Criminal Law Flashcards
General Matters: How does a state acquire jurisdiction over a case in criminal law?
A state acquires jurisdiction over a crime if EITHER the CONDUCT and/or the RESULT happened in that state
General Matters: Merger + Exception + Remember Conspiracy
Generally, there is NO MERGER of crimes
Exception: SOLICITATIONS and ATTEMPTS DO MERGE into the substantive offense (e.g. you cannot be convicted of attempting to commit a crime AND that crime)
Remember; Conspiracy does NOT merge into the substantive offense, and therefore you may be charged with both
Essential Elements of Crime: Elements of Crimes Generally
1) Act (actus reus)
2) Mental state (mens rea)
3) Concurrence (physical act and mental act at same time)
4) Harmful result and causation
Essential Elements of Crime: Physical Act Definition + Non Act Examples
An act can be ANY bodily movement, but MUST be voluntary
Examples: 1) Reflexive or convulsive acts (e.g. seizure), 2) Unconscious or asleep acts
Essential Elements of Crime: Omission as an Act Circumstances
Generally, there is no legal duty to rescue, BUT a legal duty to act can arise in any of the following 5 circumstances:
1) By statute (e.g. filing tax returns)
2) By employment contract (e.g. nurse or lifeguard)
3) Relationship between the parties (e.g. parents duty to protect children)
* *4) Fail to adequately perform after assuming duty of care
* *5) Where your conduct created the peril
** = most popular on MBE
Essential Elements of Crime: Common Law Mental States of a Crime + Remember Additional Defenses for Specific Intent Crimes
1) specific intent crimes
2) malice crimes
3) general intent crimes
4) strict liability crimes
Remember: 1) voluntary intoxication, and 2) unreasonable mistake of fact - these are ONLY available for specific intent crimes
Essential Elements of Crime: Specific Intent Crimes + Tip Mnemonic
Students (solicitation) Can (conspiracy) Always (attempt) (the inchoate offenses) \_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_ Fake (first-degree murder) A (assault) Laugh (larceny), Even (embezzlement) For (false pretenses) Ridiculous (robbery) Bar (burglary) Facts (forgery)
Essential Elements of Crime: Malice Definition Crimes
1) Murder (common law murder, a.k.a. second-degree murder)
2) arson
Essential Elements of Crime: General Intent Definition + Crimes
General intent means D has a GENERAL AWARENESS that she is acting in a manner that would be prohibited by law
All crimes not specific intent or malice are general intent crimes, unless they qualify for strict liability
Essential Elements of Crime: Strict Liability + Remember Defenses of No Intent + Tip to Find Strict Liability Crimes by Statutory Reading
No intent needed to be guilty of strict liability crimes, therefore any defense negating intention will be unsuccessful
Tip: If the crime is administrative, regulatory, or morality area AND you don’t see adverbs such as “knowingly, willfully, or intentionally” then the statute is meant to be a no intent crime of strict liability
Essential Elements of Crime: Model Penal Code - Purposely Definition
One acts purposely when it is his CONSCIOUS OBJECTIVE to engage in certain conduct or cause a certain result
Essential Elements of Crime: Model Penal Code - Knowingly Definition
One acts knowingly when he is AWARE that his conduct will very likely cause the result
Essential Elements of Crime: Model Penal Code - Recklessly Definition
One acts recklessly when he CONSCIOUSLY DISREGARDS a SUBSTANTIAL AND UNJUSTIFIABLE risk
Essential Elements of Crime: Model Penal Code - Negligently Definition
One acts negligently when he fails to be aware of a SUBSTANTIAL and UNJUSTIFIABLE risk
Essential Elements of Crime: Concurrence Requirement
D must have had the intent necessary for the crime AT THE TIME he committed the act
Essential Elements of Crime: Causation Requirement
Some crimes (e.g. homicide) require a harmful result and causation, thus when a crime requires conduct and specified result, D’s conduct must be both the ACTUAL CAUSE and PROXIMATE CAUSE
Accomplice Liability: Parties to a Crime & Definition - Common Law
1) Principals in the 1st Degree - persons who actually ENGAGE IN THE ACT that constitutes the criminal offense;
2) Principals in the 2nd Degree - persons who aid, advise, or encourage the principal and ARE PRESENT at the crime;
3) Accessories before the fact - persons who aid, advise, or encourage the principal but ARE NOT PRESENT at the crime
4) Accessories after the fact - persons who assist the principal AFTER the crime
Accomplice Liability: Parties to a Crime - Modern Statutes
Most jurisdictions ABOLISHED the distinctions between principals in 1st and 2nd degree and accessories after and before the fact. They define parties as one of the two:
1) Principal - one who, with the requisite mental state, actually engages in the act or omission that causes the criminal result
2) Accomplice - one who AIDS, ADVISES, or ENCOURAGES the principal in the commission of the crime charged
3) Accessory after the fact - one who receives, comforts, or assists another knowing the he has committed a felony in order to help the felon escape the arrest, trial, or conviction
Accomplice Liability: Mental State Required for Accomplice Liability
In order to be convicted of a substantive crime as an accomplice, the accomplice MUST have:
1) The INTENT TO ASSIST the principal in the commission of the crime, AND
2) the INTENT that the principal commit the crime
Accomplice Liability: Scope of Liability
An accomplice is responsible for the crimes SHE COMMITTED or AIDED/ADVISED/ENCOURAGED and for OTHER CRIMES that were committed if PROBABLE and FORESEEABLE
Accomplice Liability: Accomplices and Withdrawal (Encouraged v. Aided) + Remember One Withdrawal Method that Always Works
Encouraged: If the person encouraged the crime, the person MUST REPUDIATE the encouragement
Aided: If the person aided by providing assistance, he must do EVERYTHING POSSIBLE TO NEUTRALIZE this assistance (e.g. retrieve materials)
Remember: An alternate means of withdrawing is to CONTACT THE POLICE
Inchoate Offenses: Conspiracy Definition + Remember Agreement Options
Conspiracy is an agreement, with an intent to agree, and an intent to pursue an UNLAWFUL OBJECTIVE
Remember: Agreement NEED NOT be expressed, intent CAN BE INFERRED from conduct
Inchoate Offenses: Conspiracy - No Merger Rule
Conspiracy DOES NOT MERGE into the substantive offense, therefore you can be convicted of conspiring to do something A D actually doing it (e.g. robbery and conspiracy to commit robbery)
Inchoate Offenses: Conspiracy - Agreement Approaches
1) Bilateral approach (common law) - the traditional rule required TWO guilty parties. Therefore, if one person in a two party conspiracy is feigning agreement, the other CANNOT BE GUILTY of conspiracy. (the acquittal of all persons but one alleged to conspire PRECLUDES CONVICTION of the remaining D)
2) Unilateral approach (MPC approach) - requires that ONLY ONE person have a genuine criminal intent
Inchoate Offenses: Conspiracy - Overt Act Requirement (Majority v. Minority Rule) + Remember Mere Preparation
Majority Rule (MPC): There must be an AGREEMENT PLUS SOME OVERT ACT in furtherance of the conspiracy
Remember: Even an act of MERE PREPARATION would constitute an overt act (e.g. buying a black glove)
Minority Rule (common law): Liability for conspiracy is grounded with THE AGREEMENT ITSELF
Inchoate Offenses: Conspiracy - Factual Impossibility + Remember Rule for Other Inchoate Offenses
Factual impossibility IS NO DEFENSE to conspiracy
Remember: Factual impossibility is NEVER a defense to inchoate crimes
Inchoate Offenses: Conspiracy - Withdrawal
Withdrawal, even if adequate, CAN NEVER relieve the D from liability for the conspiracy itself, BUT may withdraw them from liability for subsequent crimes
Inchoate Offenses: Solicitation + Remember Common Law Agreement Requirement + Remember Merger
Solicitation is ASKING someone to commit a crime
Remember: Under common law, it IS NOT necessary that the person AGREE to commit the crime
Remember: If you ask a person to commit the crime, and the person agrees to do it, solicitation merges INTO CONSPIRACY