Consent

Question 1

P1

Answer 1

Nanny state vs freedom of bodily autonomy

Question 2

P2

Answer 2

Euthanasia

Question 3

3

Answer 3

Unclear — Range of rest

Question 4

4

Answer 4

Sport and horse play

Question 5

What is nanny state

Answer 5

Gov interference with personal choice

Question 6

How is there nanny state

Answer 6

R V BM - socially acceptable only for extreme body modification

Who’s socially acceptable? Judges composition

R V brown - homophobic and cannot consent to s*xaul gratification if gay but can in R b Wilson husband to wife

Question 7

Euthanisa judges stance

Answer 7

Dr cox
Euthanised terminally I’ll
Only given suspended sentence when max was life

Question 8

Euthanasia current stance

Answer 8

Prima facie illegal
DPP V pretty cannot consent to own death
R V slingsby cannot consent to murder

Question 9

Euthanasia economic

Answer 9

Tony bland
250,000 5 days

NHS cost

Question 10

Euthanisa parliament and public

Answer 10

Baroness mevher bill got to House of Commons before covid

Switzerland Canada have it

Public support in media after DPP V pretty

Question 11

However Euthanisa

Answer 11

Moral and religion
Christianity that life is gift from god

Slippery slope - used by those no intended for
Devaluation oh human life

Question 12

Unclear tests medical

Answer 12

Gillock competence - asses child’s competence to give consent

Yet Keira bell is now during nhs due to be able to consent at 16 to gender transform

Question 13

Range of test fraud

Answer 13

R V dica can’t be via fraud
R V tabbsum - consent to nature and quality to act without deception

• time consuming for court

Question 14

Test for capacity

Answer 14

Age sober authority

Burrell V hammer - strict liability - unfair in D

Question 15

Sport and horseplay
Sport

Answer 15

Issue with R V barns and R V billinghirst

Question 16

R V barns issue

Answer 16

Injury caused by foul not in rules of fame is not consented tooo

Doesn’t balance need of individual as foil can be commited reckless

Question 17

Billinghurst issue

Answer 17

Hard to draw line
High test= high injury And can happen on half time or end of game

Unclear when consent will and will not apply

Question 18

Horseplay

Answer 18

R V aitken - V does not need to consent D just needs to believe consent

R V Jones - no intend needed however

Question 19

Drunken horseplay

Answer 19

R V richard and irwin

Drunk mistaken intent is allowed

Question 20

Reforms

Answer 20

Law commission 1995 not listened too

Euthanisa bill be passed
Reform to make democracy