Depression Flashcards
Unipolar depression
Biological explanation - Monoamine theory
- The monoamine hypothesis claims that low level of monoamines cause depression.
- Monoamines consist of noradrenaline/norepinephrine, dopamine and serotonin.
- Serotonin regulates the other neurotransmitters, so low levels of serotonin leads to lower levels of dopamine.
- Low levels of serotonin cause erratic brain function and thought patterns.
- Low levels of noradrenaline cause lower levels of alertness and arousal, symptoms of depression.
- Low levels of dopamine cause lack of concentration and focus.
- Low levels of monoamines could be caused because the reuptake mechanism recaptures the neurotransmitters before they reach the receptor sites.
- Depressed people could release too much monoamine oxidase so the monoamines are broken down too fast.
Unipolar depression
Evidence for biological explanation
- Drevets et al (1999) found reduced serotonin receptor-binding potential in unmedicated depressed patients.
- Versiani et al (1999) found that patients who had noradrenaline reuptake inhibitors increased their mood if changing the biology can reduce symptoms there may be a biological cause.
- Bunney et al (1970) found that urinary levels of noradrenaline decreased during episodes of depression.
- Bell et al (2001) depleted levels of tryptophan and found this caused a relapse of symptoms in depressed patients showing that changing the biology of a person can cause the symptoms of unipolar depression.
- Delgado (2000) found that monoamine depletion did not make symptoms worse in depressed patients not taking medication.
- Angoa-Perez (2014) found that mice without the gene for tryptophan did not show signs of depression.
- Delgado et al (1990) used a special diet to lower the level of tryptophan found that depressive symptoms returned for 67% of ppts.
- Anti-depressants which increase the monoamines alleviate depression showing reduced monoamines are a possible cause.
- However, the level of neurotransmitters rises very quickly once an individual is on medication.
- There are alternative theories such as the cognitive therefore it is not the only explanation.
Unipolar depression
Symptoms
Emotional
- Lowered mood and self esteem.
- Anger - negative emotions are more common than positive symptoms.
Motivational
- Activity levels - reduced energy levels which makes them lethargic. This leads to withdrawal from work, education and social life.
Somatic
- Disruption to sleep and eating behaviours
Cognitive
- Poor concentration
- Dwelling on the negative - focus on negative aspects of a situation
- Absolutist thinking - see unfortunate events as a disaster/
Prevalence of depression
- Population - Kesler et al (1994) 10% of adults in the US suffer from severe unipolar depression in any given year, while another 3-5% suffer from mild forms.
Smith et al found similar stats for Canada, England and other countries. - Age of onset - Weismann et al (1992) - average age of onset is 27 in the USE but dropped with each generation from 1915. Severe unipolar depression may develop at any age.
- Gender - Weismann et al (1991) in most industrialised countries women are twice as likely to suffer from severe episodes of unipolar depression than men. 26% of women may have severe episodes at some point in their life compared with 12% of men.
- Goldberg (1995) most who do recover are likely to have at least one subsequent episode of depression within lifetime.
Unipolar depression
Evaluation of monoamine hypothesis
- incomplete, describes depression in great depth but not where it comes from. This also applies to cognitive theory which explains depressive thought patterns but only vague ideas why some people develop pessimistic explanatory styles or negative schema’s but others don’t.
- Twin studies and adoption studies do not show 100% concordance rate. This suggests something non-biological is also a factor, like the environment a person lives in. Genes may give predisposition but require a trigger to bring the symptoms out.
- Thase et al (2002) found that depresses patients had increased levels of noradrenaline. This is the opposite of what monoamine theory predicts.
- Twin studies studies show evidence of a genetic aspect to depression. This is because depression is more common in people who are related to depressives than in the general population.
Unipolar depression
Biological treatment - MAOIs
- When released into the synapse serotonin and noradrenaline are broken down by the enzyme monoamine oxidase.
- This reduces the amount of serotonin and noradrenaline .
- MAOI’s inhibit the action of monoamine oxidase so results in higher levels or serotonin in the synapse
Unipolar depression
Evaluation of biological treatment - MAOIs
- Seen as being least effective.
- According to Bennett (2006) they have 50% success rate.
- Side effects include blood pressure and increased risk or cerebral hemorrhage, especially if taken with yeast products, fish and bananas.
Unipolar depression
Biological treatment - Tricyclics
- Serotonin and noradrenaline are released into the synapse.
- On the pre-synaptic side where there are re-uptake sites that absorb chemicals.
- Tricyclics act by blocking these sites so more serotonin and noradrenaline is available in the synapse for a longer period of time
Unipolar depression
Evaluation of biological treatment - Tricyclics
- Have 60-65% success rate.
- They work on serotonin and noradrenaline pathways, thus have similar side effects. For, example sexual problems, effect the heart and arteries, dry mouth, blurred vision.
- Potentially lethal in large doses.
Unipolar depression
Biological treatment - SSRI’s
- Inhibit re-uptake, but are selective to serotonin.
- Treats in the inadequate amount of serotonin in the synaptic gap. This is needed for effective neurotransmitter to occur.
- SSRI’s work to prevent re-uptake of serotonin, this makes it stay in the synaptic gap longer which makes the serotonin more efficient.
Unipolar depression
Side effects of biological treatment - SSRI’s
- Only alter one pathway, so there is fewer side effects.
- Almost impossible to overdose on SSRI’s.
- The most experienced side are dry mouth and constipation however extreme violence and murder have been reported.
- There have been 250,000 reported cases of suicide, 25,000 of which have been successful. However according to Fergusson et al (2005) there is greater likelihood of suicide with tricyclics.
Unipolar depression
Evaluation of biological treatment - SSRI’s
- All these drugs take weeks to work which suggests their mechanism of action is far more complex than inhibiting re-uptake of serotonin.
- SSRI’s may work by altering the serotonin system in the brain. Some even believe that there is a change to the natural growth in the hippocampus.
Unipolar depression
Effectiveness of biological treatment - SSRI’s
Hollen et al (2005)
- Depressed patients were treated for 16 weeks.
They recieved either: an SSRI or cognitive therapy.
- Similar numbers of each group showed considerable improvement.
Hollen et al (2005)
- Then picked up and followed these successes for 12 months.
- When cognitive therapy therapy was stopped and no further treatment was received, relatively few sufferers relapsed into depression. This suggests that cognitive therapy has dealt with the cause of depression.
- When drug therapy was given and maintained relapse rate is relatively low which suggests the drugs are working.
- 76% relapse when drugs are withdrawn. This confirms that drugs are fine until medication stops. During the prescribed period the drugs reduced symptoms but did not deal with the causes, if they did the patient should be fine when medication was stopped.
- Drugs appear to be palliative.
- Effectiveness dropped from 60% to below 20% in those who had previously been prescribed similar drugs.
Unipolar depression
Cognitive treatment - CBT
- Aims to help people become aware of negative interpretations.
- Overcome depressive thoughts by changing maladpative interpretations by considering alternative thoughts.
- Cognitive theory helps people develop alternative ways of thinking and behaving which aims to reduce their psychological distress.
Unipolar depression
Beck cognitive theory- CBT
- 3 mechanisms: cognitive triad, errors in logic and schemata
- Cognitive triad:
Consists of negative thoughts
Unpleasant experiences are attributed to personal worthlessness.
Depressive, negative thoughts about experience consist in the interpretation that when somethings happens, it is perceived to be bad. - Genetic factors and early experiences affect thinking and schemata are built from interactions and experiences, involves developing positive and negative beliefs to interpret the world.
- A generalised negative belief will make someone vulnerable to depression.