Constitution Flashcards

1
Q

Functions of finance commission

A
  1. Distribution of net proceeds
  2. Principle govern grant in aid
  3. Measures to augment consolidated fund of state to supplement resource of panchayat, mucipalities
  4. Any other matter
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Indian vs western secularism

A
  1. Seperate vs principled distance
  2. Non interferenec vs positive (haj, kumbhamela), secular
  3. Uniform law vs seperate personal laws
  4. No aid vs religious endowment act
  5. Primacy to individual liberty vs coupled with community rights
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Limitations of the basic structure approach? Wf? Conclusion

A
  1. Textual legitimacy leading to elastic nature of basic structure
  2. Tyranny of unelected - njac 99th- 2/3 + 20
  3. Whims of judges - precendents
  4. Against separation of power which in itself is a basic structure
  5. not immune- defeated within 2 years

VP - severe compromise of parliament sovereignty and mandate of people

Wf- constitutional bench , amend 368, Australia- referendum conducted for major amendment

Fresh breath of air to politico legal jurisprudence

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Articles related to anti defection

A
  1. 1985-52nd aa, xnth schedule
  2. 102 - disqualified
  3. 191- la, lc
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Recommemdations wrt anti defection

A
  1. Dinesh goswami committee - only in case of no confidence motion against party whip
  2. Halim - certain restrictions- not allowed to join other political party
  3. Manipur defection case - permanent tribunal
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

PAC origin

A

Montagu chelmsford reform

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Give some limitations of pac

A
  1. PRS data - fewer reports per year since 1980
    ** since 2019 only 15 reports **
  2. Consensus - vaccine production and distribution couldn’t be adopted as one of the agenda
  3. Politicisation
    Ex: 2017 pac chairman criticised for calling PM to explain demonetisation
  4. Post mortem - excess grants
  5. Advisory - parl final decision
  6. Officers dodging summons
  7. No technical expertise, dependence on CAG- difficult to function in case of CAG oversight
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Functions of drsc

A

Demand for grants before voting, bills, annual report, national basic long term policy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Key points for misuse of Parliamentary privileges

A
  1. 2017 karnataka speaker 2 journalists for a year
  2. 2019- Maharashtra speaker ordered action of arrest against a man for creating parody video of a speech made by mla
  3. Judge and plaintiffs
  4. Rti, rtk under 19(1)
  5. Social contract- instrument to uphold citizen welfare not gag genuine

Keshav Singh case- privileges subject to FR

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Current provisions to maintain judicial accountability

A
  1. 124(4) , Judges inquiry act
  2. Charter called ‘ restatement of judicial values’ in 1997- guidelines for general behaviour of judges
  3. 235 - HC control over subordinate courts
  4. Sc aggarwal case - cji public authority under RTI
  5. System of appeal, review
  6. Collegium- send back, but if reiterated
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Way forward to ensure judicial accountability

A
  1. Judicial standards and accountability bil- 2010 - assets, standards of conduct, minor disciplinary
  2. 2nd arc senior judge of SC- JUDICIAL VALUE COMMISSIONER
  3. Denmark and Sweden - spl institutions

Sp Gupta vs UOI - court accountable to the public for the decision it takes on behalf of public

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Define ODR

A

It’s an ADR ( ANM) for small and medium value cases using digital tech

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Cabinet committee introduction

A

GOI TRANSACTION OF BUSINESS RULES 1961 - Emerging out of 77(3) - dispose off his dept- if concerns other- concurrence under the authority of cabinet

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Difference between cabinet committee vs parl committee

A
  1. Members- ministers vs mp
  2. Pm vs prstv
  3. Changes vs 1 year
  4. Chairman- pm vs speaker selects
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Wf to solve iswd

A
  1. Interstate council
  2. CW mgmt authority - mihir shah
  3. Track 2 paradiplomacy - Cauvery water family -f2f
  4. Supply side to demand side management
  5. Frances system of water parliament ( advisory and leadership role within river basin) - seats reserved for NGO and environmental specialist
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Some recommendations of sarkaria commision wrt FEDRALISM

A
  1. President if withholding state bill—–> give reasons
  2. Concurrent list - consult state
  3. Consult CM before appointment of governor
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Difference between niti ayog and pc

A
  1. Competitive+ cooperative vs dictated fedralism
  2. Top down
  3. Instant monitoring - development and monitoring agency vs post mortem
  4. action, strategy, vision- 3,7,15
  5. Market economy vs socialism
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Why ULB less revenue

A
  1. Populism- free water , free electricity
  2. Cag report - lacunae in acc keeping
  3. Sfc
    **ONLY 9 states have constituted 6th sfc out of which only 2 are active **
  4. Poor quality services , citizens unwilling to pay
  5. Urban sprawl - jurisdiction
  6. Tools like municipal bonds
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Wf for boosting ulb bodies

A
  1. property tax - satellite based monitoring and formalising cadastral maps
    **ES 2017- Bangalore, Jaipur are collecting 5-20% of their potential property tax
  2. Credit rating system so as to explore bond market
  3. Betterment levy, unlock land value
  4. Need to balance their budgets by law ( similar to frbm)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Introduction of PMO

A

Is a staff agency to assist PM in efficient discharge of his role. Status of dept under allocation of businees rules 1961

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Issues of the office of CAG

A
  1. Delay- demonetisation, rafale deal
  2. Rbi, fci, lic
  3. Secret services
  4. Presumptive loss highlighted by cag
  5. Redactive pricing audit
  6. Formal apology of vinod rai in 2g spectrum case
  7. Since 1996 only one iaas
  8. Sc judgements
    - V subramian Balaji vs tn - duty of CAG arises only after expenses have occurred
    - Suleman Rahamat khan vs state — CAG cannot question policy objectives of govt
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Removal of upsc

A

Insolvent, paid employment outside, infirmity of mind

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Criticism of 15th fc

A
  1. All South except tn
  2. Post devolution revenue deficit grant - disincentivising financial prudence

Es 2017 - states heavy dependency on aid
- aid curse - no effort to develop public infra
- citizen not able to hold state accountable- as state not depended on their tax

  1. Local bodies tied grants
  2. TOR included monitoring performance of power reforms, tax reforms- against constitutional role.
  3. Sector specific grants, performance based grants — increasing central govt interference
  4. Cess and surcharge,

NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND POLICY STUDY - increase to 42% by 14th Fc neutralised by redn of other grants by center

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

Issues with national commission for protection of child rights,, nice

A
  1. 2020-21– 16% increase in crime against children
  2. One third of child brides in india ( unicef)
  3. Allegations of turning blind eye towards police brutality of children during caa protests
  4. Indifferent - online trafficking, child porno
  5. No condom ad (6-10), bombay begum
  6. During pandemic - child labor, abuse etc increased manifold

Nice
1. Jj act, pocso— instrumental
2. Bal swaraj, samwedhna, corporal punishment
3, audits in CCI - muzzafarpur shelter home
4. Rehabilitation of children in conflict with law -
5. Quick response cell to stop instances of child marraige

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Issues with minorities commission
1. 6/7 post including chairman were vacant for in 2021 2. No constitutional status. No power of civil court while conducting enquiries 3. Politicization of appointnent- non competency - pendancy 4. Minority commission only in 16 states - no hierarchial setup - overburdened 5. Centralization and no multiple benches - citizens don't approach 6. Financial allocation, technological capacity
25
Criticism with NGT
1. As of June 22– 2200 cases pending with NGT 2. Development vs conservation dilemma 2. Wpa 1972,fra 2006 3. Enforcement of verdict 4. Often simultaneously in SC - 136, PIL 5. EXpert vacanicies - ussullay retired ifos officers 7. Expertise - SC questioned NGt In subansiri manas project. Court overruled the ban 8. SC revered mopa airport case - said lacked merit based review 9. Sc Criticism of mechanical pre draft orders
26
Issues with cvc
1. No investigative wing of it's own. CBI Or departmental CVO 2. Multiple - cvc, CBI, lokpal 3. Advisory. No power to register criminal case or ask cbi to inquire 5. Delay, very low conviction rate - not effective Detterent
27
Wf for cvc
1. Investigative wing 2. Clearly delinetae - cvc, CBI, lokpal 3. Preventive mechanism rather than post facto 4. Specialized wing to study procedures of decision making especially in corruption prone ministries 5. Establish formal mechanism for communication and coordination between CAG and CVC
28
Ahmadi committee suggestions on NHRC
1. Financial autinomy 2. Power to choose own staff 3. Chairman to be a member of appointing committee 4. Hr violations of armed forces
29
Issues with CBI
1. Caged parrot- opposition and coalition 3. No suo motto 4. Dpse act- consent of states - bureacratic lethargy, vested interests 5. 10 states have withdrawn consent - latest being T.N 5. Asthana vs verma 6. Several failed cases — arushi case But the conviction rate as of 2022 stands at ~75%
30
Reforms needed in cbi
1. Parl standing Committee - archaic dpse with CBI act - CBI cadre PSC , recent 1. New law - 2. Director of CBI to monitor the vacancies 3. Case statistics and annual report on its website 2. Bifurcate into anti corruption body and national crimes bureau 3. Role of cvc, CBI, lokpal 4. CBI to appoint it's own public prosecutor ( now law min) 5. Rti- social audit
31
2nd ARC about regulatory bodies and other
1. Detailed review. Regulate only where necessary 3. Drsc 4. Involving citizen group and professional org in regulation activities Damodaran commitee has also recommended direct accountability of regulatory bodies to parliament
32
Issues with UAPA
1. Vague - indefinite definition of terrorism- raising funds, preparation 2. Increasing cases - 72% 2019 over 2015 2. Arrest w/o warrant (43 A, 43B), deny bail, 30 days police and 180 days judicial custody without warrant, secret witness during proceedings 3. Curb dissent Put a box and write Asif Iqbal Tanha case : state has blurred the line between rt to protest and terrorist activity 4. Fedralism - police in state list 5. Low conviction rate - only 3% convicted out of total arrest between 2018 and 2020
33
Act of electoral bond
Finance act 2017
34
Issues with electoral bond
1. According to EC —- Retrograde, 29C 3. Shell companies. Now no limit 3. Companies need not declare names of parties to which they have donated. Against the rt of shareholders 4. Fcra- foreign companies registered in india - unchecked foreign fund 5. Companies can use it as a legal channel to round trip their tax haven cash 6. Against RTK of citizens. But govt can obtain data bcoz sbi is a psu ADR report - maximum donation is being made to current government
35
Way forward for electrol funding
1. SY quereshi - national electoral fund 2. Indrajit gupta - state funding 3. Ec - political parties cag audit
36
Intro and conclusion for RTI
Intro - aruna roy MKSS and other citizen groups Conclusion- American sc judge louis brandies " Sunlight is the best disinfectant and electricity the best policeman "
37
Wf for RTI act 2nd arc
1. Public records office 2. Single window system- application and su motto 3. Uniform rate and multiple modes 4. Osa - national security act
38
Introduction for sedition
124A of IPC Was put on hold by sc in sg vombatkere case. The new BNS bill does away with sedition, but has a similar sounding provision under A.150, though the word sedition is not used
39
Issues with 124A sedition
1. Colonial legacy . All major democracies including UK 3. Range of communication- holding posters, social media posts, raising slogans and personal communications . 4. Vague provisions - hatred, contempt, disaffection Shreya Singhal case struck down 66a bcoz it was vague Note : more clear in bns bill. But ‘ sovereignty and unity of India ‘ 3. Conviction rate at 3.3% (2019) 4. Authorities not following ‘ Kedarnath spirit’- incite violence or creates public disorder
40
Hate speech conclusion recommendatioms
1. Bezbaruah - anti racial discrimination under IPC, helpline 2. Vishwanathan commitee - cyber crime coordinator state, anti cyber crime cell - district 3. True speech - banglore police
41
Reforms under 2nd ARC for police reforms
1. Seperate l&o and investigation 3. District attorney 4. Ulb- local police 5. Outsource non core functions - address verification 6. National level coordination Institute - for various interstate crimes
42
Wf for custodial torture
1. Dk basu guidelines 2. Anti torture bill 2017 needs to be revamped - state responsible for injury and bop on police Concln - peelian principe of London metropolitan police - persuasion, advice, warning
43
Prakash singh case
1. Fix tenure and selection of dgp, ig 2. Police establishment board 3. State Police complaint authority
44
Through multiple judgements SC upheld 3 broad principles regarding imprisonment and custody
1. Will not become non human 2. All human rights within limitation 3. No justification for aggravating suffering already inherent in the incarceration
45
2 major commitees for prision reforms
1. Mulla commitee - national prison commisson (modernization), seperate undertrials from. Convicts 2. Amitava roy- One lawyer - 30 prisoners Video conferencing for trial
46
Recommendations for election disputes
Law commission recommendations 1. Electoral benches in each HC 2. Simplify the procedure for filing EP 3. Speedy trial and disposal
47
Issues wrt MPLADS
1. Fedralism - directly to district authority 2. Against doctrine of SOP - 2 nd arc 3. Non lapsable - election rush 4. Cag- no inclusive participation 5. Nepotism
48
6th schedule issues
1. Tribal vs non tribal conflicts- non tribal calls out the provision to be discriminatory 2. Functional overlap with pri Or muncipal 3. Multiple power center - ex: Meghalaya though a state, almost entire state under 6th schedule 4. North cachar - money to extremist 5. Bias - bodoland 6. Law- assent of governor - no time limit 7. Various tribal group with diff customs under one DC — logjam —- chakma council in Assam 8. Power capture by elites 9. Forum to propagate their political future,,, not working for welfare of the dc Cji hidyatullah - mini Constitution
49
Issues with FRA 2006
1. Lack of proper land record - huge rejection rate 2. Subdistrict and district- bureaucratic inefficiencies 3. Forest right committees not being formed by gram Sabha 4. Xaxa - rejected wo reason - wrong interpretation of OTFD, gps survey 5. Rejection not communicated and rt to appeal not explained 6. Alienation - forest authorities reluctant to share power Flip side - ETURUNAGARAM in Andhra - vast encroachment in forest land post fra cut off date to put forth illegal land claims
50
Reforms proposed by ec over the years
1. Candidate - charge >5 yrs, ep against defeated candidate also 2. Election- paid news- electorl offence, 126- print media, 6 months prior to expiry ban on adv of govt achievement 3. Process - totalizer, don't transfer election officer, register and deregister
51
Major recco of 15th FC
1. Fd to 4% in next 5 fiscals 2. 41% 3. Sfc by 2024 4. New defence fund 5. Grants- local bodies grant, Sector specific, revenue deficit , disaster management 6. performance based incentives - aspirational district, tourism promotion, discom reforms etc
52
Salient features of the new IT rules 2021
1. Social media, digital news, OTT 2. Social media - grievance, cno, compalice officer, monthly report about their complaince mechanism, 3. Traceability - first orginator - sovereignty and public order 4. Digital media and OTT platform - self regulation by publisher, self regulating body, oversight mechanism by min of I&B 5. OTT platform publish post self classification based on age. Parental locks
53
Define NGO
Self governing, pvt, not for profit organization that are geared towards various initiatives including community development or environmental protection.
54
Strength of ngo
1. Proximity to grassroot 2. Flexible, One issue - speed 3. Trust. Lwe 5. Expertise 6. innovation - ubi in Mp Sewa 7. Participative democracy
55
Challenges of NGO
1. IB report - IMPACT OF NGO ON DEV— Kudankulam project, us based solar equipment 2. mercy cops - insurgents 3. Compassion intl- conversion 4. CBI report - only 10% registered NGO file annual report 5. No short term courses 6. Muzaffarpur shelter home 7. Changing nature of social activism- more career oriented rather than bringing on ground changes 8. No good board of governanace 9. fire fighting approach. No sustained solution
56
Define CSR
Concept whereby companies integrate socially beneficial programmes in their business operation by spending a% Of their profit. Companies act 2013 made it mandatory
57
Define citizen charter
Commitment by pub authorities for delivery of services according to predetermined standards. Makes them accountable to citizens and hence improve public service delivery
58
Reco of 2 nd arc for cc
1. One size do not fit all 2. Reform internal process to meet 3. Cc should be prepared for each individual unit under the overall umbrella of org charter 4. Periodic evaluation 5. Hold officers accountable
59
Few examples of recent culture of secracy
1. RTI ACT - Less than 45% 2. Electoral bonds -29C 3. Osa still 4. Reports - vohra committee 5. Ddpb amending rti
60
Case for lateral entry
1. Delhi Metro (technocrat), nandan nilekeni 2. Cyber crime, terrorism. AVGC commitee 3. Baswan committee 4. Fresh ideas 5. Career bureaucrats motivated 6. Common practice in us uk
61
Challenges for lateral entry
1. Spoils system 2. 3 years + renumeration not competitive with pvt sector 3. Work culture + systemic interference 4. Need vs demand ( market model) 4 . policy vs ground implementation 5. Systemic inertia already at place 6. System of positive discrimination might be affected 7. Dependence on few individuals for domain expertise might backfire at later stage
62
How pressure groups helped democracy
1. Educating public - extinction rebellion 2. Mobilising - farm protest 3. Policy formulation - ORF 4. Economic growth- FICCI, tax reforms to suit the govt 5. Env issues - narmada bachao 6. Vulnerable- sewa, mahila sashaktikaran andolan- 498A, maternity benifit bill
63
Reasons for removal of indian president vs American prez
Violation of constn Conviction of treason, bribery, high crimes, misdemeanor
64
Challenges of health insurance pointed out by amartya sen in his book UNCERTAIN GLORY
1. distortion isssue- biased against phc- only if hospitalised 4. Efficiency issue - moral hazard, no incentive for hospital to be efficient
65
Key points to remember for French const
1. Written 2. Very rigid 3. Judicial review- constitutional council with a 9 year term - advisory body 4. Multiple citizenship 5. Executive president - directly elected for seven years 6. French PM assist prez in day to day 7. French parl very limited powers. Rest of the matters taken care by Prez. 8. unitary Quasi presidential+ quasi PM
66
Key features of USA const
1. Written 2. Rigid 3. President 4 years 4. Fedral 5. Dual citizenship Jury system Prez recommends name to Senate
67
Key features of Russian constn
1. Rigid 2. Fedral 3. semi presidential 4. dual citizenship with those countries that have signed treaty with Russia. Ex: Tajikistan 5. Fr are there
68
Pesa issues
Part 1X to schedule V 1. Allegations of political considerations in forming Tac and declaring fifth schedule areas 2. Traditional practises of tribals have not yet been imbibed into the pesa- mankia Munda 3. Only Rajasthan left 4. Ambiguous defn and interpretation of bureaucracy-Mfp, minor water body definition 5. Gram Saba should be consulted for diversion of land land but it’s only on paper 6. Lanjia Saora, bills, Santhal, Gonds , not yet accustomed 7. 2 ministries –Ministry of tribal affairs and Ministry of PR 8. push for corporate entry - allegations of companies splitting up tribals by bribing some
69
Mental health care act 2017 key points
1. Right to live with dignity 2. Right to access public health centres 3. Right to give advance directives regarding mode of treatment 4. Right to confidentiality 5. Electro convulsive shock therapy cannot be used without giving muscle relaxant  6. Mental health authority at central and state
70
Features of fptp ( opposite will be for proportional representation)
1. Big constituency 2. Only one candidate wins per constituency 3. Usually vote for the candidate and not the party 4. More seats than the votes 
71
Niti ayog good things
1. Premier think tank –key role in design an pd conceptualisation of Ayushmann Bharat, model land leasing act 2. Island development agency, Northeast development agency 3. Cooperative fedralism via governing council meetings 5. Competitive federalism – SDG India index, composite water management index 6. Innovation –arise – prototype to commercial 7. Knowledge hub – best practises
72
Parliamentary vs presidential system
1. dual executive (President plus Prime Minister ) vs President is the real executive 2. Collective responsibility versus President directly accountable to the people 3. Dual membership – ministers are members of both legislature and the executive 4. Dissolution of the lower house versus no dissolution 6. No strict Separation of powers versus strict separation of powers
73
National courts of appeal need
1. Judicial burden 2. Constitutional cases like Shreya Singhal, Naz foundation et cetera was heard by two judge bench 3. International practice of having cassation benches 4. Law commission under Justice KK Matthew has suggested that Supreme Court should have two divisions – constitutional and appeals 5. Against article 39A-Poor has to travel all the way to Delhi
74
Can ADR Completely replace courts
1. Marriage and commercial settlement cases okay 2. Mediation, conciliation et cetera might lead one to settle for lesser compensation 3. Often the poor maybe the one who will be compromising 4. The practice of following judicial precedents Necessary to bring about certain degree of standardisation and uniformity
75
Few cases where SC interfered in management of temples
1. Sabarimala case, Haji Ali Dargah case- opening temple to women 2. Shirur Mutt case – state can control secular activities 3. Chidambaram Temple case – article 26 doesn’t give the right to mismanage 4. Parsi women who have married outside their religion have the right to participate in the fire worship
76
Issues with tribunals in general and way forward
Issues 1. Under the control of line ministry 2. From RK Jain to Chandrakumar case Supreme Court has tried to point out several lacunas 3. Delay- DRt- on an average more than 50% failed hearing 4. National tax Tribunal was dissolved by Supreme Court because it usurped the power of civil courts 5. Several zonal councils of NGT was shut down because of vacancies Wf 1. R. Gandhi case- shouldn’t be under the control of line ministry against which it has to pass orders 2. The recent Roger Matthew case suggested a national commission for tribunals-an-overarching body 3. Law commission in the past have suggested that qualification of the members should be that they should be eligible to be a judge of high Court 4. Stable rosters in High Court so as to promote specialisation
77
What are the issues with simultaneous elections. Give some wf Recently commitee formed under FR president ramnath kovind
1. Against federalism – extended , some shortened 2. No guarantee that there won’t be mid-term polls 3. Seven lakh polling stations –security forces 4. Big national parties only might end up winning state elections – more attention to national issues 5. Will have to face the electorate only once a year –reduced accountability 6. Illiterate – confusion for whom they are voting Wf 1. One year one election – as suggested by EC – should be the starting point 2. Constructive elections like in Germany 3. Side by side electoral reforms
78
A section under RPA to keep a check on criminalisation
1. Section 8 – disqualification from standing for elections 3. Section 123 – corrupt practises 4. Section 33A- details about cases where they have been accused of crimes punishable with greater than two years 5. Section 29C- Financing details 6. 61A evm 7. 58A - cancel on booth capturing 8. 77 — limits election exp 9. 126- ban on electronic media to display any election matter 48 hours 10. 126A—-exit polls Imprisonment upto 6 months for furnishing wrong details
79
Intro for basic structure doctrine
1. Form of JR put forward in KBC judgment through which court checks the legality of parliament amendments 2. Nanipalkhival - leg is the creature of constn and not it’s master 3. Some features of constn beyond amendment
80
Merits of anti defection
1. Govt stability and more focus on governance 2. Less election expenditure 3. Party discipline 4. People - voted for policies espoused by the political party 5. Realignment of party ( allows merger ) 6. First time constn recognition of political party
81
Demerits of anti defection law
1. Defection vs disagreement/ dissent 2. Breaking chain of accountability - electorate vs party diktats 4. Speaker - allegations of partiality 5. Finding loopholes - ex: using the Nebam Rebia ruling of 2016 - seeking removal of speaker when disqualification proceeding anticipated-> tying down hands of speaker 6. Irrational discrimination- encouraging wholesome defection Ex: recent Shivsena split of Maharashtra 7. National election study by Lokniti - in 2019 there was an increase in candidate based voting wrt 2014
82
Overall issues of functioning of parliament
1, representative quality - age ( 25 to 40 , 26 in 1st, 12 in 17th), gender (14% in 17th LS) 2. Avg sitting day - 130 in (1950s) to less than 70 3. Quality of legislation A. Bill referred to parliament committees - 14,15, 16– 60, 71, 25 B. Debates and discussions- case study - senator ted Cruz 21 hours, farm law repeal bill 8 min - 3, 5 C. Key piece of legislation via ordinance and money bill route 4. Productivity of budget sessions - time spend by LS in discussing union budget has been declining since 1990s ( prs) 5. Tax payers money - budget session 2018 washed out almost 200 crore based on loss of productivity 6. Freq disruptions 7. Reducing Mp to mere head count 8. criminalisation of politics
83
Wf for parliament
1. Venkaiah Naidu 15 point charter - consciousness- Gandhian - quorum - 50% member attendance - limit whip - quo of stability - mandated no of day of sitting - Odisha 100 day model 2. Pm question hour in uk every Wednesday for 2 hours 3. Pvt member bill 4. Keisham Meghachandra - speaker - tribunal to decide defection
84
Significance of DRSC
1. Better consensus building - televised vs close door - no anti defection law 2. Better quality of legislations - better discussion and experts Ex: data protection bill more than 80 redo of PSC 3. Enables member to build expertise in a particular area 4. Constn morality - govt accountability 5. Less judicial intervention
85
Key issues wrt DRSC
1. Reducing no of bills referred 2. New trend of joint committees rather than DRSC 3. Don’t always consult experts - ex: rte 2008 4. Standing research team. Gen support staff 5. Short duration of 1 year 6. Recommendations not binding
86
Wf for DRSC
MR MADHAVAN and PRATAP BANU MEHTA in “ rethinking public institutions” 1. USA model - mandatory referral 2. Inc term from 1 yr 3. Inc transparency - minutes of meeting 4. public consultation mandatory 5. Support - robust parliament library
87
Conclusion for DRSC
Lifeblood of parliament democracy - light of 71 day sitting and disruption
88
Need for judicial acc
1. Qlty judgement - Bombay HC - groping a child without skin to skin contact wouldn’t come under pocso 2. Impartial functioning- internal commitee formed to investigate sexual harassment allegations against CJI headed by himself 3. Applicability of RTI - Bombay HC - it’s file noting wrt administrative functions wouldn’t come under RTI 4. No legal obligation to prepare annual report - Odisha, tn, tripura 5. Pendency 6. K veeraswami vs UOI - no senior judge of SC could be subjected to criminal investigation without written permission of CJI. Very rare a judge ..
89
Types of ADR mechanisms in india
1. Arbitration and conciliation act 1996 2. Mediation - consumer protection act 3. Lok adalat- pre litigation 4. Plea bargaining under Crpc 5. Gram Nyayaly
90
Benefits of ADR
1, Indu Malhotra - the LAW AND PRACTICE OF ARBITRATION and conciliation- upholds 39A 2. Judicial rut - in 2023 NLA - 63 year old pending dispute in Hubballi civil court solved 3. Fast - data by law ministry in 2018 - more than 50 lakh case disposed of by these court on an avg in the last 3 yrs by these courts during national la 4. Cost effective 5. Hostility 6. Give views without fear of technicality 7. Soln based on opinion of both - practical, flexible, adaptable
91
Benefits of virtual court
1. Family and matrimony disputes 2. Schedule, reschedule, postpone- comfort of home 3. Documentary evidence 4. Easier to move to separate virtual room 5. Multiple locations, travel cost 6. No theatrics of public meeting
92
Issues with virtual courts
1. Open court principle of 145(3) 2. Tech savvy lawyers and support staff 3. Rural urban gap 4. Hacking of imp doc - psych evaluation 5. safety - Michigan —-> assault suspect in victims home 6. cross examination- delayed streaming, overemphasis on facial expression 7. other evidence apart from doc 8. Juhi Chawla case - web link on social media
93
Cooperative federalism
1. CF involves center and state cooperating with each other for overall devp of the nation 2. Participation of states in creation and implementation of national policies 3. In state of Raj vs uoi- SC quoted granville Austin wherein it was said " Indian fedration is an example of cooperative fedralism. India has created a strong central govt, it has not made the state govt weak" 4. Examples - a. Gst council ( 246A, 279A) b. Interstate council ( art 263 ) c. Niti ayog d. Ndma and sdma during covid e. 258, 258A-- mutual delegation of executive functions
94
Competitive federalism
1. Increased devolution by 14th, 15th FC 2. Performance based devolution mandate of FC - demographic performance and tax effort 3. Index - composite water mgmt index ( Niti ayog ) , swach Bharath ( mohua) , ease of doing business ( dpiit) 4. Certain states endeavouring for ease of doing business. Ex: Bhoomi portal of Karnataka, labor laws eased in rajasthan Recent Mohit minerals case - sc - Indian fedralism is a dialogue between cooperative and non cooperative fedralism
95
Relevance of RS
1. Legislative - pca, bonded labor , gram nyalay bill 2. Ananthasayanam Iyengar -hasty legislation and place for genius who couldn’t win popular mandate 3. Special power - 249, 312, 352 ( endorse emergency when no LS) 4. Deliberative chamber - qlty leg 5. Chamber of continuity 6. Scutinizing chamber - 8/12 DRSC
96
Issues with RS
1. Qlty of memebers - party fundraisers, journalist , lost election 2. Delaying chamber if oppn 3. Frequent disruptions - till 1997- 100%, 2015-19–> 61% productivity 4. Bypassing — money bill 5. RPA amendment act 2003, no domicile req 6. Sachin - 24 days 7. ADR 2020– 24% of RS has criminal cases 8. Independent and nominated members— less time to speak
97
Wf for RS
1. No of sitting NCRWC -100 days 2. Self disciple and participation 3. Able members UK model 4. Us senate model - 50*2 5. Tech adoption and infra sector
98
Issues with governor
1. Partisanship, no qualifications 2. Constn directives - governor of Jharkhand 3. Public spate - wb governor, Kerala 4. Gubernatorial procrastination 5. Going against advice of com - NABAM REBIA vs DEPUTY SPEAKER - called LA at an earlier date , unilateral editing of governor votebof thanks in TN 6. 356 Discretionary — art 163 1. Art 200 2. 356 3. Hung assembly 4. Lost the confidence ( Bommai case - floor test and not on subjective assessment of the governor )
99
Challenges in political arena wrt federalism
1. Interstate council - only 11 meetings since 1990.last in 2016 2. Governor 3. several Cm boycotted the 7th meeting of governing council of Niti ayog - center not treating them as equal partners 4. Executive- extension of bsf 5. Leg- farm law, entry 14 of center
100
Befits of panchayat systems
1, transparency and close to people 2. Resource and rep to deprived 3. Reduced urban bias 4. Accountability- speed, qty, Qlty 5, political partcipation - A anadavalli 6. Reduced absentism in pHc and govt schools 7. Jobs during Covid 8. Carbon neutral meenganadi
101
Challenges with panchayat hi raj system
1. Decentralisation of corruption - mani shankar Iyer 2. Fund - sfc, low equilibrium trap (es) 3. Panchayt pati- Damoh district in MP - husbands take oath 4. qualified support staff 5. devolution of functions in 11th schedule 6. Parallel Instn 7. elite capture 8. No adequate consultation with GS
102
Wf for panchayat
1. Activity mapping - mani Shankar 2. Kerala big bang- coc for civil, full devolution, panchayat ombudsman 3. Es 2018 - devolution should be linked to performance in tax collection 5. Sumit Bose - full time secy in gram panchayats
103
How panchayats will make money
1, T Raghunandan - RETHINKING PUBLIC INSTN IN INDIA - allocation, release , expenditure information network 2, rural bonds 3 . Common resource centres using MNREGA 4. Tourist vehicle fee, restaurants, cyber cafés
104
Wf for pesa
1, ngos and civil society 2. Role modelling - Draupadi Murmu 3, experts - Indian frontier administrative service 4. Samatha vs Andhra - land for land 5. National citizens panel
105
Intro for speaker and his roles
Art 93 Pt Jawahar - speaker is the symbol of nations freedom and liberty 1. Leader of ls, presides 2. Final interpreter of provisions 3. quorum 4. Money bill 5. Disqualification Xth schedule 6. Joint sitting 7. chair - general purpose committee, rules commitee
106
Issues with speaker
1. Impartiality- election anyway on party ticket 2. Criticism - money bill to bypass RS 3. Anti defection law wielded such that to favour ruling party Ex: Keisham meghachandra- Manipur defection case 4. No review of speakers decision, final 5. Increased disruptions - allegedly providing more time to ruling party
107
Wf for speaker
1. Resign from party - Neelam Sanjeeva reddy 2. Uk practice - give up party membership, commitee of 2 senior legislators to assist speaker 3. Keisham meghachandra case - court suggested permanent tribunal to decide on anti defection GV MAVLANKAR - once a speaker is elected he should raise above party and politics
108
Deputy speaker—- intro , importance
Along with speaker is the guardian of privileges. Symbol of parliamentary democracy 1. Maintains continuity - absent or vacant 2. Not a subordinate- speaker resignation to him 3. Strengthen oppn - convention
109
Deputy speaker not being appointed. Analyse
1. No time frame —- 93,178- “ as soon as possible “ 2. Rule 8 of procedure —- when the speaker fixes - constn experts — shall= mandatory - but treasury bench of parliament - no immediate requirement, bills are being passed and discussion held - several min - panel of chairpersons - courts cannot intervene - art 122(1)
110
Importance of pmo
1. conduit - diff ministries, public ( mann ki Ba’ath), grievance redressal ( cpgrams ) 2. Think tank - second opinion 3. Space , atomic energy 4. Complexity and scope of governance - need experts 5. Foreign relations - require expert panel 6. Faster decision making and implementation— removes policy paralysis
111
Importance of private members bill
1. Progressive leg - sasi taroor- anti discrimination 2. Raisin d’être of parliament- law making 3. Land mark leg - tiruchi n shiva pioneered the transgender bill 4. mps more than mere head count
112
Issues of private members bill and wf
1. Procedural impediments- cap on no. Of bills , discussion only on fridays 2. One month notice vs 7 day 3. Lesser chance of being approved 2. delay in discussion - naresh Gujral 2017,,2018 3. Research support Library, PRS LAMP fellowship
113
X vs NCT Delhi for MTP act
1. Even unmarried women - abortion upto 24 weeks 2. Marital rape 3. Transgender’s 4. If consensual - no need to report under posco 5. New forms of familial relationships
114
Legal- judicial problem of MTP act
1. Suchitra Srivastava- reproductive autonomy under art 21. Still RMP 2. Non exhaustive list of circumstances - 20-24 3. if medical board denies- go to court 4. Critics say its more about protecting practitioners
115
Problems with abortion
1. legal judicial 2. Health - gynaecologists in rural - nfhs 2019-21 data — more than a quarter of abortions done at hom 3. Society - taboo - sex selective 4. Ethics Pro life vs pro choice
116
Significance of data - keywords
1. Tech sector - creative disruption - data analytic 2. Economy - integrated markets - IR 4.0 3. Government - egovernance - informed policy making - better targeting - prevent frauds 4, individuals - informed choice - ease of living
117
Issues of data for individuals
1. Privacy and safeguards 2. BN Srikrishna - consent is broken in india 3. Cyber crime - bullying, stalking, doxxing
118
Issues of data wrt government
1. Fake news 2. Cyber crimes 3. it act vs it rules 4. Critical data - nuclear, cyber etc
119
Key words for data by big tech
Manipulation, monetisation, colonisation
120
Digital data protection bill 2022 — key provisions
1. CONSENT - purpose limitation - multiple languages - deemed consent 2. Data principal - post-mortem - withdraw consent - correction or erasure by fiduciaries - grievance redressal 3. Data fiduciary - acc and transparency measures - notify breach - data protection officer - more responsibilities for significant DF 4. Exemption - medical and legal - govt entities 5. Cross border data transfer 6. Data protection board of India
121
Issues of DDP bill
1. data - processed manually - lack of data portability rt to principal - sensitive personal data - ease of data localization 2. Government - Conflict of interest - 14/22 clauses - govt weak data security infra Ex: recent issue of confidential data of sbi employees made public in telegram 3. Independence of regulator 4. Clause 44(3) amends sec 8(1)(j) of rti to widen the scope of withholding personnel info - imbalance between transparency and privacy. Can lead to protection of corrupt 4. No criminal liability Ben Srikrishna - fundamentally flawed
122
Key words for differentiating 2019 and 2022 bill
1. Manual data 2. Non personnel data 3. Post-mortem consent 4. Data localization 5. Fin plus criminal
123
New rules regarding online game in IT rules
1. Govt will setup SRO. Will decide whether to allow 2. Gambling prohibited 3. age rating and parental consent 4. Banned or prohibited content 5. Identities of online gamers 6. Opt out after their own limits of time and money spent
124
Importance of gaming sector to India
1. ALL INDIA GAMING FEDRATION - 5 mn dollars by 2025 2. Sunrise industry 3. Youth 4. infra - 5g, mobile 5. 3 gaming unicorns - Dream Sports, Games24x7 and MPL.
125
Issue with online gaming
1. Socio- psychological - attention economy - addiction, mental health, incidence of violence 2. Regulatory grey area - not in any list 3. Blanket ban in certain states - kill + underground Ex. Kerala banned online rummy in 2021,,, hc lifted 4. Ethical - near miss phenomena - dopamine kicks — addiction 5. Money laundering 6. Data protection 7. Offshore gambling Betting, gaming apps Betway, Lotus365, Fun88 continue operations, ads despite blanket ban.
126
Wf for online gaming
1. Govt - online gaming authority in TN - China 3 hours a week limit - ban surrogate ad 2. Industry - robust grievance redressal 3. Consumer Aware
127
Effects of constitutionalisation- key words
1. Civil courts 2. Consolidated fund of india 3. Functional autonomy 4. security of tenure 5. Legitimacy in the eye of public 6. Reports submitted
128
Powers and functions of ECI
1. Political parties - registration - recognition - election symbols 2. Voter - electoral roll - awareness 3, election - date and schedule - results - model code of conduct 4, quasi judicial body -
129
Success of ECI
1, every single voter - Gir forest 2. EVM - booth capturing, vote counting 3. VVPAT 4. Mcc 5. Level playing field 6. Electronic transmitted postal ballot system - service voters 7. SVEEP , matdata junction 8. Special drives for homeless and sex workers in cities
130
Concerns and limitations of ECI
1. Constitutional limitations - qualification, appt process, - cec vs ec —- removal process ( TN SESHAN CASE —> cec = ec ) 2. Legal limitations - law to regulate appointment ( the election commn bill solves this issue ) - sec 29A— deregister - mcc - no legal backing 3. Executive control - appt, removal, short tenures - no separate secretariat - not charged on CFI - post retirement offers 4. Judicial interference ( NP PONNUSWAMI CASE - judiciary can’t ) SC stays ECI order revoking ‘star campaigner’ status of former MP CM Kamal Nath
131
Suggestions for ECI
1. Recent election commission bill - selection commitee- pm+ lop+ cabinet min, search commitee headed by cabinet secy , ec cannot be reappointed 2. 255th LC - permanent secretariat 3. Security from arbitrary removal of ec 4. CFI 5. Power to deregister pp
132
Sc judgement and rpa
1. Aidmk vs ECI - EVM constititutionally valid 2. ADR vs UOI - Compulsory declaration of assets, educational qualifications, criminal background 2. PUCL vs UOI - NOTA 3. Subramanian swamy - VVVPAT 4. Public interest foundation case - mandatory for pp to publish details regarding pending cc on candidate within 72 hrs of selection else coc 5. Abhiram Singh vs commachen- 123(3)— seeking votes in the name of caste, community etc — corrupt practices 6. Lilly Thomas 7. Jan chowkidari
133
Positives of remote voting
1. Political justice of preamble 2. Inclusive - 300/900 mn didn’t vote in the 2019 elections mainly due to accessibility issues 3. Awakened citizenry 4. disenfranchisement and invisibility of migrants - Kalgoth, Dumak villages in Uttarakhand 25% not able to vote because of migration 5. Voting apathy in urban areas - leaves
134
Challenges of remote voting
1. Tech 2. EVM tech 3. Mapping of migrants 4. Voter verification 5. What if they come directly after registering as RV
135
Wf for Remote voting
1, pilot projects of dynamic ballot voting unit 2. Etpb 3. Ec with iitm - blockchain
136
National party recog criteria
1. 2 % seats in Ls- 3 2. 6% of votes in 4 states 3. Sp in 4 states
137
Issues with RUPPS
1. Front to avail tax exemption — 219 rupps , 600 crores in 19-20 2. No financial discipline, political morality, public accountability 2300 didn’t submit contribution report in 19-20 3. Money laundering, round tripping 4. No transparency - rti 5. No political activitiy 6. Eci can’t deregister
138
Wf for rupps
1, eci power to deregister 2. Pp under rti 3. Srtingenet norms for PP registrations Indira Gandhi vs raj narain
139
Implications of freebies
1. Electoral democracy - against spirit of F and F elections - disadvantage to parties taking substantive issues - govt of the day resorting to competitive populism — no level playing field - money power 2. Fiscal - weakens fiscal situation - es 2016- loan waiver - exit of tax paying middle class - redirecting scarce - opportunity cost - domino effect — other states
140
Merits of freebies
1. Not corrupt practice - Subramanian Balaji 2. Food security 3. Social welfare - bikes to girls 4. Benefit Manufacturers of laptop , phones etc
141
Success of NC for women
1. Laws- Bhanwari Devi 2.suo motto notices - Moved against star , zee Delhi hc 3. Outdated customs in MAIMON BHASKARI CASE 4. Awareness 5. Review laws from time to time 6. Special studies and investigation Ex: special study on female women prisoners, disabilities and woman
142
Criticism for NCW
1. Toothless tiger - ex: Manipur sexual violence case— 100s of complaints, all they could do was ‘ forward ‘ to authorities 2. Victim blaming - Badun (up ) rape case victim choosing odd hours to go to temple 3. All parties so far NCW chairperson a party member 4. Favouring political bosses Ex: Nirbhaya gang rape case 5. Friction among memebers - member secy — ias officer 6. Issue of shadow pandemic 7. No constn status, less funding
143
Wf for ncw
1, file to field approach 2, advertise vacancies + selection committee— lop, civil society 3. Social audit by external agencies 4. Reducing power distance - awareness among rural women
144
Good things about NGT
1. Experts 2. Instrumental role in protecting forest, rts of tribal 3. Samit Mehta — polluters pay 4. SBA SANGARSH SAMITI - no fault liability 5. Supreme Court has clarified that NGT has suommotto powers - Vizag Lg plant gas leak
145
Success of NHRC
1. Opened to judicial and moral scrutiny — hussanaira khatoon, nhrc guideline to be strictly adhered 2. File to field - Mundka fire Delhi chief secy and its own team 3. compensation, media coverage 4. Extensive research - right and challenges in surrogates
146
Issues with NHRC
1. Manual scavenging, encounter killing, Manipur violence 2. Toothless tiger by its own former chairman - advisory 3. 1 yr time limit 4. Pvt , armed 5. Retirement home for pliable judges
147
Benefits of electoral bonds
1, clean money , formal banking sector 2. Anonymity - post poll intimidation 3. KYC verified 4. Tax adv 5. Political party can maintain a corpus - good instead of rich candidate 6. SC in ADR case — no scope for black money since it’s not tradeable
148
General issues with electoral funding
1. Commercialisation - consultancy, social media, celebrities 2. Criminalisation 3. Freebies and cash for vote 4. Inner party democracy - rich gets ticket 5. Corporatisation of media- paid news
149
Plus of rti
1. 3 fundamental shifts 2. Scams - common wealth 3. Predictability and openness- answer keys of iit 4. New offices Sarabjit Roy case - pvt PU companies Sc Aggarwal case - cji
150
Issues with RTI
1. Report card - satark Nagarik sangatan - < 45% recieved the info they sought 2. More than 3 lakh with 26 IC 3. Transparency international report - 25% IC posts vacant and only 5% women 3. > 70 rti activist murdered ( mkss) 5. Very few IC have option of e- filing of request 4. Sec 4 suo motto rare 5. Sec 8- widened under the new DPDP bill 6. No political party 7. Dilution of position of cic via RTI act 8. Frivolous rti trying to overwhelm the system
151
Issues with custodial torture
1. Art 21 , DPL, 2nd arc - brawn over brain 2. Demonstrative effect 3. Culture of impunity - 2001 and 18 ~ 1700 deaths. Only 26 convicted 4. Loophole in law - confessions not admissible but evidence obtained via torture 5. Innocent - Ryan public school case 6. Denting India’s intl image - Denmark Kim Davy extradition 7. Women and children - mathura rape case 8. Social acceptability of encounter killings
152
Issues with police in general
1. Colonial era law - police act 1861 2. Infrastructural - PSC 22- 600 not even telephone - forensic infra, reliance on oral 3. Institutional - vacancies — 155, 195, 222/ lakh - stress ( STATUS OF POLICING IN INDIA REPORT ) - lack of training — focus on discipline - women ( INDIA JUSTICE REPORT 2022- 24 years ) 4. Social - non citizen friendly ( LOKNITI CSDS SURVEY - less than 25%) 5. Functional - law - 66A - custodial torture - political stooges - new crime — cyber, organised
153
Broad heading for overcrowding of prisons-
1. Infrastructure and resource - staff, occupancy, Covid 2. Human rights - no distinction , torture , mental health 3. Legal - undertrials, legal aid 4. Systemic issues - reformative approach, security measures, corruption 5. Intl image - india unable to extradite Kim davey because denmark sights the issue of poor prison
154
Issues with csr
1. Bare minimum: If a company spends an amount over the minimum 2%, as stipulated, the excess amount is liable to be set off against spending in the succeeding three financial years 2. Geographical Bias: a recent report by Ashoka Universitynoted that since the majority of CSR companies are located in the states like Maharashtra, Karnataka - states like U.P and M.P are left out from availing benefits of CSR 3. Sectorial Bias: There is also a sectorial bias. An analysis of CSR spending (2014-18) reveals that while most CSR spending is on education (37%) and health and sanitation (29%), only 9% was spent on the environment. 4. Lack of Community Participation: This is due to a lack of awareness and interest in activities relating to CSR. No plan can be successful without community engagement. 5. Green washing, publicity stunt 6. Public companies are mostly in industries where customer perception of the company does not matter (ONGC, NDMC, NTPC, etc.) as much as it does for a private company and this has led to a degree of complacency in meeting the CSR spending target
155
Wf for csr
1. Centralized Platform: a national-level centralized platform should be created by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs where all States could list potential CSR projects. Companies can check this platform and assess as to where the CSR funds would be most impactful. 4. Recommendations by the high-level committee on CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY (2018): - Bringing CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY within the purview of the statutory financial audit with details of CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY expenditure included in the financial statement of a company
156
How NGOs is creating a a participatory democracy
1. Communication link - ASER REPORTS 2. Awareness about rts of people - WORK OF NIRMAN NGO - tribals of Odisha regarding FRA rights 3. Capacity building of people . Ex: KERALA SHASTRA SAHITYA PARISHAD - people’ science movt , Akanksha foundation providing legal aid ( instead of Nalsa) 4. Social evils - Sachi Saheli- bloody revolution 5. Broaden govt accountability- mkss rti 6. Crisis - American india foundation 3 pronged approach 7. Alternative models of service delivery - fair price shops by MKSS 8. Most vulnerable - helpage india ( cheaper old age home than pvt ) childLine
157
Cons of micro fin institutes
1. Volatile combination- profit+ no competition + Ill 2. Credit risk analysis 3. Collection agencies 4. Higher interest rates 5. Dominant caste 6. Women loan controlled by men
158
Issues with regulatory bodies
1. financial dependence on line ministry 2. Govt interfere with tenures, election of non experts 3. Non effective scrutiny by parliament Ex: 15th LS out of 11000 discussions only 9 pertained to an independent regulator 4. Information gap: not mandated to submit regular report to parliamentary committees 5. Overlapping domains - sebi and IRDAI on unit linked insurance scheme
159
Statutory functions of enforcement directorate
1. PMLA 2002 2. FEMA 1999 3. Fugitive economic offenders act 2018 4. Sponsoring agency under COFEPOSA—to deal with smuggling
160
Criticisms against ED
1. Misuse of PMLA to investigate ordinary crimes - attachment of assets of genuine victims 2. ECIR Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) - not given to accused 3. Several petitions across the country wrt blanket powers - searching, seizing, investigating and attaching assets 4. Conviction rate low- Data given by govt in 2022- only 23 convicted in ~ 5400 cases filed by ed under pmla 5. Allegation of Political biases 6. Government interference in tenure extension ( though it was upheld in Jaya Thakur case)
161
Fiscal federalism issues
1. GST 2. I5th FC 3. Cess and surcharge 4. CSS 5. National institute of public finance and policy study — neutralised by redn in grants 6. Mohit minerals case 7. states weak fiscal position — freebies, loan waiver 8. Abolition of planning commission - institutional vacuum
162
Way forward for fiscal federalism
1. NK Singh 3 principle - equivalence, decentralisation, subsidiarity 2. Sarkaria commn- no. Of centrally sponsored schemes to be kept to min 3. Punchi commn- union - state consultations on concurrent list schemes via ISC 4. Expert suggests to keep a 10% upper limit on total Cess and surcharge 5. Periodic review and sunset clause for cess
163
Nps vs ops
1. Defined benefit vs defined contribution 2. Govt employees vs all 3. Last drawn salary vs market risk 4. Financial burden 5. Opportunity cost vs development focused 6. Privileged few vs opposition by pressure groups
164
What are the issues with pressure groups
1. Representation of minority Ex: pro business 2. Lack of transparency - ex: how are they funding govt 3. Elite capture 4. Demands leading to resource allocation problem . Ex: Confedration of central govt employees asking for restoration of OPS
165
Intro for ubi
Universal , unconditional , regular , cash transfer for individuals Recco by es 2017
166
Merits of ubi
1. Accidents of life 2. Forced labor, poverty 3. Women - study by WORKFREE NGO 4. Rapid boom of technology—> breathing space to re skill 5. Ease of administration- no targeting issue 6. No exclusion inclusion error
167
Demerits or issues of UBI
1. Abhijit Banerjee randomised control trials 2. Moral hazard-laziness 3. Expend on alcohol 4. Gender disparity- men may exercise control 5. Not market risk proof like in-kind transfer 6. What amount? 7. Inflation 8. States fiscal capacity
168
Wf for UBI
1. Amartya Sen 2. Phase out non merit subsidies and phase wise pilot study of UBI 3. Sunset clause
169
Issues with collegium system
1. Transparency - no official procedure or written manual 2. No review regarding effectiveness of the process 3. Critics of the system argue - ‘ uncle judges phenomena ‘ - kith and kin - 230th law commission 4. No global equivalent 5. j. Chellameshwar ( dissenting opinion in NJAC judgement)— collegium decisions are opaque and inaccessible to public and history 6. After receiving report govt on avg 127 days while collegium takes 119 days to confirm the reco
170
Positives of collegium
1. Independence of judiciary, interference of executive 2. Govt main litigant J. Kehar ( feeling of gratitude towards govt impact independence of judiciary “) 3. System now improved - mix of seniority, merit and diversity ( gender and minority)being considered Ex: recommendation of Saurabh Kripal, which would make him first openly gay judge in India - the judgments of the judges are circulated among the members of the collegium, well in advance. – The Centre for Research & Planning of the court also prepares a compilation of relevant background material to assist the collegium. – There is also a Judgment Evaluation Committee which goes through the judicial work of the candidates with a fine-tooth comb. The judgments are graded with the very best receiving an “outstanding” grade.
171
How to further improve the collegium system
1. Revamp NJAC - NCRWC Recco - 3 judges including CJI, LAW min, nominee of president 2. At present 2 stakeholders— include bar and civil society 3. Us model - prez nominated candidate have to prove his worth in Us congress hearings 4. Uk model - judicial appt commitee — open to all interested candidates to apply Bangalore principles of judicial conduct 2002 which focuses on core virtues of judicial life should form the core
172
Gubernatorial procrastination
Intro - Telangana govt, neet bill of Tamil Nadu, Kerala university amendment bill 1. 3 primary issues with art 200 1. Absence of time limit 2. Discretion to reserve for president against express advice of COM 3. Claim that governor can kill any bill by withholding assent 2. When SC considered the petition filed by Telangana government 1. As mentioned in art 200, governor should return bill that they do not agree to “ as soon as possible “ 2. The expression “ as soon as possible “ contains significant constitutional content and must be borne in mind by constitutional authorities 3. In a previous case - Purushottam nambudiri case - though timeline for governor to give assent, gov must honour the will of the legislature and act in harmony with com 4, NCRWC - timeline of 6 months Constn silences shouldn’t give way for
173
IT amendment rules 2023 ( apart from gaming), concerns
1. Online intermediaries and ISP- reasonable efforts to not host content related to CG that’s identified “fake” by “ fact checking unit “ 2. If not will loose their safe Harbor protection Concerns 1. Fails to define fake news 2. May lead to inc in arbitration powers of govt 3. Shreya Singhal case —- law that limits speech can neither be vague, nor overboard
174
Rationale of these IT rules
1. Regulating mis info Ex. Attack on migrant workers in TN 2. Improved accountability of social media intermediaries 3. Rising users -IAMAI 900 million internet users by 2025 — larger user base ~ more vulnerabilities 4. Security- recently Washington post exposed khalistani elements using bots to conduct misinfo operations against GOI 5. Intl commitment- 2022 g20 Bali declaration— noted the need to counter disinfo campaigns to promote cyber security
175
Provisions of POSHW act
Based on vishaka judgement guidelines and intl conventions like CEDAW 1. Acts - unwelcomed sexual advances, requesting sexual favours, making sexually coloured remarks, showing pornographers etc 2. Legal obligation on employer to PSHW 3. Formation of ICC if 10 or more employees 4. Local complaints commitee to handle those that don’t belong to above 4. ICC will have power of civil courts to gather evidence 5. Employers to take awareness prog 6. Penalties for non complaince with the act
176
What are the issues in the implementation of POSHW in the light of recent SC judgement
1. There were serious lapses and uncertainties in the implementation of the PoSH Act Ex: no ICC in wrestling fedration of india 2. Even if there is ICC - lack of stipulated no of members or lack of external member 3. Lack of awareness as to who to approach 4. Lack of confidence in the process and the outcome 5. Fear - job loss, alienation by colleagues
177
Wf for Poshw
1. Awareness campaigns in local language 2. Concerned organisations to publish info regard icc in their website 3. Awareness generation camps by Nalsa,slsa, statutory bodies for professionals etc 4. National and state judicial academy —- capacity building of members of ic As Supreme Court noted This social malady needs urgent amelioration through robust and efficient implementation of the Act.
178
Ambiguities wrt sec 8 of rpa
1. 103- president to decide on disqualification. But sec 8 not clear 2. Sec 11 - ec has power to remove / reduce disq. Led to opposition accusing bias 3. Date of the beginning of disq- Ex: Rahul Gandhi- 14, Azam khan- day of his conviction 4. If stayed or reversed - effect retrospective or prospective 5. If s/r - procedure for induction
179
Positives of basic structure
1. Differentiated between amending and rewriting 2. Implementation of constitutionalism 3. Extremely careful in using Ex: janhit abhiyan case - reservation on economic criteria do not violate basic structure 4. So far used this doctrine only in 6 cases to declare a law ultravires
180
Wf for fra 2006
1. Nc Saxena commitee - increase tribal representation in FRC 2. Skill training and employment opportunities for tribals Ex: Dediapada, Gujrat , forest authorities allowed tribals to collect bamboo flowers and arranged its sale with JK paper mills 3. Role of ngo- awareness generation 4. Periyar conservation model