Constitution Flashcards
Functions of finance commission
- Distribution of net proceeds
- Principle govern grant in aid
- Measures to augment consolidated fund of state to supplement resource of panchayat, mucipalities
- Any other matter
Indian vs western secularism
- Seperate vs principled distance
- Non interferenec vs positive (haj, kumbhamela), secular
- Uniform law vs seperate personal laws
- No aid vs religious endowment act
- Primacy to individual liberty vs coupled with community rights
Limitations of the basic structure approach? Wf? Conclusion
- Textual legitimacy leading to elastic nature of basic structure
- Tyranny of unelected - njac 99th- 2/3 + 20
- Whims of judges - precendents
- Against separation of power which in itself is a basic structure
- not immune- defeated within 2 years
VP - severe compromise of parliament sovereignty and mandate of people
Wf- constitutional bench , amend 368, Australia- referendum conducted for major amendment
Fresh breath of air to politico legal jurisprudence
Articles related to anti defection
- 1985-52nd aa, xnth schedule
- 102 - disqualified
- 191- la, lc
Recommemdations wrt anti defection
- Dinesh goswami committee - only in case of no confidence motion against party whip
- Halim - certain restrictions- not allowed to join other political party
- Manipur defection case - permanent tribunal
PAC origin
Montagu chelmsford reform
Give some limitations of pac
- PRS data - fewer reports per year since 1980
** since 2019 only 15 reports ** - Consensus - vaccine production and distribution couldn’t be adopted as one of the agenda
- Politicisation
Ex: 2017 pac chairman criticised for calling PM to explain demonetisation - Post mortem - excess grants
- Advisory - parl final decision
- Officers dodging summons
- No technical expertise, dependence on CAG- difficult to function in case of CAG oversight
Functions of drsc
Demand for grants before voting, bills, annual report, national basic long term policy
Key points for misuse of Parliamentary privileges
- 2017 karnataka speaker 2 journalists for a year
- 2019- Maharashtra speaker ordered action of arrest against a man for creating parody video of a speech made by mla
- Judge and plaintiffs
- Rti, rtk under 19(1)
- Social contract- instrument to uphold citizen welfare not gag genuine
Keshav Singh case- privileges subject to FR
Current provisions to maintain judicial accountability
- 124(4) , Judges inquiry act
- Charter called ‘ restatement of judicial values’ in 1997- guidelines for general behaviour of judges
- 235 - HC control over subordinate courts
- Sc aggarwal case - cji public authority under RTI
- System of appeal, review
- Collegium- send back, but if reiterated
Way forward to ensure judicial accountability
- Judicial standards and accountability bil- 2010 - assets, standards of conduct, minor disciplinary
- 2nd arc senior judge of SC- JUDICIAL VALUE COMMISSIONER
- Denmark and Sweden - spl institutions
Sp Gupta vs UOI - court accountable to the public for the decision it takes on behalf of public
Define ODR
It’s an ADR ( ANM) for small and medium value cases using digital tech
Cabinet committee introduction
GOI TRANSACTION OF BUSINESS RULES 1961 - Emerging out of 77(3) - dispose off his dept- if concerns other- concurrence under the authority of cabinet
Difference between cabinet committee vs parl committee
- Members- ministers vs mp
- Pm vs prstv
- Changes vs 1 year
- Chairman- pm vs speaker selects
Wf to solve iswd
- Interstate council
- CW mgmt authority - mihir shah
- Track 2 paradiplomacy - Cauvery water family -f2f
- Supply side to demand side management
- Frances system of water parliament ( advisory and leadership role within river basin) - seats reserved for NGO and environmental specialist
Some recommendations of sarkaria commision wrt FEDRALISM
- President if withholding state bill—–> give reasons
- Concurrent list - consult state
- Consult CM before appointment of governor
Difference between niti ayog and pc
- Competitive+ cooperative vs dictated fedralism
- Top down
- Instant monitoring - development and monitoring agency vs post mortem
- action, strategy, vision- 3,7,15
- Market economy vs socialism
Why ULB less revenue
- Populism- free water , free electricity
- Cag report - lacunae in acc keeping
- Sfc
**ONLY 9 states have constituted 6th sfc out of which only 2 are active ** - Poor quality services , citizens unwilling to pay
- Urban sprawl - jurisdiction
- Tools like municipal bonds
Wf for boosting ulb bodies
- property tax - satellite based monitoring and formalising cadastral maps
**ES 2017- Bangalore, Jaipur are collecting 5-20% of their potential property tax - Credit rating system so as to explore bond market
- Betterment levy, unlock land value
- Need to balance their budgets by law ( similar to frbm)
Introduction of PMO
Is a staff agency to assist PM in efficient discharge of his role. Status of dept under allocation of businees rules 1961
Issues of the office of CAG
- Delay- demonetisation, rafale deal
- Rbi, fci, lic
- Secret services
- Presumptive loss highlighted by cag
- Redactive pricing audit
- Formal apology of vinod rai in 2g spectrum case
- Since 1996 only one iaas
- Sc judgements
- V subramian Balaji vs tn - duty of CAG arises only after expenses have occurred
- Suleman Rahamat khan vs state — CAG cannot question policy objectives of govt
Removal of upsc
Insolvent, paid employment outside, infirmity of mind
Criticism of 15th fc
- All South except tn
- Post devolution revenue deficit grant - disincentivising financial prudence
Es 2017 - states heavy dependency on aid
- aid curse - no effort to develop public infra
- citizen not able to hold state accountable- as state not depended on their tax
- Local bodies tied grants
- TOR included monitoring performance of power reforms, tax reforms- against constitutional role.
- Sector specific grants, performance based grants — increasing central govt interference
- Cess and surcharge,
NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC FINANCE AND POLICY STUDY - increase to 42% by 14th Fc neutralised by redn of other grants by center
Issues with national commission for protection of child rights,, nice
- 2020-21– 16% increase in crime against children
- One third of child brides in india ( unicef)
- Allegations of turning blind eye towards police brutality of children during caa protests
- Indifferent - online trafficking, child porno
- No condom ad (6-10), bombay begum
- During pandemic - child labor, abuse etc increased manifold
Nice
1. Jj act, pocso— instrumental
2. Bal swaraj, samwedhna, corporal punishment
3, audits in CCI - muzzafarpur shelter home
4. Rehabilitation of children in conflict with law -
5. Quick response cell to stop instances of child marraige