrias
- ALS is a frequent cause of flaccid & spastic but other types of dysarthrias are not usually seen in ALS, so if there is another type of dysarthia existing, there may be another disease or the diagnosis of ALS may be in error.
- Also Parkinson’s is only associated with hypokinetic dysarthria
TBI –
- can cause any type of dysarthria
- but in closed head injury the most common type is spastic
- OHI do not usually cause flaccid dysarthria but can cause the other CNS dysarthrias (spastic, ataxic, UUMN).
- Skull fracture and neck traumas can cause flaccid dysarthrias, but not other types
Surgical trauma –
- can cause any type of dysarthia except hypokinetic.
- Surgeries involved with ear, nose throat, chest/cardiac areas are only associated with flaccid dysarthria.
- Neurosurgery can cause CNS dysarthrias as well as flaccid dyarthria
Toxic and metabolic conditions –
- do not typically cause flaccid or UUMN dysarthria but can cause the other types
- Toxic conditions associated with drugs/medications cause hyperkinetic and ataxic dysarthias most often
Infectious and inflammatory conditions -
- rarely cause dysarthrias although they sometimes do occur
- The type of dysarthria depends on the condition
Demyelinating diseases –
- can cause any type of dysarthria but hypokinetic is rare.
- The type of dysarthria depends on the disorder, Guillain Barre disease is usually associated with flaccid whereas
- MS is usually associated with ataxic dysarthria