Contracts Flashcards
Where do we ALWAYS start with a contracts question?
Applicable Law
Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) governs contracts for the sale of goods. The common law governs all other contracts.
Merchants [if applicable]
The UCC has special rules for merchants. Merchants are those who regularly deal in the goods involved in the contract. For purposes of the firm offer rule and the Statute of Frauds, a merchant also includes any business person when the transaction is commercial in nature.
Mixed Contracts
When a contract includes both goods and the provision of services, courts will apply the predominant purpose test to determine the applicable law by looking at the main reason for entering into the contract.
Contract Formation
A valid contract requires an offer, acceptance, and consideration.
Offer
An offer is a manifestation of intent to enter into a contract and requires definite and certain terms and must be communicated to the offeree.
Essential Terms
Under common law, all essential terms must be provided, which are the parties, subject matter, price, and quantity.
The essential terms required by the UCC are the parties, subject matter, and quantity. A court will “gap fill” any other missing terms, including price.
Acceptance
Acceptance requires a manifestation of assent to the terms of the offer. Acceptance can be communicated by words (oral or written) or conduct creating an implied-in-fact contract.
Bilateral Contracts
A bilateral contract is one where both parties make promises to perform.
Unilateral Contracts
A unilateral contract is one where the offeror’s promise is exchanged for the offeree’s performance.
Termination of an Offer
An offer may be terminated through a rejection, counteroffer, or revocation.
Rejection
An offeree may outright reject the offer by the offeror.
Counteroffer
A counteroffer is an offer made by the offeree that contains the same subject matter as the original offer but containing different terms. It is a rejection and a new offer.
Remember to distinguish between counterofferes and mere inquiries
Revocation
An offeror can revoke an ordinary offer at any time before acceptance. The revocation must be communicated to the offeree. A revocation can be effected through unambiguous words or conduct that is inconsistent with the intent to contract, so long as the offeree is aware of the words or conduct that indicate the offer was revoked.
UCC Firm Offers
UCC firm offers are irrevocable even without consideration. To be a firm offer, it must be made by a merchant, in a signed writing, and gives assurance it will be held open for the specified time. No offer can be irrevocable for more than three months without consideration.
Note: the offer is not automatically revoked after three months; the offeror can revoke after three months, but if he does not the offer remains open
Option Contract
An option contract is one where the offeror grants the offeree an “option” to enter into a contract for a specified period of time (or reasonable amount of time if not stated) in exchange for consideration.
Detrimental Reliance and Part Performance
An offer will be temporarily irrevocable if the offeree has made preparations to perform in reasonable reliance on the offer or has performed in part.
Illusory Contract
An illusory contract is an attempt to contract, but is not legally binding.
(i.e., “I will buy your car next week if I feel like it.”)
Implied-in-Fact Contract
An implied-in-fact contract is based on a tacit promise, inferred when conduct creates a contract, a benefit was received that could have been refused, and it would be fair to expect payment.
Examples - eating at a restaurant, getting a haircut without actually saying “please cut my hair”
Mailbox Rule
The mailbox rule provides an acceptance is effective upon dispatch.
Mailbox Rule Exceptions
- When the offer itself provides otherwise, the offer controls.
- An option contract is effective upon receipt.
- If both an acceptance and a rejection are sent, it depends which one was dispatched first. If the rejection was dispatched first, the acceptance will only become effective if it is received first. If the acceptance was dispatched first, it is effective upon dispatch consistent with the normal rule.
Output Contract
In an output contract, the buyer agrees to buy all of the seller’s output of a particular item for a specified period of time.
Note - be sure to analyze why it’s not illusory using the facts
Requirements Contract
In a requirements contract, the parties agree the seller will be the exclusive source of all the buyer’s requirements of a particular item for a specifified period of time.
Note - be sure to analyze why it’s not illusory using the facts
Mirror Image Rule
Under the common law, the mirror image rule provides that an acceptance must “mirror” the offer. If the acceptance conflicts with the terms of the offer or adds new terms, it is a rejection and counteroffer.
UCC 2-207
Under UCC 2-207, acceptance of an offer may be valid even if the terms are additional to or different from those contained in the offer, unless acceptance is expressly conditioned on assent to the additional or different terms.
NOTE: Follow this by an analysis of whether the terms are additional or different and whether the parties are merchants.
Additional Terms (UCC)
If any party is a non-merchant, any additional terms are a proposal and will not become part of the contract unless the other party consents. If both parties are merchants, additional terms automatically become part of the contract unless the offer expressly limits acceptance to its terms, the additional term materially alters the contract (e.g., warranty disclaimer), or the offeror objects to the additional term within a reasonable time.
Different Terms (UCC)
The majority of jurisdictions apply the “knock out” rule, which provides that conflicting terms will cancel each other out, leaving the contract only with the agreed upon terms, and the court will “gap fill” if needed. A minority of jurisdictions will either treat the different terms as additional terms or allow the offeror’s terms to control.
Acceptance by Shipping Goods
Unless the offer specifies otherwise, an offer to buy goods may be accepted by shipping conforming goods. If the seller ships non-conforming goods without acknowledging the non-conformity, the offer has been accepted and breached simultaneously. If the seller ships non-conforming goods as an accommodation, there is no acceptance and rather a counteroffer the buyer can choose to accept or reject.
Consideration
Consideration is a bargained for exchange of a legal detriment. A court will not inquire into the adequacy of the consideration. However, some types of promises, such as gifts, past consideration, and a pre-existing duty are not valid consideration.
Statute of Frauds
The Statute of Frauds (SOF) provides that certain types of contracts are unenforceable unless they are in writing, signed by the party to be charged, and contain the essential terms of the deal. Five categories of contracts fall within the SOF: marriage, real property, contracts that cannot be performed within one year, contracts for the sale of goods exceeding $500, and suretyship contracts.
Mnemonic - MSOUR
SOF Exceptions
- Made in consideration of marriage (e.g., although a prenup must be in writing, an agreement to enter into one need not be)
- Part performance in real estate contract (payment, improvements, possession - 2 of 3 generally required)
- Paying the debt of another when the main purpose is the promisor’s own economic benefit
- Sale of goods - goods are accepted and paid for or specially manufactured
Approach for SOF
- Determine whether SOF applies
- If SOF, determine if requirements are met (written and signed by party to be charged)
- If requirements are not met, discuss exceptions
Mutual Mistake
If both parties are mistaken as to a basic assumption of the contract and the mistake has a material effect on the deal, the contract is voidable so long as the adversely affected party did not assume the risk of the mistake.