Criminal Law Flashcards
Übersicht
I. General
II. Personal Crimes
III. Property crimes
IV. Inchoate crimes
V. Defenses
I. General
Allgemeines Schema
- mens rea (state of mind)
- actus reus
- concurrence
- causation
- lack of defense
I. General
- mens rea
Can manifest as general intent or specific intent
Dolus Arten:
- - Desire of result regardless of likelihood
- Knowledge that a result is substantially certain regardless of desire to bring it about
- Deliberately ignorant willful blindness
Sonstige:
- Negligence is objective. Recklessness is subjective, requiring awareness of a high degree of risk
- Criminal negligence requires more than tortious negligence unreasonable risk of injury to others
I. General
- actus reus
= The voluntary act oder omission to act where legal duty to
ct exists by, e.g., special relationship, contract, statute, creating the peril, voluntary assumption of duty
I. General
- Concurrence
Concurrence between mental state and act: Intent actuates Δ’s act, not the result
I. General
- Causation
Δ’s conduct must be the actual and proximate cause of the crime
a) Actual cause: Result wouldn’t have occurred “but for” Δ’s act, or Δ’s act was a substantial factor
b) Proximate cause: Result is a natural and probable consequence of the risk created by Δ’s act
P: An intervening act breaks chain of causation if independent of Δ’s act or outside the foreseeable sphere of risk created by Δ
I. General
SonderP: Transferred intent, bei welchen crimes?
Δ intends harm actually caused to a different victim. Intent transferred to new victim
Applies to:
1. homicide
2. battery
3. arson
(but not attempt)
I. General
SonderP: Unterscheidung GI vs. SI
GI: intend to do act, but not necessarily result = wanton or reckless (criminally negligent) misconduct may be sufficient (weil es nur auf die Handlung ankommt)
Bsp. Battery, Rape, Involuntary, manslaughter, Common law murder (without specific intent), Arson, Kidnapping , False imprisonment
Besonderheit defenses: involuntary intoxication, reasonable mistake of fact (in good faith)
SI: intent to accomplish result (act + objective) = wanton/reckless not sufficient
Bsp. Larceny, robbery, Burglary, Forgery, False pretenses, Embezzlement, Assault, 1° premeditated murder, Voluntary manslaughter, Inchoate crimes (solicitation, attempt, conspiracy, accomplice)
Besonderheit defenses: zusätzlich auch voluntary intoxication, zusätzlich auch unreasonable mistake of fact (in good faith)
II. Personal crimes
Übersicht
- Homicide
- Battery
- Assault
- Kidnapping
- False Imprisonment
- Rape
II. Personal crimes
- Homicide: allgemeines und Arten
Allgemein:
- Murder at common law is the unlawful killing (neither justifiable nor excusable) of another human being with malice aforethought. “Malice” may be express or implied, and is determined by intent
- Causation: Δ’s act must be cause in fact (“but for”) and proximate cause of victim’s death
aa) Proximate cause if the result is natural and probable cause of act, even if unanticipated, An act that hastens an inevitable result is still a proximate cause
bb) Simultaneous acts of 2+ people may be independently sufficient causes of a result
cc) Acts of an innocent agent can be attributable to the principal
- One cannot give legally valid consent to death or serious bodily injury
Arten: Statutory modifications of common law:
1. First degree (1°) murder
2. Second degree (2°) (common law) murder
3. Felony murder (FM)
4. Manslaughter (MS)
5. Misfeasance (involuntary homicide)
II. Personal crimes
- Homicide: First degree murder
= Express malice is shown by any length of premeditation and deliberation before the unlawful taking of a human life
- Premeditation: Reflection on intent to kill (“Should I kill this person?”)
- Deliberation: Decision to kill in cool and dispassionate manner (“What about the consequences?”)
- If killing is proximately caused during or attempt of an enumerated or inherently dangerous felony (IDF) (BARRK: burglary, arson, robbery, rape, kidnapping), it is 1° felony murder (see below)
- Includes killing by poison, torture, or lying in wait
- Voluntary intoxication (defense to SI crimes) mitigates murder from 1° to 2°, not to manslaughter
II. Personal crimes
- Homicide: Second degree murder
= Malice is implied where there is intent to kill (without premeditation), intent to cause serious bodily harm, reckless indifference to human life (depraved heart, extreme negligence), OR intent to commit an inherently dangerous felony
- Includes felony murder where the felony is not BARRK
- Use of a deadly weapon allows inference of intent to kill
- Reckless indifference to human life sufficient (no SI). So voluntary intoxication is NOT a defense
II. Personal crimes
- Homicide: Felony murder
= Any death caused in commission or attempted commission (substantial step toward completion) of a felony (such as BARRK) is 1° felony murder. Malice is implied from intent to commit the underlying felony. Resulting death must be a foreseeable result of the felony, but distinct from the felony
- Felony starts when Δ could be convicted of its attempt, ends when Δ reaches “temporary safety”, aber Δ may still be guilty if the act that kills occurs before/during flight from scene and V dies after flight, if there is a close causal relationship between underlying felony and death
- Co-felon liability: When killing occurs during an IDF, one is liable for killing by an accomplice if the criminal acts could foreseeably result in death, and death occurs in furtherance of the felony
a) Proximate cause theory (less lenient): All co-felons are liable for any death (caused by anyone) proximately caused by Δ’s acts in furtherance of the felony
b) Agency theory (more lenient) (default/majority rule): FM only if a killing is done by a co-felon (an agent). EXCEPTION: Victim used as shield or forced into danger → FM
aa) If bystander accidentally killed by PO during shootout, FM under proximate cause theory, likely no FM under agency theory
bb) If a felon intentionally kills a co-felon, not a “foreseeable” result, likely no FM
c) Redline limitation (co-felon death): In most jx, Δ not liable for FM if killing is justifiable or excusable, i.e., if police, victim, or bystander kills a co-felon, or co-felon kills self - A valid defense to the underlying felony negates FM
II. Personal crimes
- Homicide: Manslaughter
= is an unlawful killing without malice (intent may still be there)
a) Voluntary MS: Intentional killing resulting from adequate provocation (uncooled heat of passion)
a) Adequate provocation is objective + subjective: Enough to excite sudden, uncontrollable passion such that a reasonable person would lose self-control (e.g., moment of discovering infidelity, threat of deadly force) + Δ was actually provoked
bb) Cooling off is objective + subjective: Not enough time between Δ’s heat of passion and the killing for a reasonable person provoked in same way to cool off + Δ did not cool off
cc) Murder may be REDUCED to MS via imperfect self-defense: Δ had honest but unreasonable belief that deadly force was necessary (doesn’t qualify as full self-defense), or Δ was at fault in starting fight
b) Involuntary MS: Unintentional killing caused by criminal negligence (recklessness under MPC) or foreseeably caused during a misdemeanor manslaughter (misdemeanor or non-IDF felony)
II. Personal crimes
- Homicide: Misfeasance
= involuntary homicide: One with a legal duty to act may be guilty of murder for failing to act
a) Murder if intent to kill arises from desiring or knowing of a substantial likelihood of death
b) Manslaughter if death is not specifically desired, even if Δ knew or should have known that V might get hurt
II. Personal crimes
- Battery
= the unlawful application of force to the person of another resulting in bodily injury or offensive touching
a) The act must be intentional, reckless, or criminally negligent. Force may be indirect (e.g., siccing a dog)
b) Simple battery may rise to aggravated battery (a felony) where Δ causes serious bodily injury, Δ uses a deadly weapon (used in intended manner), or V is specially protected (e.g., child, woman, police)
c) DEFENSES: valid consent (no coercion or fraud), defense (self/others, proportional force), prevent crime
felony
a serious crime that can be punished by more than one year in prison (= Pendant zum Verbrechen)
II. Personal crimes
- Assault
a) “Attempted battery” assault: Δ intended to commit battery, no need to finish (V need not be aware)
b) “Fear of battery” assault: Δ intentionally put V in reasonable apprehension of imminent bodily harm
c) Simple assault may rise to aggravated assault (a felony) where Δ acts with intent to commit a violent crime (rape or murder), Δ uses a dangerous weapon, or V is specially protected
II. Personal crimes
- Kidnapping
= Unlawful confinement of V w/o consent via movement of V or concealment of V in a “secret” place
a) Confinement: V is compelled to go where he doesn’t wish to go or remain where he doesn’t wish to remain
b) Children and the mentally disabled lack legal capacity to consent, so their consent is irrelevant