Crime And Deviance 👮♀️ Flashcards
Right realism and crime
Crimes like substance abuse and stealing can be explained by a lack of work ethic in underclass ( Charles Murray)
David Marsland - right realism
Over generous welfare state makes people out of work, boredom causes deviance
Evaluations of right realism and crime
It blames the victims, substance abuse is a huge problem and it’s insensitive to blame it on boredom.
Rich people also do drugs
Welfare state is under generous
Biology in right realism and crime
Phrenologists believed that you could tell whether a person was a criminal based on lumps on their head
HB Glass
Argued that me. Who had particular chromosomes are likely to be sex deviants due to their excess Y chromosome
Evaluations to biology in right realism
- ignores reasons for ‘biology’, squeegee men tended to be black and were cracked down upon but white college deviant students were ignored
Rational choice theory
People commit crimes because society gives them a chance to, if it’s easy they will do it, can’t use soft punishment as it won’t prevent them from committing crimes
Cornish and Clarke
Criminals tend to weigh up the costs and benefits of offending, they commit when there’s more to gain than to lose
Evaluations of rational choice theory
- ignores the victims of the crimes as it only focuses on perpetrators
-ignores subcultural issues, focuses only on individuals
-social democrats, left realists and Marxists argue that things like capitalist and an under generous welfare state lead to crime
Crime prevention strategies
- early intervention (left realism)
- community style policing (left realism)
-zero tolerance policing (right realism )
-deterrent
-rehabilitation
-structural crime prevention strategies - militarisation of the police
Early intervention
Tony Blair promised that labour would be ‘tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime “ removing reasons why people commit, sure-start centres, compensatory policies etc..
Evaluations of early intervention
-expensive and difficult to judge how beneficial these longitudinal studies are
-politically difficult
Situational crime prevention
Putting things in place to prevent crime (street spikes and barriers etc)
Making it harder to ‘get away’ with the crime. It doesn’t stop the causes it just stops the crime
Evaluations of situational crime prevention strategies
-may create a two tier class system where the poor are left vulnerable
-Mirza says it causes displacement where it doesn’t stop the crime it just moves it somewhere else
-Left realists say it causes hostility between the communities
Environmental crime preventions Wilsons “broken windows theory”
-immediately replacing damaged areas
-zero tolerance style policing with harsh punishments
Zimbardos study, abandoned two cars in different places, one poor area and the other in a built up nice area. In 10 minutes the one in the poor area was wrecked, the other one stayed untouched for over a week
Evaluations of broken window theory
Doesn’t focus on the first step of a crime
Hasn’t been applied properly
Military style policing
Police driving armoured cars, carrying weapons, wearing stab vests etc…
Evaluations of military style policing
Left realists like Lea Kinsey and young argue that it’s going to increase feelings of marginalisation, their solution is to have community style policing
Left realism and crime
Looking at reality rather than just theories, vulnerable people are more likely to be victims which has a negative impact on society
The Perry pre school project (left realism)
David Weikart and Perry pre school head teacher conducted a study with 123 students with risk factors of failing school, they were randomly divided into two groups one with a high quality pre school program and a comparison group who received no pre school education. Conducted from 1962-1967 but were also followed throughout their lives. Found that the program group did much better in life
Evaluations of the Perry preschool project
-other experiences in life could have influenced the results
-ethical issues
-not representative
Left realism: why does crime happen?
-marginalisation
-relative deprivation
-subcultures
Marginalisation
Left realists argue that certain groups turn to crime as a result of feeling ostracised by society. Some groups have means to stand up against oppression, however some groups do not and are marginalised causing them to turn to crime
Relative deprivation
People believe that they’re more deprived than others in society, Runciman argues that as expectations for quality of life rise, so does our dissatisfaction with our deprivation
Subcultures
Form as a response to marginalisation and relative deprivation, young people join criminal subcultures to not be marginalised and get rewards. Subcultures can create community tensions and can illustrate problems within the economic system. Status frustration(Cohen)
Evaluations to left realist theories
-Marxism by a different name
-feminists may argue that is these lead to crime then you would expect women to commit more crime
-there isn’t unlimited money and it’s impossible to just get rid of inequality
White collar crime
Occupational/ workplace crime that occurs in middle class settings
Key examples of white collar crime
Ford pinto - car that was made with bad engineering that was ignored, killed over 200 people
Deep water horizon- oil rig exploded after they lied to people about the issues being dealt with
Bhopal disaster - industrial poisonous gas leak, 5000 died because of ignored safety dangers
Stephan box
The harm caused by white collar crimes are far more serious than street crimes, like physical harm to individuals, environmental costs and costs in health and welfare benefits
Croall
Despite the high personal and economic costs of white collar crimes, it is not regarded a serious issue by the general public. These crimes are often invisible as in big companies it is difficult to know where the blame lies. Many people don’t even know they’re victims
Functionalism in crime and deviance
Crime can be functional in moderation for society, it creates social solidarity and jobs. Durkheim states that an appropriate amount of crime can cause a collective conscience. However too much crime could cause a showing that society isn’t functioning adequately
Marshall B Clinard
Crime serves as a warning function, it indicates that something in society isn’t working properly
Example- London riots
Albert Cohen
Deviance can act as a “safety valve” it allows people to express their individuality when their work doesn’t allow them to