Contracts Flashcards
Elements needed to form a valid contract
- Mutual assent (offer + acceptance);
- Consideration (bargained for legal detriment); and
- No defenses to formation
Define
bilateral contract
Contract made by both sides; i.e. mutual promises
Define
unilateral contract
Requires full performance as the method of acceptance
Define
offer
- An outward, objective manifestation of willingness to enter into a bargain;
- That creates the power of acceptance in the offeree (i.e. nothing left to do except say “yes”)
Under common law, what terms must be included in the offer?
- Parties
- Subject matter
- Price
- Quantity
How can an offer be terminated?
- Counter-offer;
- Death;
- Incapacity;
- Lapse;
- Rejection; or
- Revocation
What types of offers are irrevocable?
- Option contracts;
- Firm offers;
- When there is detrimental reliance;
- When offeree has started performance on a unilateral contract
What does a counteroffer function as?
rejection + new offer
Define
mirror image rule
(common law)
Acceptance must be a mirror image of every single term of the offer
If any part of the terms are different, it will function as a counter-offer and rejection
Under UCC §2-207, what happens if an acceptance contains “additional or different” terms from the original offer if both parties are merchants?
The terms will automatically become part of the contract, unless:
- the terms materially change the contract;
- the offeror objects; or
- the offer explicitly limited the offer to the original terms
How does a merchant accept an offer to buy goods?
- Promise to ship the goods; or
- Shipping the goods within a reasonable time period
Does shipment of nonconforming goods qualify as acceptance?
Yes, but also constitutes breach
What is the mailbox rule?
Acceptance is effective upon DISPATCH
What happens if both an acceptance and rejection is sent by the offeree when the:
- Rejection is sent first?
- Acceptance is sent first?
- Acceptance will be effective if received BEFORE the rejection
- Acceptance effective upon dispatch (regardless of whether rejection is received before)
Define
consideration
- Detriment to promisee (promisee forgoes something of value); or
- Bargained-for exchange (must not be nominal)
Is consideration required to modify a contract under common law?
Yes, unless:
- New obligations on both sides; or
- Existence of circumstances unforeseen by either party
Does the UCC require consideration for modification?
No, as long as both parties are acting in good faith
Define
void contract
Entire contract is void and non-existent
Define
voidable contract
Valid contract unless one party seeks to void it
Define
unenforceable contract
A valid contract that cannot be enforced if one party halts performance
What are the 10 defenses to contract formation and enforceability?
- Duress
- Incapacity
- Illegality
- Misrepresentation
- Misunderstanding
- Mistake
- Public Policy
- Statute of Frauds
- Undue Influence
- Unconscionability
What actions can a court take upon finding a contract unconscionable?
- Declare the entire contract void;
- Strike the unconscionable clause while leaving the rest; or
- Rewrite the offending clause to make it conscionable
What are examples of procedural unconscionability?
- Adhesion contracts (“take it or leave it”)
- Contracts with boilerplate terms
- Contracts with hidden terms that are vague or confusing
What are examples of substantive unconscionability?
- Grossly excessive price
- Disproportionate consequences for minor breach
- Provisions unreasonably limiting warranties or remedies
Differentiate K’s that have illegal subject matter vs. illegal purpose
Illegal Subject Matter: Illegal and completely void & unenforceable
Illegal Purpose: Voidable by party who:
- Did not know of the purpose; or
- Knew but did not facilitate the purpose and the purpose does not involve “serious moral turpitude”
⚠️ Note: If both parties knew of the illegal purpose, K is void and unenforceable
When can a contract be voided for mutual mistake?
By the adversely affected party if:
- Both parties had a mistake of fact when the contract was formed;
- About a material assumption of the contract;
- Adversely affected party did not assume risk of the mistake; and
- Mistake cannot be fixed by reformation
When can a party void for unilateral mistake?
The adversely affected party can void if:
- There was a mistake as to basic assumption when K was formed;
- About material effect of K; and
- Adversely affected party did not assume risk of the mistake
AND either:
- Mistake would make K unenforceable; or
- Other party had reason to know of mistake; or
- Mistake was the other party’s fault
When can a party seek reformation for a mistake?
- Parties had a prior agreement;
- Parties agreed to put the prior agreement in writing; and
- There is a difference in the prior agreement and the writing due to mistake
What three factors do courts consider when deciding the enforceability of non-compete clauses?
- Is there a significant business justification (e.g. access to trade secrets);
- Is the scope reasonable in duration and geographical reach; and
- Is there an express provision of a covenant not to compete?
⚠️ Note: Courts can choose to enforce only reasonable provisions of a non-compete