Criminal Law Rules Flashcards
A state has jurisdiction over a crime if:
- Any act constituting an element of the offense was committed in the state
- An act outside the state caused a result in the state
- The crime involved the neglect of a duty imposed by the law of the state
- There was an attempt or conspiracy outside the state plus an act inside the state, or
- There was an attempt or conspiracy inside the state to commit an offense outside the state
Merger Common Law
- If convicted of a felony and a misdemeanor then the charge would merge into the felony
Modern Merger
- No merger of crimes generally
- Solicitation merges if the crime is committed
- Attempt merges if the crime is committed
MPC Merger
- D may not be convicted of more than one inchoate crime (attempt, conspiracy, solicitation)
Felony vs. Misdemeanor
Felony: punishable by death or imprisonment for more than 1 year
Misdemeanor: all other crimes
Elements of a crime
- A physical act (actus reus)
- a mental state (mens rea)
- A concurrence of the act and the mental state
Nonvoluntary movement examples
- A reflexive or convulsive act
- An act performed while unconscious or asleep
- Conduct that is not the product of the person’s own volition
Physical Act (Actus Reus)
- D either performed a voluntary physical act or failed to act under circumstances imposing a legal duty to act
- Any bodily movement
Omission as an act gives rise to liability only if:
- there is a legal duty to act
- the defendant has knowledge of the facts giving rise to the duty to act; and
- it is reasonably possible to perform the duty
How is a duty to act created
- By statute
- By contract
- the relationship between the parties (child/parent; Spouse)
- the voluntary assumption of care by the defendant for the victim
- the d created the peril for the victim
Specific Intent
- A crime that requires the act to be done with specific intent or objectives
- Can be inferred from the manner in which the crime was committed
- Qualify for defense of voluntary intoxication and unreasonable mistake of fact
Specific Intent Crimes (Students can always fake a laugh even for ridiculous bar facts)
- Solicitation
- Conspiracy
- Attempt
- First degree premeditated murder
- Assault
- Larceny
- Embezzlement
- False pretenses
- Robbery
- Burglary
- Forgery
Malice Crimes
- Common Law Murder and Arson
- Requires a reckless disregard of an obvious or high risk that the particular harmful result will occur
- Defenses to specific intent do not apply to malice
General Intent Crimes
- Jury may infer the required general intent merely from doing of the act
- catch-all for all crimes that aren’t specific intent and malice
Strict Liability Offenses
- D can be found guilty from the mere fact that they committed the act.
- Selling liquor to minors, statutory rape
- Will give a statute and there are no adverbs such as knowingly, willfully, or intentionally
MPC Categories of Intent
- Purposely
- Knowingly
- Recklessly
- Negligently
Purposely Intent
- A person acts purposely when their conscious object is to engage in certain conduct
Knowingly Intent
A person acts knowingly when they are aware their conduct is of a particular nature or that certain circumstances exist and their conduct will necessarily or very likely cause a particular result
- Can be aware if know of a high probability and deliberately avoid learning the truth
Reckless Intent
A person acts recklessly when they consciously disregard a substantial and unjustifiable risk and this disregard constitutes a gross deviation for a reasonable standard of care
Negligence
- A person acts negligently when they fail to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk and the failure is a substantial deviation from the reasonable standard of care
Transferred Intent
- D can be liable if they intend the harm that is caused but to a different person (i shoot at 1 person but hit another)
- Can be charged with crime and attempt for other person
Causation
- Cause In-Fact
- Proximate Causation
Common Law Parties to a Crime
- Principal in the first degree
- Principal in the second degree
- Accessories before the fact
- Accessories after the fact
Modern View Parties to a Crime
- All parties to the crime can be found guilty of the principal offense
- Principal: one who, with the requisite mens rea, engages in the act or omission that causes the criminal result
- Accomplice: one who aids, advises, or encourages the principal in the commission of the crime charged
- Accessory after the fact: someone who assists after the fact
Mental State for Accomplice Liability
- The intent to assist the principal in the commission of a crime
- the intent that the principal commit the substantive offense
- If mens rea is recklessness or negligence then the accomplice must have acted with recklessness or negligence as well
Scope of Accomplice Liability
- Responsible for the crimes they were a part of and other crimes that were probable or foreseeable
Exceptions from Accomplice Liability
- Members of the protected class of the statute
- Necessary parties not provided for in the statute
- Withdrawal
Conspiracy Elements
(1) an agreement between two or more persons; (2) an intent to enter into the agreement, (3) an intent by at least two persons to achieve the objective of the agreement. A majority of states require an overt act, but an act of mere preparation will suffice.
MPC Unilateral Conspiracy Approact
- Requires that only one personal have genuine criminal intent
Common Law Bilateral Approach
- A conspiracy requires at least two “guilty minds” if one person is faking then the other person cannot be convicted of conspiracy
Termination of Conspiracy
- Usually terminates upon completion of the wrongful objective
Liability of Co-Conspirators Crimes
(1) crimes were committed in furtherance of the objectives of the conspiracy and (2) were foreseeable
Non Defenses to Conspiracy
- Withdrawal is not a defense to conspiracy but can be in furtherance of the conspiracy. Must perform an affirmative act
- Factual Impossibility is not a defense
Solicitation Elements
- Asking, inciting, counseling, advising, urging or commanding another to commit a crime, with the intent that the person solicited commit the crime
Attempt Elements
(1) specific intent to commit a crime
(2) an overt act in furtherance of the crime
Overt Act for Attempt
Must commit an act beyond mere preparation.
- Traditional view requires the act to be dangerously close to completion of the crime.
- modern view requires the act is a substantial step in the commission of the crime