Corporate Insolvency Flashcards
What is the Relevant Date?
15/09/2003 (the “Relevant Date”).
This is the date the Enterprise Act (“EA”) 2002 came into force.
What is Insolvency?
The inability to repay Debts.
What is the Cashflow Test for Insolvency?
The Firm is unable to repay its Debts as they fall due.
What is the Balance Sheet Test for Insolvency?
The Firm’s Liabilities (Present, Contingent, and Prospective) exceed its Assets.
What are the Options for Directors if the Firm is in Financial Difficulty?
- Do Nothing.
- Liquidate the Firm.
- Appoint an Administrator.
- Execute an Intercreditor Agreement.
- Request the Appointment of a Receiver.
What are the Advantages of Intercreditor Agreements?
They permit Direct Negotiation without Statutory Regulation.
This is an Informal Insolvency Arrangement.
What are the Tactics for Securing an Intercreditor Agreement?
- Reduce Costs.
- Sell Assets and Businesses.
- Grant New or Additional Security.
- Replace Directors or Senior Employees.
- Issue New Shares to Creditors (Debt-for-Equity Swap).
What is a Standstill Agreement?
An Agreement wherein Creditors consent to temporarily withhold from Enforcement.
What is a Pre-Insolvency Moratorium?
A Statutory Grace Period during which Creditors are prohibited from Enforcement.
What is the Scope of a Pre-Insolvency Moratorium?
- Enforcement of Security: Creditors cannot Enforce any Security over Firm Assets.
- Legal Proceedings: New Proceedings cannot be initiated and Existing Proceedings are Stayed.
- Administration Procedures: Creditors cannot initiate Administration; only the Directors can.
- Winding-Up Procedures: Creditors cannot initiate Winding-Up; only the Directors can, and no Shareholder to do so will pass without Director Approval.
What is the Procedure for Obtaining a Pre-Insolvency Moratorium?
Grounds for Application:
- Statement of Financial Difficulty: Directors must declare the Firm is, or is likely to become, Insolvent.
- Monitor’s Statement: A Licensed Insolvency Practitioner (the “Monitor”) must confirm the Moratorium will likely result in the Firm’s rescue.
Duration and Extension:
- The Moratorium initially lasts for 20 business days.
- It can then be extended for another 20 business days without Creditor consent.
- It can then be extended for up to one year from Commencement with Creditor consent or a Court Order.
Termination:
- The Moratorium automatically ends if:
- The Firm enters Liquidation or Administration; or
- The Court sanctions a CVA, SOA, or Restructuring Plan.
Under what Conditions must a Firm Repay a Pre-Moratorium Debt?
- Rent During Moratorium.
- Monitor’s Remuneration and Expenses.
- Loans under Financial Services Contracts.
- Goods and Services Supplied During Moratorium.
- Employee Wages, Salaries, and Redundancy Payments.
What are the Two Formal Insolvency Arranagements?
- Company Voluntary Arrangement (“CVA”).
- Restructuring Plan.
What are the Key Features of a Company Voluntary Arrangement?
- Supervision by an Insolvency Practitioner.
- Combination with Other Procedures: CVAs can be used alongside other Procedures.
- No Court Approval Required: Must be reported to Court, but does not require its sanction.
- Director Control: Directors remain in office and continue running the Firm, subject to the CVA’s Terms.
- Compromise with Creditors: Creditors may agree to accept part payment or extended payment schedules.
What is the Procedure for Executing a Company Voluntary Arrangement?
Proposal Drafting:
- The Board, or if applicable the Liquidator or Administrator, drafts the Proposal and appoints a Nominee (an Insolvency Practitioner).
- The Board submit the Proposal and a Statement of Affairs, assisted in drafting by the Nominee.
Nominee’s Report to Court:
- The Nominee considers whether the Proposal has a resasonable propsect of approval and implementation.
- Within 28 days, the Nominee must report to the Court on whether Creditors and Shareholder Meetings sould be convened.
Creditor Meeting:
- Creditors are given at least 14 days’ Notice to vote on the Proposal.
- It must be approved by at least 75% in value of Voting Creditors, excluding Secured Creditors; and
- Cannot be opposed by more than 50% of Unconnected Creditors by Value (Independent from the Firm).
Shareholder Meeting:
- The Shareholder Meeting is held within 5 days of the Creditors’ decision.
- It must be approved by a Simple Majority, but Creditor Assent always trumpts Shareholder Dissent.
Reporting and Implementation:
- The Nominee reports the outcome to the Court, after which, the Nominee becomes the Supervisor and oversees the Arrangement.
To what Extent is a Company Voluntary Arrangement Binding?
- It Binds all Unsecured Sreditors, including those who abstained or dissented.
- It only Binds Secured and Preferntial Creditors if they unanimously agree.
Can Creditors challenge a Company Voluntary Arrangement?
Yes, within 28 days of Approval on Grounds of Unfair Prejudice or Material Irregularity.
What is the Supervisor’s Role?
- Ensure compliance.
- Validate Creditor Claims.
- Manage payments and distributions.
- Issue a Final Report upon completion.
What is a Restucturing Plan?
An Agreement to Restructure a Firm’s Liabilities by compromising Creditor and Shareholder Claims.
What is the Procedure for Executing a Restructuring Plan?
Class Division:
- Creditors and Shareholders divided into Classes based on their rights and interests.
Voting Requirements:
- The Plan must be approval by at least 75% in value of those voting in each Class.
Court Sanction:
- The Court must approve the Plan, after which it becomes Binding, sometimes even on Dissenting Classes.
What are the Court’s Powers during the Process of Executing a Restructuring Plan?
Exclusion from Voting:
- The Court can exclude Parties with no genuine economic interest from voting.
Cross-Class Cram Down:
- The Court can enforce the Plan across Dissenting Classes if:
- Dissenting Class members would not be worse off than under the most likely alternative; and
- The Plan has been approved by at least one Class with a genuine economic interest.
Debt for Equity Swap:
- The Court can facilitate a Debt-to-Equity swap by forcing Dissenting Classes to acquiesce.
To what Extent is a Restructuring Plan Binding?
Completely. It Binds Unsecured, Preferential, and Secured Creditors.
To whom does an Administrator Owe Duties?
The Firm’s Creditors:
- It must act in the Best Interests of all Creditors.
The Court, as an Officer Thereof:
- It must act impartially and in accordance with the Statutory Objectives.
What are the Statutory Objectives an Administrator must work toward?
Primary Objective — Rescue the Firm:
- Rehabilitate the Firm so that it may proceed as a Going Concern.
Secondary Objective —Achieve a Better Result for Creditors as a Whole:
- Achieve a better result for Creditors relative to Liquidation without Administration.
- Conditional on the Primary being unachievable.
Tertiary Objective — Realise Assets to Distribute to Secured or Preferential Creditors:
- Liquidate Firm Assets to make whole Secured and Preferential Creditors.
- Conditional on the Primary and Secondary Objectives being unachievable.
Who can Apply for the In-Court Procedure for Appointing an Administrator?
- The Firm.
- The Board.
- The Creditors.
- The Liquidator.
- The Supervisor under the CVA.
What is the In-Court Procedure for Appointing an Administrator?
Petition:
- A Qualified Applicant submit a Petition and Serve Notice on any QFCHs within 2 Business Days.
- Application triggers an Interim Moratorium, which lasts until it is decided.
Conditions for Court’s Assent:
- The Firm is, or is likely to become, Insolvent.
- The Court believes the Appointment will likely achieve the Administration’s Objectives.