Crim Pro Flashcards
A pending motion for discharge may be denied if:
i) An extension of time has been ordered and it has not expired
ii) The failure to hold trial is attributable to the accused, a codefendant in the same trial, or their counsel;
iii) The accused was unavailable for trial; or
iv) The demand is invalid
A motion to take a deposition to perpetuate testimony generally must be filed :
A motion to take a deposition to perpetuate testimony generally must be
filed more than TEN (10) days before trial.
Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.190(i).
if the defendant elects to participate in discovery:
i) Within X days of receiving the prosecutor’s witness list, the defendant must provide the prosecutor ..
- a written list of the names and addresses of all trial witnesses
- any witness statements,
- reports,
- papers,
- tangible objects, or reports to be used at trial.
How can a new trial motion be made?
- The new trial motion may be made orally and dictated into the record as long as a court reporter is present. If made orally, the motion will be argued and immediately ruled on.
- the new trial motion may be written, filed with the court, and served on the prosecutor. If made in writing, the court must set a hearing date.
Each party is entitled to how many preemptory juror challenges?
i) Ten (10) peremptory challenges for felonies punishable by death or imprisonment for life;
ii) Six (6) peremptory challenges for all other felonies; and
iii) Three peremptory challenges for misdemeanors.
The court has the discretion to allow additional peremptory challenges when appropriate. Fla. Stat. § 913.08(1); Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.350(a),(e).
If a Defendant is not brought to trial within 10 days of “Notice of Expiration of Speedy Trial Time” hearing, then…
- the case must generally be discharged.
The discharge bars prosecution of
- the crime charged AND
- all other crimes that were or might have been charged as result of the same conduct or criminal episode as a lesser degree or lesser included offense on which trial has not commenced, convicted obtain, or adjudication withheld.
If the State files a traverse that denies the alleged facts, then a MTD for lack of factual matters :
A motion to dismiss for lack of factual matters must be denied
Counsel may also be appointed for a defendant who is partially indigent IF
the defendant absorbs the costs of representation to the extent the defendant is able to without substantial hardship.
For due process purposes, a defendant must be present during :
- the examination,
- challenging,
- impaneling, and
- swearing of the jury.
Thereafter, if the defendant voluntarily absences himself without leave of the court or is removed from the court because of disruptive conduct, the trial may continue in his absence;
the defendant may be both convicted and sentenced in absentia.
A defendant subject to an unlawful search and seizure may file a motion to suppress anything seized as evidence on the following grounds: (iii nn)
i) The property was illegally seized without a warrant;
ii) The warrant was insufficient;
iii) The seized property was not described in the warrant;
iv) There was no probable cause for the grounds on which the warrant was issued; or
v) The warrant was illegally executed.
Can a motino for continuance be made after demand for speedy trial?
- Yes,
- HOWEVER good cause for continuances or delay on the behalf of the accused does not include non-readiness for trial,
- except as to matters that
- arise after the demand is filed and
- could not reasonably have been anticipated
The court may entertain a motion to dismiss at any time on the grounds that :
- The defendant is charged for an offense for which he has been previously pardoned, placed in jeopardy, or granted immunity;
or
- There are no material disputed facts, and the undisputed facts do not establish a prima facie case of guilt.
Within five days of the filing of the “Demand for Speedy Trial” , the court :
the court must hold a calendar call
A pretrial motion to dismiss must :
- raise all available defenses.
- Every ground for a motion to dismiss that is not presented in the motion is waived.
- objections based on fundamental grounds are NOT WAIVED
The court must hold a calendar call within X days of a defendant filing a motion for speedy trial.
5 days
All search warrants must :
- be based on probable cause and
- supported by affidavits naming or describing
- the person, place, or thing to be searched AND
- must particularly describe the property to be seized.
All search warrants MUST be returned within TEN (10) days after issuance. Fla. Stat. § 933.05.
At first appearance, The judge must provide the accused with _________ and advise the accused of:
- The judge must provide the accused with a copy of the complaint
* The judge must advise the accused - (i) of the charges against him including an alleged violation of probation or community control,
- (ii) of the right to remain silent,
- (iii) that anything he says may be used against him,
- (iv) of the right to counsel, and
- (v) of the right to communicate with counsel, family, or friends.
The court generally must grant a new trial if the defendant’s substantial rights were prejudiced and if any of the following grounds is established:
i) The defendant was not present at a proceeding that required his presence;
ii) The jury received unauthorized evidence out of court;
iii) The jurors separated after retiring to deliberate without leave of court;
iv) Any juror or the prosecutor was guilty of misconduct;
v) The court erred in deciding a matter of law during the trial;
vi) The court erroneously instructed the jury on a matter of law or refused to give a requested, proper instruction; or
vii) For any other cause not attributable to the defendant that led the defendant not to receive a fair and impartial trial.
The court generally must grant a new trial if any of the following is established:
i) The jurors decided the verdict by lot;
ii) The verdict is contrary to the law or the weight of the evidence; or
iii) New and material evidence emerged that
- the defendant could not have discovered with reasonable diligence
- that, if introduced at trial, would have changed the verdict or finding of the court.
Every person charged with a crime must generally be brought to trial within :
- MISDEMEANOR - within 90 days of arrest for a misdemeanor
- FELONY - within 175 days of arrest for a felony.
How may a defendant waive the right to counsel?
The defendant may waive the right to counsel in a writing signed and dated by the defendant, but this waiver is limited to the first appearance only
A demand for speedy trial constitutes a…
- a pleading by the accused
- that he is available for trial,
- has diligently investigated the case,
- and is prepared or will be prepared for trial within five days.
- A demand by the accused who does not satisfy these conditions can be stricken as invalid on motion by the prosecutor
A Motion to Supress a Confession or admission illegally obtained must
- identify the statement to be suppressed and
- state the reasons for suppression,
- it must include a general statement of facts that constitute the basis for the motion
when may a challange for cause of a juror be made?
before the panel is sworn by orally stating grounds for the challenge.
If the parties fail to comply with the discovery rules or court orders, then the court may:
i) Issue a compliance order;
ii) Grant a continuance;
iii) Grant a mistrial;
iv) Prohibit the party from calling a witness or introducing evidence that was not disclosed; or
v) Enter any other just order.
As part of discovery, the court may require a defendant to do the following :
i) Appear in a lineup;
ii) Speak for identification by a witness;
iii) Be fingerprinted;
iv) Pose for photographs not amounting to a reenactment;
v) Try on articles of clothing;
vi) Permit the taking of samples of the defendant’s hair, blood, and other reasonably obtained materials;
vii) Provide handwriting samples; and
viii) Submit to a reasonable physical or medical inspection.
the court may set the case for trial on the notice to appear without the need for an indictment or information IF
If the defendant enters a plea of not guilty
If a notice to appear is not issued and the person is arrested, then a booking officer may :
subsequently issue a notice to appear
as long as
- a reasonable investigation is conducted
- and
- a determination is made that there is a likelihood that the person will appear as directed.
When must a notice of alibi be filed?
- not fewer than 10 days before trial upon demand of the prosecutor, the defendant must :
- file and
- serve a written notice of any intention to claim an alibi.
An officer making an arrest with a warrant must :
1) inform the arrestee of the reasons for the arrest
and
2) that a warrant has been issued
UNLESS the arrestee first flees or forcibly resists.
When may a defendant waive his right to be present at any and all proceedings?
when procescuted for a misdemeanor
If the defendant’s trial is not commenced within the applicable time period, then the defendant may :
- file with the court a separate pleading entitled “Notice of Expiration of Speedy Trial Time”
- AND
- serve a copy on the prosecuting authority.
- NOTE : A notice filed before the expiration to the applicable time period is invalid.)
If a continuance is granted to one or more of several defendants, then…
the court MAY proceed with the trial of the defendants who have not been granted a continuance.
Fla. Stat. § 918.016.
When may a motion for new trial or arrest of judgment be made?
within 10 days after the verdict or the finding of guilt by the court
A defendant must file a motion to dismiss :
either
- before the arraignment
- or at the arraignment
unless the court in its discretion permits the defendant additional time to so file.
Can a demand for speedy trial be withdraw?
Not unless there is:
- order of the court,
- with consent of the prosecution
- or for good cause.
All depositions of county residents must be taken :
- in the courthouse,
- in an agreed upon location, or
- in a court-designated location.
Exceptional circumstances do not include:
i) General congestion of the court’s docket;
ii) Lack of diligent preparation;
iii) Failure to obtain available witnesses, or
iv) Other avoidable or foreseeable delays.
When may the State or defendant file a motion for a continuance?
- before the matter is set for trial
- at the time that the matter is set for trial
unless good cause for failure to do so is otherwise shown.
A criminal trial proceeds in the following order:
The trial proceeds as follows:
(i) jury selection (voir dire);
(ii) the State presents its case;
(iii) the defense presents its case;
(iv) the State rebuts the defendant’s case;
(v) jury charge; and
(vi) three closing arguments (state, defendant, state’s rebuttal). Fla. Stat. §918.19; Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.381.
what is the effect of defendant filing a notice of discovery?
binds both the prosecutor and the defendant to all discovery procedures, including depositions.
A notice to appear may not be issued if :
- (i) the person fails or refuses to identify himself,
- (ii) the person fails or refuses to sign the notice,
- (iii) the person has no ties to the community,
- (iv) the person poses an unreasonable risk of bodily harm to himself or another,
- (v) the person has previously failed to appear, or
- (vi) the officer suspects that the person may be wanted in another jurisdiction.
If a court denies a discharge motion for failure of speedy trial for grounds other than the demand is invalid, then…
the court must schedule a trial, which must commence within 90 days of the order. Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.191(i).
The State MAY file a traverse or demur to a motion to dismiss that :
alleges factual matters
If a motion to supress evidence in an unlawful search is deemed legally sufficient by the court, then…
a hearing on the motion will be set.
Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.190(g).