Constitutional Law Flashcards
Justiciable Case or Controversy
“RAMPSE” - (1) Ripeness; (2) Abstention; (3) Mootness; (4) Political Question; (5) Standing; and (6) Eleventh Amendment
Ripeness
1) π suffers (threat of) harm, 2) fit for review, 3) sufficient facts & record for review
Abstention
Fed. Ct will abstain from hearing con. law claim on unsettled question of STATE law
Mootness
must have a controversy at all stages of proceeding or the case will be dismissed unless: 1) issue capable of repetition but evading review OR 2) voluntary cessation - rep’s claim in class action moot, other claims still viable
Political Question
issue for other branch or inherently incapable of judicial resolution
Standing
1) injury in fact, 2) causation between conduct and injury, 3) redressability
Standing (associational standing)
1) members would have standing on own, 2) interests germane to org’s purpose, 3) individual members participation not required
Standing (taxpayer)
Usually Establishment Clause. 1) enacted under Congress’s taxing and spending power, 2) exceeds some specific limitation on power
Eleventh Amendment
Can’t sue state in fed. ct unless sues state officer, ST consents, Congress removes immunity (EXCEPTION: actions against local governments or state officers for injunctive relief are NOT barred)
Government Power
Separation of Powers; Fed Legislative Powers; Fed Executive Powers; Federalism;
Separation of Powers (judicial)
justiciability, supreme court review - writ of certiorari
Separation of Powers (legislative)
sources of power (express/implied, necessary & proper) and limitation
Separation of Powers (executive)
foreign/domestic powers/limitations, exec. privilege/immunity, impeach
Federal Legislative Powers
“CON T3” - (1) Commerce Clause; (2) Others (citizenship, civil Rights, foreign affairs, war, elections, property); (3) Necessary & Proper; (4) Tax/Spending; (5) Taking Property; (6) Tenth Amendment
Commerce Clause
Congress may regulate: (1) channels of ICC, and (2) instrumentalities of ICC (persons and things in ICC); and (3) may regulate economic activity that has a substantial effect of ICC (in the area of noneconomic activity, a substantial effect cannot be based on cumulative impact)
Tax/Spending Clause
Congress may tax and spend for the general welfare (and may enact any tax to raise revenue for the general welfare)
Other Legislative Powers
Citizenship (power is plenary), Civil Rights, Foreign Affairs, War, Elections, Property (can dispose of and make all needful rules regarding territories and property of the US)
Necessary and Proper Clause
May use any means not prohibited by Constitution to execute any branch’s authority
Tenth Amendment
powers not granted to U.S., or prohibited to states, reserved to states/people (Congress cannot commandeer state action BUT can put strings on grants unless unduly coercive; AND may prohibit harmful commercial activity by state governments)
Federal Executive Powers (foreign affairs)
President represents U.S. to foreign nations (treaties and exec agreements)
Treaties
Power to enter into treaties (2/3 Senate approval needed for ratification)
Executive Agreements
Power to sign w/ head of foreign country. No senate consent.
Federal Executive Powers (domestic affairs)
appointment of officers, removal power, veto power, pardons
Federal Executive Powers (Commander-in-Chief)
cannot declare war but can deploy troops
Federal Executive Power (scope of power)
Youngstown Sheet:
i. Acts with express or implied Congressional authority, powers at highest (“maximum power”)
ii. Acts where Congress is silent, action upheld unless usurps power of another branch (“zone of twilight”)
iii. Acts against express Congressional will, has little authority (“lowest ebb”)
Executive Privilege and Immunity
i. Privilege applies to communications unless required for criminal proceeding
ii. Absolute immunity from civil suits for official actions while in office only
Impeachment
majority in the House needed to charge impeachment and a 2/3 Senate vote to convict and remove from office
Federalism
Preemption, Dormant CC, Privilege and Immunities, Art. IV (P&I); 14th Amend (P&I)
Preemption
Supremacy Clause (Art. IV) fed laws supreme law of land (express or implied)
Dormant Commerce Clause
state law that places “undue burden on ICC” unconstitutional:
i. Discrimination against out of staters presumed to be undue burden on ISC unless . . .
EEXCEPTIONS - [“MINE DAT”] - 1) state is Market participant, 2) law furthers Important, Non-Economic state interest, and there are non-Discriminatory Alternatives; or 3) law favors government performing Traditional government functions
Privileges and Immunities Clause (Art. IV)
No state may deny citizens of other states privileges & immunities it accords own citizens (anti-discrimination) unless necessary for important govt interest; No less restrictive alt; Apply when local laws discriminate against citizens of other states (if it does not discriminate, do not apply)