death and the afterlife Flashcards
Parousia
the second coming of Christ
Election
God choosing the saved
Purgatory
place/state of cleansing sin before heaven > not biblical so causes problems for Protestants (whose authority is purely the Bible)
Beatific Vision
meeting God face to face
Resurrection
restored in bodily form
‘bury me as you wish […] when I…’
‘bury me as you wish […] when I drink the poison I will no longer remain with you, but shall go off and depart for some happy state of the blessed’ - Socrates as recounted by Plato
- Greek influence
- the immaterial soul continues independently from the physical body
‘Multitudes who sleep in the…’
‘Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will wake: some to everlasting life, other to shame and everlasting contempt.’ - Daniel, 12:2
- written (probably) as encouragement for Jews prosecuted for their faith (old testament, 165BC)
- the same body will be used for resurrection
- collective, delayed judgement
- restoration of justice to the Jewish people
Biblical roots for the idea of future resurrection
- if God is brings living creatures into being, and God is eternal, then isn’t life eternal? Even for those who die?
- the Bible tells several instances of prophets restoring life to those who have died eg. Elijah and his disciple Elisha so why can’t God do the same?
- the Bible also talks about how God would restore the nation of Israel, his chosen people (misunderstood as a prophecy of the death and resurrection of Jesus by Christian interpreters)
> the passage refers to a “suffering servant” of the Lord
> doesn’t refer to Jesus or the messiah directly at all
What is the Christian view of the afterlife?
- influenced by the concept of bodily resurrection
- adopted by the pharisees and cemented by the recordings of Jesus’ resurrection
- the recordings indicate a real, physical existence in a human body, perhaps one that is spiritually perfect and immortal
- the afterlife this body will inhabit is understood to be a concept known as the Kingdom of God
What did early Christian writers generally agree on?
- Jesus’ resurrection did not mark the end of the world but the beginning of the Jesus movement and the foundation of Christianity
- Jesus’ resurrection was a moment of hope
- Jesus’ resurrection was a moment in which God acted in a mysterious and spectacular way
> As time went on the early Christians reflected on these ideas and began to give them greater theological and philosophical emphasis.
What did Jesus teach about death?
- not just about immortality but the establishment of a new world order
- his life was a sacrifice for sin
- his death would prompt God to establish a new world order/kingdom
- he would be raised up with the saints and martyrs who had died before him and his followers would have a place in the new kingdom
‘The time is fulfilled, and…’
‘The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God has come near.’ - Mark, 1:14
‘Truly I tell you, there are some standing…’
‘Truly I tell you, there are some standing here who will not taste death until they see that the kingdom has come with power.’ - Mark, 9:1
- possibly driven by political motives (overthrowing the Roman empire in a lifetime)
‘But if it is by the finger of…’
‘But if it is by the finger of God that I cast out the demons, then the kingdom of God has come to you.’ - Luke, 11:20
‘My kingdom is not of…’
‘My kingdom is not of this earth’ - John 18:35
- suggests a spiritual kingdom which contradicts other passages
- Reza Aslan suggests this is a bad translation
What did many early Christians expect after Jesus’ ascension?
- they were living on the threshold of a new era
- seem to have expected the resurrected Jesus to return shortly and herald in the new glorious state
- parousia when God would judge the world and select those who have lived a good life to live eternally in restored and renewed world
Book of Revelations’ description of the Kingdom of God
- fullest descriptions of the restored world
- no more suffering and new heavenly Jerusalem would descend to Earth as a symbol of the renewed world
- ‘Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth; for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more.’ - Book of Revelation, 21:1-4
- ‘Death shall be no more; mourning and crying and pain will be no more, for the first things have passed away.’ - Book of Revelations, 21:1-4
‘Then I saw a new heaven and…’
‘Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth; for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more.’ - Book of Revelation, 21:1-4
‘Death shall be no…’
‘Death shall be no more; mourning and crying and pain will be no more, for the first things have passed away.’ - Book of Revelations, 21:1-4
what are the possible interpretations for what Jesus meant by the Kingdom of God?
- an actual place
- a spiritual state
- a symbol of the moral life
What is ‘inaugurated eschatology’?
- scholars used the term to refer to the way Jesus presented the Kingdom of God as if it had already started
- eg. Jesus’ healing miracles
- St Paul argues that Jesus’ resurrection is the first sign that the fallen world is restored and that humans can at last ‘see’ God face to face (1 Corinthians)
What did Jesus preach about the new Kingdom of God?
- that the future Kingdom is a state where the righteous live in perfect harmony with God in a redeemed world.
What did St Paul argue about the Kingdom of God?
- that Jesus’ resurrection is the first sign that the fallen world is restored and that humans can at last ‘see’ and ‘know’ God face to face (1 Corinthians 13:12)
- that before Christ, humans were only able to see the future heavenly state dimly or through a ‘dark glass’ but now it is possible to glimpse what the future will look like ‘clearly’
Hades
- The Gospel of Matthew in particular refers to the state of hell as Hades and sometimes as Gehenna
- (in Greek thought) Hades was a shadowy half existence of human spirits after death awaiting judgement
- The Old Testament equivalent to Hades is Sheol, the underworld of departed spirits
- Matthew combines all these ideas to warn the unrighteous that the state of hell is fire, torment, wailing and lament
Gehenna
- The Gospel of Matthew in particular refers to the state as Hades and sometimes as Gehenna
- often translated as hell
- in later Jewish thought, Gehenna was a place of torment and suffering for the wicked
- Matthew combines all these ideas to warn the unrighteous that the state of hell is fire, torment, wailing and lament
How does the Book of Revelation describe hell?
- a lake of fire.
- Eg. the story of The Richman and Lazarus
- Some scholars suggest that the rich man may have been a wealthy Sadducee (a priest who maintains the Temple in Jerusalem and does not believe in the afterlife.
Issues with the Christian notion of the afterlife
- there has not been a new Kingdom of God yet
- misinterpretation of the “suffering servant”
- contradiction as to whether the Kingdom is actual, spiritual, or symbolic > there is also no clear picture of heaven and hell, maybe not what JC was talking about
buddhist criticism of Christian ideas of the afterlife
> ‘Transient are all compound things […] sorrowful are all compound things […] all things are without self’ - The Buddha (Anatta - not having self)
Christian reliance on continued existence of self is an illusion and prevents us from reaching enlightenment
arguably this is a dehumanising idea
Jesus’ discussion with the non-apocalyptic Sadducees
[Mark 12:18-27]
- the Sadducees propose a situation where a woman would be resurrected with multiple husbands due to the Law of Moses
- Jesus said they didn’t understand the Scripture
- instead, no one will be married at the resurrection since those who are raised will be ‘like the angels in heaven’ - unmarried and, presumably, eternally happy about it