Criminal Law Flashcards
Legal Duty to Act
- By statute
- By contract
- Because of the relationship between the parties
- Because you voluntarily assume a duty of care and fail to adequately perform it
- Where your conduct created the peril
Specific Intent Crimes
“Students Can Always Fake A Laugh Even For Ridiculous Bar Facts” Solicitation Conspiracy Attempt First-Degree Murder Assault Larceny Embezzlement False Pretenses Robbery Burglary Forgery
They will qualify for (1) Voluntary Intoxication; and (2) Unreasonable Mistake of Fact
Malice Crimes
Murder
Arson
General Intent Crimes
All crimes not so far mentioned are general intent crimes unless they qualify for strict liability.
General intent means the D has a general awareness that she is acting in a manner that would be prohibited by law.
Strict Liability Crimes
“The no-intent crimes”
Key point: any defense that negates intention cannot be a defense to the no intent crimes of strict liability.
Purposely (MPC)
One acts purposely when it is his conscious objective to engage in certain conduct or cause a certain result.
Knowingly (MPC)
One acts knowingly when he is aware that his conduct will very likely cause the result
Recklessly (MPC)
One acts recklessly when he consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk
Negligently (MPC)
One acts negligently when he fails to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk
Concurrence
The D must have had the intent necessary for the crime at the time he committed the act constituting the crime
Causation
Some crimes (e.g. homicide) require a harmful result and causation. Thus, when a crime is defined to require not merely conduct, but also a specified result (e.g. death) the defendant’s conduct must be both the cause-in-fact and the proximate cause of the specified result.
Common Law Parties to a Crime
(1) Principals in First Degree - persons who actually engage in the act that constitutes the criminal offense
(2) Principals in Second Degree - persons who aid, advise, or encourage the principal and are present at the crime;
(3) Accessories Before the Fact - persons who aid, advise, or encourage the principal but are not present at the crime
(4) Accessories After the Fact - persons who assist the principal after the crime
Modern Parties to a Crime
(1) Principal - one who, with the requisite mental state, actually engages in the act or omission that causes the criminal result;
(2) Accomplice - one who aids, advises, or encourages the principal in the commission of the crime charged;
(3) Accessory After then Fact - one who receives, comforts, or assists another knowing that he has committed a felony, in order to help the felon escape arrest, trial, or conviction
Mental State Required for Accomplice Liability
(1) the intent to assist the principal in the commission of the crime; and
(2) the intent that the principal commit the crime
Scope of Accomplice Liability
Responsible for the crimes she committed or aided/advised/encourage AND for any other crimes committed in the course of committing the crime contemplated, as long as the other crimes were probable and foreseeable
Accomplice Withdrawal
If encouraged crime, must repudiate the encouragement
If aided by providing assistance to the principal, must do everything possible to neutralize this assistance
Contacting police = withdrawing
Conspiracy
An agreement, between two or more persons, with intent to enter into agreement (express or implied), and an intent to pursue an unlawful objective.
NO MERGER
Bilateral Conspiracy Approach
Common Law Rule
If one person is merely feigning agreement, the other person cannot be guilty of conspiracy.
Furthermore, acquittal of all person with whom a D is alleged to have conspired, precludes conviction of the remaining D under this approach.
Unilateral Conspiracy Approach
Modern rule/MPC approach
Only one person needs to have genuine criminal intent
Majority Rule - Overt Act (Conspiracy)
In order to ground liability for conspiracy, there must be an agreement + some overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy
Any little act will do, even mere preparation
Minority Rule - Overt Act (Conspiracy)
Common law rule
Liability is grounded with the agreement itself
Solicitation
Asking someone to commit a crime. This crime ends when you ask them.
Under common law, not necessary that the person solicited agree to commit the crime.
Once person agrees, merges into conspiracy.
Attempt
(1) Specific intent, plus (2) overt act in furtherance of the crime
Overt act here must be a substantial step in furtherance of the commission of the crime; thus, mere preparation cannot ground liability for attempt.
Majority Rule - Defense of Abandonment (Attempt)
Once D has taken a substantial step toward committing the crime, abandonment is NEVER a defense.
Minority Rule - Defense of Abandonment (Attempt)
MPC allows for Defense of Abandonment only if it is fully voluntary and a complete renunciation of criminal purpose.
Common Law Murder
The unlawful killing of another human being with malice aforethought. Such a state of mind exists if there is:
- Intent to kill; or
- Intent to commit a felony; or
- Intent to inflict great bodily harm; or
- Reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life.
First Degree Murder
Three categories:
- Premeditated killing (human + acting with intent or knowledge to cause death)
- Felony murder
- Homicide of police officer (know victim is cop + cop working at time)
Second Degree Murder
(1) Depraved heart killing— a killing done with reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life; or
(2) Murders that are not classified as first-degree murders
Felony Murder
Any killing—even accidental killing—committed during the course of a felony.
Note: defense to underlying felony is defense to felony murder