Contract Practice Flashcards
Types of a claim?
Ø Contractual claims – arising out of breach of expressed provisions of the Contract (Additional payment under Clause 53 in FIDIC 1987 or Clause 20 in FIDIC 1999)
Ø Claims at law – breach of implied terms of the Contract (Decennial liability)
Ø Quantum meruit claims (Ex: Work done based on LOI)
Ø Ex gratia claims – out of kindness to maintain relationships (Ex: Due to substantial pricing errors, Exceptional price fluctuations)
What are the contents of a Contract Documents?
Vol 1 – Contract Agreement, Form of Tender, Instructions to Tenderers, CoC, App to Tender
Vol 2 – Specification
Vol 3 – BOQ
Vol 4 – Drawings
What is the advantage of having a LAD provision in the contract?
Ensure Contractor’s performance, Contractor’s risks are limited
Emp gets automatic right for recovery of damages, No need for proving actual damage
As per the OCoC Clause 47 - Contractor shall pay to the Employer the sum stated in the appendix to the Tender as a penalty for such default every day or part of the day as which shall elapse.
Partial completion portion may deducted from any penalty as per 47 (2)
What grounds COntractor can terminate? (Default of employer)
Contractor can terminate, if the employer;
a. Fails to pay the contractor within 60 days after the engineer's certification (subject to other provisions) b. Obstruct to issue such certificate or refuses any approvals which is fundamental for the execution of work c. Give formal notice to the contractor that for unforeseen reasons due to economic dislocation, it is impossible for him to continue to meet his contractual obligations
○ Contractor is entitle to terminate the employment after giving 14 days prior written notice
Emp obliged to pay the damages
Final accounts as per your contract (OCoC 1987)
• Within 6 months after issuing Maintenance Certificate - The Contractor shall submit statement of Final Account with supporting documents
1. Value of work +
2. All other sums due to him under the contract
(+Variations/Claims carried out during DLP)
• Within two months (with required backups) the Engineer shall issue a final certificate stating:
○ The amount finally due under the contract
○ The balance due from Emp to the contractor or from Contractor to the Emp
If agreed, Final Statement + discharge letter
If dispute exists, Eng issue Interim Payment Certificate, dispute may be administrated under Clause 67
Final payment within 60 days of receipt of Final Certificate.
How do you pay Material on Site & Off site?
• Invoices and delivery orders (physically verify quantity)
• Protected against all kinds of damages to the Eng approvals
• Quantity not exceeding the requirement (works+spares) and intended to be used in the project and not prematurely procured
• Not exceeding 80% of their value in accordance with the contract.
(% of invoice value as stated in App to Tender (1987) or 80% of the Engineer’s determination of cost (1999)
Material off-site (Oman Condition not allowed)
• The Contract should allow material off-site payments
• Vesting certificate – undertaking materials are sole property of the Emp
• Insurance – as Contract insurance policies do not cover off-site materials
• Clearly marked and separated from other materials
Factory inspection certificate
Why Extension of time?
Contractor to avoid liability for LD / Emp to avoid Time at Large situation
What is PI cover?
Professionals have a duty to exercise reasonable skill, care and diligence in the performance of his obligations.
Requirements to establish a claim under negligence - Duty of care owed, Breach of that duty occurred, Breach caused injured party to suffer loss.
What is Sectional completion and What is Partial possession
Sectional completion – completion of any Section for which separate Time for Completion is provided in the Contract
Partial possession – occupation or use of any substantial part of the Permanent Works by the Employer either before or after completion to the satisfaction of the Eng
What are other alternate dispute resolutions methods available
Negotiation, Mediation, Conciliation, Med-Ard, Expert Determination, Neutral Evalaution, Dispute Review Boards, Mini Trial
How to certify Advance Payment (pre requirements)
- LOA issued or On Signing the Form of Agreement
- Performance Bond
- Advance Payment Guarantee (for AP amount)
Advantages & Disadvantages of arbitration vs litigation;
Advantages;
○ Arbitrators are experts on this field
○ Confidentiality (private hearing)
○ Speed – 6 months under UAE law
○ Flexibility in procedure (place, date and time) Party autonomy
○ International enforceability – New York convention – 1959 (UAE joined in 2006)
Continuity of the same arbitrator(s)
DisAdvatages;
Cost
Power of arbitrators (Calling witnesses / disclosure of documents)
FIDIC Modified according to the client requirements (making it bespoke contract)
Payment terms Advance payment Price escalation disallowed Notice periods /Condition precedent EOT requirements Arbitration rules No Interest for late payments
Advance Payment, It’s purpose, value, validity and recovery?
Why AP – generally there is a negative cash flow for most part of the project at the beginning, reduce finance cost to Contractor and reduce tender price.
Generally, against a bond - Contractor has to submit approved wording, contract copy and cash flow forecast to obtain AP Bond from bank.
Advance Payment Amount = 10% x Contract Value - Contingencies
Recovery : 10% of the estimated value of Permanent Works executed during the period to which the interim certificate applies
APB Validity Period : 12 months or until the full recovery of the advance payment whichever is the later.
Emp obligations towards Nominated SC
○ Selection and appointment of a suitable SC on time
○ Nominate another SC if Main Contractor raise reasonable objection – Clause 59.2
○ Making direct payments to NSC in case of MC’s failure – OCoC Clause 59.5
○ Appoint another SC if the NSC fails to perform
What is a contract?
A contract is a legally binding agreement with specific terms made between two or more parties in which there is a promise to do something in return for a valuable benefit known as consideration.
What is meant by Cross liability ?
When insurance under both contractor and employer, damages to both parties are covered as if they are separately insured
Interim Payment Certificate
Clause 60.4 – within 28 days of receipt of statement, Eng shall issue an Interim Payment Certificate to Emp subject to;;
² Retention - 5% of Contract Sum
² Partial recovery of any advance payment
² Any sums which are due & payable to the Emp
Previous payment made by the Emp
Headings of a loss and expense claim?
- Delay cost due to each delay event derived from contemporary records (idling resources, demobilizing and remobilizing costs etc)
- Loss of productivity / disruption costs (measured mile approach)
- Prolonged site overheads (staff, office, utilities, plant, transport, insurance, bonds)
- Under-recovery of head office overheads (formula – Hudson, Emden, Eichleay etc)
- Additional finance charges due to longer duration
- Finance charges due to late release of retentions
- Subcontractor’s claims
- Escalation claims (Late procurement)
- Loss of profit
Final accounts procedure as per the FIDIC 87?
The contractor statement of final account to be included following;
- Value of work done accodance with contract
- Any further sum contractor consider due under the contract
Upon receipt of the draft final account statement, I will check and agreed with the contractor. Further, request the discharge letter from contractor assuring that agreed amount is final amount no any future claim as well. The dicharge letter will be activated, when the final payment certificate issued and release the performance bond as well.
When a contractor is not agreed to part of the final account, the interim payment to be issue to contractor and disputed part need to refer to the Engineer’s decision.
Oman Court Structure, Oman Legal System, Important Law Provisions in Oman
Court Structure
1. Primary Court - Court of First Instance 2. Court of Appeal (within 30 days) 3. Court of Cassation (Supreme Court)
Oman Legal System
• Common law system (Written +Judge made law + Judicial Precedent)
• Civil law system (Written only, codified law)
Important Law Provisions in Oman
• Oman Arbitration Law (Royal Decree 47/1997 as amended)
• Contracts (Muqawala) - Civil Code (Royal Decree 29/2013)
Labour Law - (Royal Decree 35/2003)
Requirements for issuing TOC/CC?
○ Permanent Works should be substantially completed Satisfactorily
○ Passed any Tests on Completion
○Written undertaking from the Contractor to finish any outstanding work during DLP
What are the types of programmes in a project?
Baseline Programme
Revised programmes
As-built programme
What is variation?
Variation is any changes made to the original scope
○ Increase or decrease of the quantity of any work
○ Omit any such work
○ Change the character or quality or kind
○ Change the levels, lines, positions, dimensions
○ Execute additional works
○ Change the specified sequence or timing of the work