Criticisms of Irenaean Theodicy

Question 1

Summary of Criticisms

Answer 1

1. Do the ends justify the means?
2. Does all suffering result in moral growth?
3. Is universal salvation fair?

Question 2

Do the ends justify the means?

Answer 2

• It is not acceptable to do something bad to achieve something good.
• Then why is it okay for God to create an imperfect word for a higher goal?

Question 3

Does all suffering result in moral growth?

Answer 3

• Some people do not morally develop as a result of suffering, but instead morally degrade.
• Can indiscriminate suffering lead to moral growth?

Question 4

Universal Salvation

Answer 4

• If everyone makes it to heaven, what is the motivation to be moral?
• Does one’s actions really have any consequences?