Constitutional framework Flashcards
Origins
Based on Article of Confederation
Agreed upon by original 13 states
Rebellions led to Constitutional Convention 1787
Founding Fathers
Key Features
- representative gov not democracy
- product of time and culture
- not focused on individual rights (those first appeared in 1791 Bill of Rights)
- order was significant
- limited government
- codified
- vague
- soveriegn
not easily changed
implied and enumerated
powers outlined vaguely
key powers (eg. congress power of the purse and president commander-in-chief)
Vagueness
Benefits:
- allows to evolve (eg. Immigration Act banned entry of Asian people into the USA)
Weaknesses:
- no mention against slavery
- didnt originally enfranchise minorities (took ammendments eg, 19th)
- vague in terms of gun rights
- lack of clarity in terms of whether the president or congress is responsible for initiating military action
Judicial review
- grants the Court power to interpret the Constitution
- not mentioned in Constitution but precedent set by 1803 case of Marbury v Madison
- led to inevitable politicisation
- Plessy v Ferguson reversed by Brown v Board
Gridlock
- all laws must be approved by both congressional chambers
- there is frequently competition and deadlock between different branches
- a limited government shutdown has occurred due to disagreements over the budget (eg. 35 day December 2018 gridlock because Trump wanted more money for his wall)
Elections
- Constitution places organisation of elections in the hands of states
- many rules not uniform across US (eg. use of postal ballots, early voting , primaries and caucuses)
- Utah mails ballots wheras some use electronic voting machines)
Separation of powers
- separate articles of the Constitution designed to define three branches
Is SoP significant?
Yes:
- each branch clearly checked and limited
- no one can serve in two simultaneously (eg. Hilary Clinton resigned as senator when appointed secretary of state)
- prevents notion of elective dictatorship as president cannot get policy through without congress
No:
- ‘separation’ is misleading, should be referred to as ‘shared’ powers
- the vice president is also the senate president and has casting vote in the event of a tie (Mike Pence used this to confirm Betty DeVos as education secretary)
- a president with a supportive supreme court and controls congress wields alot of power
presidential checks on congress
- can veto legislation passed by congress ~(Trump vetoed resolution to his emergency border)
- can issue executive orders to bypass need for formal legislation (Trumps travel ban)
- commander-in-cheif role used to deploy US troops avoiding congressional approval (Bush and Iraq invasion)
presidential checks on the courts
- nominates all federal judges (Obama and Sonia Sotomayor)
- issue pardons (Ford pardoned Nixon)
congress checks on president
- veto can be overturned by supermajority in both houses (Bush had 4/12 vetoes overridden)
- senate must confirm presidential appointments to admin (last cabinet nominee to be rejected was John Tower 1989)
- congress has the ‘power of the purse’ (Trump and border wall funding)
congress checks on court
- congress can impeach federal justices (2010 Thomas Porteous impeached for corruption)
- constitutional amendments can be initiated to overturn supreme court verdicts (1896 income tax ruled unconstitutional reversed by ratification of the 13th ammendment)
judicial checks on president
- can rule presidential actions as unconstitutional (2020 2 cases against Trump court ruled that presidents arent above law even when in office)
judicial checks on congress
- can declare acts by congress as unconstitutional (defense of marriage act ruled unconstitutional which allowed for same-sake marriage)