CON LAW Flashcards
Who can regulate interstate commerce?
CONGRESS HAS THE POWER & STATES MAY REGULATE IN ABSENCE OF CONGRESSIONAL REGULATION
HOW DO YOU DETERMINE IF STATE LAW IS CONSTITUTINAL UNDER REGULATION OF INTERSTATE COMMERCE?
DISCRIMINATORY?
NONDISCRIMINATORY?
Discriminatory = Usually unconstiutional & strict scrutiny
NONDISCRIMINATORY (SOME BURDEN ON IN STATE AND OUT OF STATE) - usually likely to be upheld and
MARKET PARTICIPANT DOCTRINE
state is acting as a market participant or business rather than regulator = allowed to favor own residents
What is required to sue under the 1st, 14th or 15th Amendment?
STATE ACTION
Example of Private Action being State Action?
private actor performing traiditional and exclusive government function or closley controlled by the state
EQUAL PROTECTION CLAUSE THREE STANDARDS
- STRICT SCRUTINY - narrowly tailored (necessary) to achieve a compelling interest (racial, alieange)
- INTERMEDIATE SCRUTINY - substantially related to important government interest (gender)
- RATIONAL BASIS - PLAINTIFF must prove not rationally related to a legitimate government interest (ALL OTHER poverty, wealth, age, education etc.)
FREEDOM OF SPEECH
government regulation of private speech
CONTENT-BASED DISCRIMINATION
forbids communication about certain ideas or viewpoint based
strict scrutiny
SYMBOLIC SPEECH
constitutional if it is narrowly trailored to an important government interest and is unrelated to supression of speech
UNPROTECTED SPEECH
RATIONAL BASIS
* speech inciting immediate or lawless or violence behavior (“clear and present danger”)
* fighting words
* true threat or words as conduct
* obscene speech (patently offensive, lacks serious literary, artistic or political value)
LESS-PROTECTED SPEECH
COMMERCIAL SPEECH
SEXUAL OR INDECENT SPEECH
TIME-PLACE-MANNER RESTRICTION
COMMERCIAL SPEECH
- speech must not be lawful and misleading
- substantial government interest
- directly advance interest
- narrowly tailored
sexual or indecent speech
law must serve a substantial government interest and leave alternative channels of communication
Time-Place-Manner Restriction
PUBLIC?
NON PUBLIC?
PUBLIC (streets, sidewalks, parks) or a DESIGNATED PUBLIC FORUM (school open after hours) MUST BE CONTENT NEUTRAL, narrowly tailored to serve a gov interest and leave alternative channels of commmunication
NONPUBLIC? (airports, government workplace) VIEWPOINT NEUTRAL & reasonably related to legit interest
Presumption againt Prior Restraint
stop speech before it happens