Criminal Procedure Flashcards
What are the 2 exceptions to the rule that constitutional protections only apply to govt. actions?
1) when a private person is acting as a govt. agent
2) defense attorneys (both private and public) are treated as govt. actors for 6th Amendment assistance of counsel analysis
what is a seizure?
when a cop, through use of physical contact or show of authority, intentionally restrains somebody’s freedom of movement
how do you test whether a seizure has occurred?
Depends on whether a reasonable innocent person would feel free to disregard the cop and leave
What is the basis for a stop and frisk/Terry stop?
when the cop has a reasonable suspicion based on articulable facts to believe the suspect is or is about to engage in criminal conduct
What can an officer search for in a Terry stop?
They can pat you down for weapons, but they can’t frisk and search you for evidence
If the pat down reveal objects whose shapes make their identity obvious (weapon, contraband, etc.), the cop can seize them
How does the legality of a Terry stop affect the admissibility of the evidence at trial?
If the basis for the stop was illegal but the officer develops a valid basis for an arrest during the frisking, the evidence found is still admissible at trial.
If the stop was unlawful and a valid basis for an arrest doesn’t develop, then the evidence is inadmissible at trial.
what is the basis for a vali traffic stop?
cop must have reasonable suspicion.
Once the stop occurs, the cop can search an occupant for weapons if they have a reasonable basis to believe the occupant is armed
what is needed for a valid basis to arrest?
Cop must have probable cause to believe that the arrestee committed a crime
What are the elements for a valid arrest warrant?
1) issued by a detached and neutral magistrate/judge
2) must be probable cause to believe the named arrestee committed a crime
3) warrant must identify the arrestee and offense they’re being arrested for
When can police arrest someone in their dwelling without an arrest warrant?
1) Exigent Circumstances (felony hot pursuit, danger to others, etc.)
2) Consent
Can an arrest warrant give police a valid basis to enter the arrestee’s home?
Yes, they can enter the arrestee’s home for the purpose of arresting him/her.
But they can’t continue to search the arrestee’s home, unless one of the warrant exceptions applies
What are the 2 bases for allowing a search incident to arrest?
1) To prevent the destruction and/or concealment of evidence
2) To protect cops from weapons the arrestee could have on them
When can police warrantlessly arrest someone?
1) If they personally witness the arrestee commit a crime
2) If it’s a felony, if the cop has probable cause to believe the arrestee committed the felony
(if it’s a misdemeanor, the cop needs to have actually witnessed it or have an arrest warrant)
When can a cop search a person incident to arrest?
If the arrest is legal, the cop can search the arrestee and the immediate area around the arrestee (arrestee’s wingspan).
What are the specific rules for a search incident to arrest in a vehicle?
If the arrestee is still near the car and unrestrained, the cop, after initiating a lawful arrest, can search the passenger compartment of the car
Do police need a warrant to search a person’s cell phone incident to an arrest?
Yes. Police can seize your cell phone incident to arrest, but they can’t unlock and search through it without a search warrant or consent
what places do you have a reasonable expectation of privacy?
1) your home
2) your hotel room
3) your office
4) your backyard/curtilage
5) your luggage
For what kinds of areas do you not have a reasonable expectation of privacy?
1) abandoned property
2) open fields
3) public streets
4) garbage cans left out on the street
5) bank records
6) things left in plain view
7) inmate’s cell
8) smells emanating from yourself or your property
What are the requirements for getting a search warrant?
1) issued by a neutral magistrate
2) probable cause to believe the items sought are evidence of a crime, fruits of a crimes, or instrumentalities of a crime
3) warrant must describe the property and placed to be searched with some particularity
What is the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine?
If evidence is obtained during an illegal search, that evidence is excluded from the prosecutor’s case
What are the exceptions to the warrant requirement for a valid search?
1) automobile exception
2) search incident to arrest
3) consent
4) exigent circumstances
5) stop and frisk
6) plain view
7) evidence obtained from administrative searches (health inspections of a restaurant, TSA searches, etc.)
How does a search incident to arrest work when the arrestee is being arrested in their own home?
The police can do a protective sweep of the immediate area surrounding the arrestee for weapons or evidence
What is the automobile exception to the warrant requirement?
If police have probable cause to believe that a vehicle contains contraband, they can search the parts of the vehicle where the contraband could be located
this excludes any area in the car where the contraband couldn’t reasonably be located (ex. looking for an illegal bazooka inside the glovebox)
If multiple people in a dwelling disagree about giving an officer consent to search the home, how does that affect the occupants?
The police cannot use any evidence/contraband they find against a person who affirmatively refuses to give consent to search the home
what is the definition of a “search”?
A government intrusion into an area where someone has a reasonable expectation of privacy
what is the precedent set by Miranda v. Arizona?
statements made as the result of a custodial interrogation are inadmissible unless they are accompanied by safeguards, i.e., the Miranda warnings
When is an interrogation “custodial”?
The person being questioned has either been arrested or is otherwise not free to leave
How can a person invoke their right to remain silent?
They must affirmatively assert the right. Once they do, the police must stop interrogating them, but they can come back after a substantial amount of time has passed and resume the questioning
What makes a questioning an “interrogation” for Miranda purposes?
when the official engages conduct and/or questioning that a police officer would or should know would elicit a response.
How can a person invoke their right to counsel?
They must affirmatively invoke the right (say “I want an attorney).
If someone invokes the right to counsel, the cops must stop the interrogation and cannot re-initiate the interrogation unless the suspect initiates conversation again or the lawyer is present.
what is the public safety exception to the Miranda requirements?
Police don’t have to Mirandize a suspect before questioning if public safety is at risk (ex. ticking time bomb)
Are statements obtained in violation of Miranda admissible?
They aren’t admissible as evidence in the prosecution’s case, although they can be used for impeaching the defendant