Community Water Fluoridation Flashcards
How does fluoride prevent caries?
- Fluoride present in fluid at the plaque/tooth interface promotes remineralisation
- The Fluoro-Apatite formed is less susceptible to demineralisation
- Topical effect greater than systemic effect
- Fluoride may also have an effect on bacteria and metabolic pathways resulting in less acid being produced
- Maintain elevated oral levels of fluoride for as long as possible (little and often)
What lesions is fluoride most effective on?
- Early lesions
What are the two broad types of Oral reservoirs?
Mineral deposits (CaF2; FAP)
- CaF2 in saliva and fluid phase of plaque
Biologically/bacterially bound calcium-fluoride
What is community water fluoridation?
- Adjustment of natural fluoride content of community water supply to achieve optimum caries prevention whilst minimising risk of dental fluorosis
What are the constituents added to community water fluoride?
- Hydrofluorosilicic acid or hexafluosilicic acid H2SiF6
- Sodium fluorosilicate or sodium silicofluoride, Na2SiF6
- Typically 0.5 – 1.2ppm, dependent on climate (related to ambient air temperature; latitude)
What act stipulates the community water fluoridation?
- Section 87C (2) of the Water Act 2003
- Code of practice from the Drinking water inspectorate
What is the fluoride Content of Scottish water?
- Water Supplier Scottish water
- Glasgow Dental School supplied by Milngavie M3 treatment works
- Mean = 0.10mgF/l (<0.04 - 0.12) natural water fluoride content
What is the UK legislation in regard to water fluoride?
- Water Fluoridation Act (1985)
- Water Industry Act (1991)
(Neither Act delivered change) - Water Act 2003, Section 58 (Fluoridation of Water supplies) Applies in England & Wales
‘may’ vs. ‘shall’
What is the Water Act 2003?
- Replaced flawed legislation - Water (Fluoridation) Act 1985 / Water Industry Act 1991)
- May replaced with shall
- Requirement for public consultation before new scheme implemented
- Statutory requirement for ‘authority’ o monitor heath effects of fluoridation (section 90A)
What is the current Legislation on water fluoridation in Scotland?
- level of fluoride in the water varies from 0.001 ppm to 1ppm. Water fluoridation is adjusting this natural fluoride concentration to 1ppm.
- Water (Fluoridation) Act 1985 (now consolidated into the 1991 Water Industry Act) still extant
What are some barriers to Water fluoridation?
- Objections/acceptability (Moral/ethical) (Safety & efficacy)
- Political barriers
- Geographical barriers
- Financial barriers
What are the ethical/ moral considerations of water fluoridation?
- Need to take into account Human civil rights
- Beneficial and has no harmful consequences
- Not infringe any basic human right (choice to drink it)
- Replicates a situation naturally
- Question of is it unethical to fluoridate where practical to do so?
What are some safety/ efficacy considerations to water fluoridation?
- The chemical used are industrial waste products
- Fertilizer production - hydrogen fluoride reacts with silica to produce hexafluorosilicic acid
- Concerns fluoride and fluoride components are toxic ( link to cancers/ bone disorders/ cognitive impairment?)
- Acute toxicity
- Cumulative posion
- Fluorosis
When is fluorosis a concern?
- Not a concern with community water fluoridation in addition to fluoride toothpaste
- There is a dose response with fluorosis
- Higher levels of fluoride worldwide with some areas 5.5-25ppmF is a concern
- Concern when effects aesthetic/severity and skeletal
What is the Clinical presentation of Fluorosis?
- Snow flaking appearance on teeth
- Lack clear border, opaque, white spots, narrow white lines on enamel surface of most of the teeth
What are some efficacy concerns around water fluoridation?
- Does it work in preventing caries?
- Is there a declining effect of fluoridation
- Can we get other sources of fluoride
- How do we control for confounding factors like social class and population migration
What are some political barriers of water fluoridation?
- Anti-fluoridation lobby very vocal
- Highly emotive topic
- Differing opinions across political parties
- How to tackle increasing level of disease, rising health inequalities, financial and workforce challenges