criminal courts sentencing Flashcards
what is a sentence
a sentence is the punishment given to defendant who has been convicted
factors of the sentence
1)the type of sentence depends on the type of offender and whether they are adult or youth offenders
2)the tariff(length) of the sentence is determined by the court also consider
-age
-the seriousness of the offence
-the likelihood of further offending
sentencing powers of the magistrate
-6 months in jail for 1 offence
-12 months jail for 2 offences
-£5,000 fine which has later been switched to unlimited
sentencing powers of the crown court
-unlimited fines
-life imprisonment(25 years)
under the S57 Sentencing Act 2020 what are the five aims of sentencing
1)retribution(punishment)
2)deterrence
3)protection from society
4)rehabilitation
5)reparation
explain punishment/ retribution giving its history
1) The offender broke the law and was found guilty
2) criminal law takes revenge against the offender on behalf of victims and society
3) the main issue is that punishment must be proportionate to the crime - “the just deserts theory”
its history:
1) based on the biblical principle ‘eye for an eye’
2) The basis of the agreement is for retaining the death penalty
explain the types of deterrence and its main problem
1)individual deterrence: when the individual offender is put off offending
2)general deterrence: aims to deter others by showing the community the potential –>courts impose this example sentence to try to increase the deterrence effect
3)the main problem: the main problem is with its effectiveness. it’s calculated based on the individual chances of getting caught
explain protecting the public explain the IPPS system and give an example
1) sentence is given to protect the public from the offender
e.g drunk driving is given a driving ban
2)protection is given through incarceration however it’s expensive
3)instead they use curfews, electronic tagging, bans, etc..
4)IPPS- for dangerous criminals whose crimes do not merit a life sentence
explain rehabilitation
1)the aim is to rehabilitate the offender so that they are less likely to commit offenses in the future, this can be done through education or training.
2)English system, C Elliott and F Quinn, 2008
- this is the reason the Sentencing Act 2020 offers community sentencing that can be tailored to meet an offender’s need.
explain reparation
reparation essentially means paying back to society what you have taken away- “restorative justice”
explain what IPPS are
1)they are minimum imprisonment rather than maximum-offender have a minimum amount of time they have to spend in prison but no maximum
2)from 2005, judges in England and Wales handed out the new king of life sentences for minor offenses.
3)however, intermediate sentences for public protection(IPPS) were found to breach human rights and were scrapped in 2012.
4)there are still 2,223 prisoners 9/10 who passed their tariff date.
what are 2 pros and cons of rehabilitative sentences
pros:
1)the court can help people
2)longer-term prisoners may not be released early until they have completed treatment
cons:
1)often those on short sentences spent too little time in prison to access help
2)the problem arises once they are released and have no job or prospects of money
explain maximum sentences
magistrates and judges are restricted by maximum sentences that are laid down by parliament in the statute covering the offense
e.g max sentence for theft I 7 years while for rape it is life
explain minimum sentences
1) The Crime Act 1997 introduced minimum sentences for both persistent offenders, drug declares and burglars
2) It also introduced an automatic life sentence for offenders convicted of a second serious or violent offense
explain presentencing reports
1)magistrates or judges have to consider a range of different factors regarding the offense and the offender
2)often a pre-sentence report will prepared by the probation service that will help with the decision to impose the most appropriate sentence
what are the factors surrounding the offense (part of the factors effecting the sentence given)
CjA 2003 states the factors are:
1)previous convictions for other similar offenses
2) whether the defendant was on bail when the offense was committed
3) whether there was any religious or racial element to the offense
4) whether there was any hostility to a disability or sexual orientation involved in the offense
explain the effect of a guilty plea (part of factors affecting the sentence given)
1)if the defendant pleads guilty at the first opportunity to do so, up to one-third will be deducted from their sentence.
2)if a defendant pleaded guilty once the trial has started then up to one-tenth discount will be deducted
explain the offender’s background (part of the factors effecting the sentence given)
1)if there are any medical or psychiatric issues involved in the offense the court will ask for the medical report before making a decision
2)if imposing a fine, the financial situation of the offender will need to be fully disclosed
explain sentencing guidelines(part of factors effecting sentence given)
1)used to be set by the court of appeal but they had to wait for a suitable base to come to the court.
2)sentencing advisory panel- was set up in 1998 to advise the court of appeal on guidelines.
3)coroners and Justice Act 2009- set sentencing council aims:
-consistency and transparency
explain the 5 main categories of sentence
1)custodial sentences
2)community sentences
3)suspended sentences
4)fines
5)discharges
explain custodial sentence (part of categories of sentencing)
custodial-most severe sentence available and is for the most serious of offenses.
S152 Criminal Justice Act 2003- custodial sentences are only available for those offenses that are ‘‘very serious’’ that not even a community sentence can justify it.
can range from a week in prison to a life sentence
explain community order (part of categories of sentencing)
community order - under the Criminal Justice Act 2003, there is now one community order to which the court can attach any combination of requirements that they think are necessary. e.g(unpaid work requirement or curfew requirement)
explain suspended sentence (part of categories of sentencing)
1)this is where the offender does not go to prison and has to comply, with conditions set out by the court. (period can be up to two years)
2)breach of conditions can result in the offender being sent back for the remainder of the sentence and the additional sentence for the new offense committed.
explain fines (part of categories of sentencing)
1)these are the most common sentences given to adults, these are mostly administered for minor offenses.
2) The magistrate can impose a maximum fine of £5000 or up to £20,000 on business-related issues
3) The crown has no limit on the fine that it can impose
explain discharges (part of categories of sentencing)
1)absolute discharge - if the court feels that the offender has received enough punishment that means the court discharged the offender with no further punishment.
conditional discharge- offender will receive no punishment on the condition that they do not re-offend for a specific period up to three years(if they re-offend, they can continue to impose another sentence)
explain sentencing youth offenders
1)the age of criminal responsibility is 10
2)offenders aged 10-17 are dealt with differently from adults, they are tried in youth courts unless the crime is so serious it’s tried in crown court.
3)youths can be tried in crown court if they are tried alongside an adult
through what case did the role of youth court consolidate? state and explain the case
1)Thompson and Venables UK 1999
2)ECTHR upheld complaints by the boys convicted of the murder of Jamie Bulger that their trial in the crown court violates their right to a fair trial.
3)the ECtHR ruled the trial of a young person should be held in a courtroom in which everyone is on the same level and defendants can stay with their families.
other roles of the youth courts
1) Young adults entitled to appropriate adults to be with them (PACE 1984)
2)more informal