Constitutional Law Flashcards
Con Law Issues Checklist
- Justiciability
- State Action
- State Power
- Federal Powers
- Limitations on State Power
- Limitations on Federal Power
- State and Federal Power Limitations/Individual Rights
Justiciability Checklist
- Case or Controversy
- Standing
- Ripe (not too early)
- Moot (not too late)
- 11th Amendment
Federal Powers Checklist
- Congress
- Judiciary
- Executive
Limitations on State Power Checklist
- Supremacy/Preemption
- DCC
- Privileges and Immunities Clause
- Contracts Clause
Limitations on Federal Power Checklist
- 10th Amendment
2. Improper delegation of legislative power
State and Federal Power Limitations/Individual Rights Checklist
- 1st Amendment - freedom of religion
- 1st Amendment - freedom of speech
- Freedom of Association
- Due Process Clause (Substantive and Procedural)
- Equal Protection Clause
- Takings
Justiciability: Case/Controversy
- Actual Dispute
- No political questions
Note: declaratory judgments are ok but advisory opinions are not.
Justiciability: Standing
- Individual
- injury
- causation
- rederessabilty
- 3d party
- individual standing
- special relationship b/w P and 3d party
- difficult for 3d party to assert his own rights
- Organizational
- elements above, and
- members standing
- related to organizational purpose
- parties’ participation not req’d
- Taxpayer: federal tax or spending program that violates the Establishment Clause
Justiciability: 11th Amendment
Immunity to the states:
- Cannot sue state
- Bars actions for damages
- Cities and counties OK
State Action - The action of a private actor can qualify as state action if:
- Traditional public function (e.g. parks, prisons, elections), or
- Government entanglement
*Always put a line or two about there being state action if an essay.
10th Amendment
Powers not delegated to federal government saved for states.
Federal govt can’t commandeer states
Federal Powers: Congress
- Commerce
- Tax and spend
- War
- Naturalization/bankrupt.
- Necessary and proper - if rationally related
Federal Powers: Congress can regulate commerce if:
A. Interstate
1. Channels of interstate commerce
2. Instrumentalities of interstate commerce
3. Persons & things moving in interstate commerce
4. Activities w/substantial effect on interstate commerce
B. Intrastate (purely local)
- Economic
1. Rational belief
2. Substantial economic effect or a substantial cumulative economic effect (ie growing wheat or MJ)
- Noneconomic
1. Direct and substantial effect
Federal Powers: Judiciary
- Cases under the Constitution
- Admiralty
- 2 states
- Citizens of diff. states
- Foreign country or citizen
- Not if independent and adequate state grounds
Federal Powers: Executive
- Carry out laws
- Executive order
- Treaties
- Appointments
- Foreign affairs
- Pardon federal offenses
- Veto bills - but no line item
- Executive privilege is qualified: weigh govt. interest
Limitations on State Power: Supremacy Clause
The Constitution is the supreme law of the land and if any State law conflicts with or impedes federal law or regulates an area traditionally occupied by congress it will be pre-empted
Limitations on State Power: Dormant Commerce Clause (DCC)
- Discriminatory or undue burden
- If discriminatory on its face, must be:
- Necessary to
- Important noneconomic govt. interest
- No reasonable alternative
- Undue burden/if not discriminatory on its face, then:
- Rational basis applied
- Balance burden v. benefit
- Exceptions:
- Market participant: state not acting as a regulator, but rather owns or operates a business
- Congress’s consent
Limitations on State Power: Privileges/Immunities Clause
- State cannot discriminate against noncitizens
- Unless substantially related and no less discriminatory alternatives
- Rights fundamental to national unity
- Corps/aliens are not citizens
Limitations on State Power: Contracts Clause
Prevents state governments from passing laws that retroactively and substantially impair existing contracts.
- Private Ks: substantial impairment; reasonable appropriate to significant/legitimate public interest
- Public Ks: necessary to important public purpose (stricter application)
Declaratory Judgment
judgments that state the legal effect of a regulation or the conduct of parties in regard to a controversy.