Criminal Law Flashcards
Crim MBE Review Done MBE Final Review Done.
Bodily movements that do NOT qualify for criminal liability
- Conduct is not the product of your own volition.
- It’s REFLEXIVE or CONVULSIVE
- An act performed while you are unconscious or asleep.
Jurisdiction over crimes
A state acquires jurisdiction over a crime if either CONDUCT or RESULT happened in that state.
An omission as a criminal act (5 circumstances)
Generally, no legal duty to rescue. But sometimes there is a duty to act.
- By statute (ex. file taxes)
- By contract (a lifeguard or nurse on duty)
- Because of relationship to the parties (parent/child, spouse/spouse)
- Because you voluntarily assume a duty of care and then fail to adequately perform it.
- Where your conduct created the peril.
Four Common Law Mental States of a Crime
- Specific intent crimes
- Malice crimes
- General intent crimes
- Strict liability crimes
11 Specific intent crimes
- Solicitation
- Conspiracy
- Attempt
- First degree murder
- Assault
- Larceny
- Embezzlement
- False Pretenses
- Robbery
- Burglary
- Forgery
“Students Can Always Fake A Laugh, Even For Ridiculous Bar Facts”
2 Malice Crimes
- Common Law Murder
2. Arson
General Intent Crimes
Catch-all. Ex. rape, battery…
Strict Liability Crimes
NO INTENT crimes.
Look for statutory language with, “knowingly, willfully, or intentionally then the statute is meant to be a NO INTENT crime of strict liability.
“Purposely”
?
“Knowingly”
When he is AWARE that his conduct will very likely cause the result.
“Recklessly”
When he CONSCIOUSLY DISREGARDS a SUBSTANTIAL and UNJUSTIFIABLE risk to human life.
“Negligently”
When he fails to be aware of a SUBSTANTIAL and UNJUSTIFIABLE risk.
Accomplice
One who aids, advises, or encourages the principal in the commission of a crime.
Accomplice liability:
Liable for:
- The crime itself, and
- All other foreseeable crimes.
How does an accomplice withdraw if he ENCOURAGED the crime?
He must REPUDIATE the encouragement.
How does an accomplice withdraw when he has aided by providing assistance?
He must do everything possible to neutralize this assistance.
Solicitation
Asking someone to commit a crime. The crime ends when you ask them.
Factual impossibility is no defense.
Conspiracy
- An agreement between two or more persons,
- With the intent to enter into an agreement, AND
- The intent to achieve the unlawful objective of the agreement.
Conspiracy Majority Rule
Must be an agreement PLUS some overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy. ANY act, even just mere preparation.
Effect of withdrawal from conspiracy
Can never relieve D of liability for the conspiracy itself, but CAN withdraw from liability for other conspirators subsequent crimes.
Attempt
- Specific intent, and
2. Overt act in furtherance of the crime
For purposes of attempt an overt act must be:
A substantial step in futherance of the commission of the crime. Mere preparation is NOT enough.
M’Naghten Rule
At time of his conduct D lacked the ability TO KNOW THE WRONGFULNESS OF HIS ACTIONS or to understand the nature, quality, and being of his actions.
Irresistible Impulse
D lacked the CAPACITY FOR SELF CONTROL and free choice.
Durham Rule
D’s conduct is a PRODUCT OF MENTAL ILLNESS.
MPC Insanity
D lacked the ability to conform his conduct to the requirements of the law.
Voluntary intoxication
Defense only to a SPECIFIC INTENT crime.
Involuntary intoxication
- Unknowingly being intoxicated.
- Becoming intoxicated under duress.
Form of insanity and therefore a defense to ALL CRIMES.
Criminal liability under the age of 7?
No.
Criminal liability under age of 14?
A rebuttable presumption of no criminal liability.
Non-deadly force in self defense
May be used anytime the victim reasonably believes that force is about to be used on him.
Use of deadly force in self defense: Majority Rule
V may use deadly force in self defense any time the V reasonably believes that deadly force is about to be used on him.
Use of deadly force in self defense: Minority Rule
V is required to retreat if it is safe to do so with three exceptions:
- No duty to retreat from home.
- No duty to retreat if you are a victim of a rape or robbery.
- Cops have no duty to retreat.
Original aggressor must do what to get back the defense of self defense?
- Withdraw, and
2. Communicate that withdrawal.
Initial aggressor and victim escalation
If V escalates minor fight into one involving deadly force and does so without giving the initial aggressor the opportunity to withdraw, original aggressor may use force in his own defense.
Defense of others
D can raise ‘defense of others’ defense if he reasonably believes that the person assisted would have had the right to use force in his own defense.
Defending property
Deadly force may never be used.
Duress is a defense to a criminal act if:
- The person acts under the threat of imminent infliction of death or great bodily harm, and
- That belief is reasonable.
Threats to 3rd persons may suffice.
Duress is a defense to all crimes except:
homicide.
Necessity
Conduct that would otherwise be criminal is justifiable if,
- As a resulting pressure from NATURAL FORCES
- D reasonably believes his conduct was necessary to
- Avoid a greater societal harm.
Mistake of Fact Defense
Only a defense when the mistake NEGATES INTENTION.
Mistake of Fact Defense: Malice and General Intent Crimes
Mistake must be reasonable.
Mistake of Fact Defense: Specific Intent Crimes
ANY mistake, NO MATTER HOW RIDICULOUS is a defense.
Mistake of Fact Defense: Strict Liability Crimes
Never a defense.
Entrapment
- Criminal DESIGN might have originated with law enforcement officers, AND
- D must not have been predisposed to commit the crime.
Battery
Unlawful application of force to the person resulting in either:
- Bodily injury, or
- Offensive touching.
General Intent Crime.
Assault
- Attempt to commit a battery, or
- Intentional creation,
- other than by mere words,
- of a reasonable apprehension
- of imminent bodily harm.
Specific intent crime.
Aggravated assault
Assault plus:
- The use of a deadly or dangerous weapon; or
- With the intent to rape, maim, or murder.
Murder
Unlawful killing of another human being with MALICE AFORETHOUGHT. Such state of mind exists if there is:
- An intent to kill; or
- Intent to inflict serious bodily harm, or
- Reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk of human life; or
- Intent to commit a felony.
Murder and proximate cause
D is responsible for all results that occur as a natural and probable consequence of his conduct, even if he did not anticipate the exact manner in which the event would occur.
Felony murder
- Any killing, even accidental, committed during the course of a felony.
Defenses for felony murder
- If D has a defense to the underlying felony.
- The deaths are not foreseeable.
- Deaths caused after D reaches a point of temporary safety.
Homicide of a police officer
1st degree murder if:
- D knows the victim is a cop; and
- V is acting in the line of duty.
Second degree murder/Depraved heart killing
Killing done with:
- Reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life; or
- Murders that are not classified as first degree murders.