Coasts EQ4 Flashcards

1
Q

What’s the location description of Bangladesh (Meghna Estuary)?

What are the human influences on Bangladesh?

What are the physical influences on Bangladesh?

What were the short/long-term impacts of flooding?

A

Located at the mouth of the river Meghna to the east of the bay of Bengal in Bangladesh.

Population pressure of over 1000 people per square km. Mangroves have had to be deforested in order to keep up with population pressures. Increased surface runoff.

Tropical cyclones are seeded by warm tropical oceans of the Indian ocean. Low pressure draws heat from oceans.

  • 138,000 died
  • 10 million homeless
  • Soil erosion
  • Food scarcity
  • Land/ water pollution
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What is the flooding taking place in the North Sea in 1953 and 2013?

A

January 1953, a nighttime storm surge caused the death of 307 people in England and over 2100 people in the Netherlands.

  • The sea level rose by 5.6 m as the storm coincided with extreme tides.
  • Flooding occurred on the east coast of England, with almost 65,000 ha of farmland and 20,000 homes flooded.
  • There were no flood warning systems, weather forecast for basic and communications limited.
  • In December 2013 the largest storm since 1953 took place. The surge reached 6.3m in places, for example, Blakeney, North Norfolk. 18,000 people evacuated, but only 14,000 properties are flooded with no deaths.
  • The major impact of avoided due to the Thames barrier, better sea defences and better forecasting.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What are the consequences of flooding in Australia?

What are the consequences of flooding in the Philippines?

A
  • Low-lying bays tripled in the last century.
  • Bondi may lose 20-40m.
  • $226bn coastal assets at risk.
  • 80% of coastline at risk.
  • Fisheries affected.
  • Relocation of homes.
    Loss of:
  • 116,000 homes causing property damage of US $72 billion;
  • $87 billion worth of commercial property threatened
  • $67 billion road and rail infrastructure.
  • 5 power stations,
  • 258 emergency service stations,
  • 75 hospitals and
  • 44 water and sewage plants.
  • Social costs would include the break up of communities, loss of livelihood, e.g. fishing, tourism, and amenity loss (?)
  • Coral reefs forming the Great Barrier Reef will die if they are unable to grow fast enough to keep up with sea level rise, leading to a loss in tourism income.
  • 2000 live on Manila bay.
  • IPCC estimates a rise of 60 cm - 1 m by 2100 in the Philippines
  • Losses of $6.5bn a year.
  • 130 fishermen earn about $12 a week.
  • Natural mangroves, coral damaged.
  • Welfare loss of $168,000 a year.
  • Much of the threatened area is poor shanty towns, e.g. Cavite City and Las Piñas in Manila, with low property value.
  • A 1 m rise would affect 2.3 million people, and 62% of Manila in the south of Luzon Island.
  • Loss of livelihood - fishing, tourism
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What is happening in Kiribati?

What are the effects on Kiribati?

What is next for Kiribati?

A

Situated in the middle of the Pacific Ocean and is composed of 33 islands. These islands are low-lying sand and mangrove atolls that are only 1m or less above sea level. Many of the islands can disappear under the sea in the next 50 years. Sea levels are rising by 1.2 cm taller.

Rising sea levels are contaminating its groundwater sources. Climate changes cause bleaching of the coral reefs. Homes and businesses are particularly damaged during the King tides. There has been an increase in beach erosion and flooding. Food sources are becoming increasingly insecure.

The Kiribati government has purchased the land in Fiji for farming agriculture and fish farming. Its people could become environmental refugees. Under a scheme supported by the government, known as the migration with dignity policy, people have decided to relocate for better job opportunities in New Zealand and Fiji.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What are hard engineering techniques?

A

Man made structures to prevent coastal flooding.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What are sea walls as well as pros and cons?

A

Stone or concrete walls at the foot of the cliff or at the top of the beach. They’re usually curved to reflect the waves back.

+ Very effective.
+ Creates a promenade to walk along
- Unattractive and expensive.
- If theres a gap erosion can occur.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What are rip rap as well as pros and cons?

A

Large rocks at the foot of the cliff, or at the top of the beach. Breaks up wave energy, allowing water to pass through.

+ Relatively cheap.
+ Energy is taken out.
- Unaesthetic to look at.
- Dangerous if people climb on them.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What are groynes as well as pros and cons?

A

Set at right angles to the coast to slow down longshore drift. They make the beach wider and higher.

+ Maintains the size of the beach.
+ Enhances the beach.
- Unattractive.
- Expensive, £1000 per metre

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What are revetments as well as pros and cons?

A

Sloped walls placed parallel and in front of the backshore. They take the force of breaking waves.

+ Absorbs wave energy.
+ Longshore drift can still occur.
- Costs £1500 per linear metre.
- Consistent maintenance.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is offshore breakwater as well as pros and cons?

A

Boulders dropped in shallow nearshore waters and aligned parallel to the shore waters. They absorb wave energy and dissipate waves.

+ Creates sheltered areas.
+ Protects vulnerable areas.
- Costs £1/2 million.
- Other defences are needed.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What are soft engineering techniques?

A

The natural environment is used to help reduce coastal erosion and river flooding.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What is beach nourishment as well as pros and cons?

A

Replaces beach sediments eroded or transported by long shore drift.

+ Uses natural sediments.
+ Supports the tourist industry.
- Costs £10 per m^3.
- May have to be replaced.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is cliff regrading as well as pros and cons?

A

Part of the cliff has been taken away in order for the angle of the cliff to be reduced.

+ Creates a natural slope.
+ Should remain stable.
- Land/ property lost.
- Costs about £1 million.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What is dune stabilisation as well as pros and cons?

A

Dunes provide a natural barrier to sea level and storm waves.

+ Looks natural and effective.
+ Provides a natural ecosystem.
- Short term.
- May need to be fenced off.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What is managed retreat as well as pros and cons?

A

Areas set out to be flooded and kept protected.

+ Allows for natural processes.
+ Extends current ecosystems.
- No compensation.
- Doesn’t prevent land being lost.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What are three adaptation strategies in managing future coastal threats?

A
  • Restoring mangroves: These are effective against storm surges, boost fish numbers, and benefit local communities.
  • Zoning areas of the coast: Threatened by sea level rise to protect further development there. This avoids increasing risk.
  • Elevating critical infrastructure: For example power stations to protect them from flooding.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What factors affect the choice of coastal management?

A
  • Erosion rates
  • Settlements
  • Resources available
  • Levels of development
  • Value of land
  • Types of processes
18
Q

What are stakeholders?

A

An individual or group of people who have an interest in the outcome of decisions made to change areas.

19
Q

What are winners and losers?

A

People who gain from a decision.

People who are likely to lose property, their business or job.

20
Q

What is taking place at Holderness to support erosion?

A
  • Bridlington is protected by a 4.7 km long sea wall.
  • Hornsea is protected by a sea wall, groynes and rock armour.
  • Coastal management at Withersea has tried to make the beach wider by using groynes and also uses a seawall to protect the coast.
  • Mappleton is protected by rock groynes.
  • Spurn Head is protected with groynes and rock armour.
  • Building and maintaining the defences is expensive and not feasible for some places along the coast.
  • No money is given for the loss of land even though it costs the owner roughly £5000-£5500 a year per acre.
  • Withernsea, Hornsea and Bridlington have seen sea defences built because the cost-benefit analysis has shown that it is worth protecting for the value of the assets on the coast there.
  • The sea defences cost £1.9 million in 1991 using 60,000 tonnes of granite and 2 large groynes
21
Q

What are the conflicts at the coast of Holderness?

A
  • There has been an increase in erosion at Great Cowden because of the groynes used in Mappleton. This has led to farms being destroyed by erosion and the loss of 100 chalets at the Golden Sands Holiday Park.
  • Some people disagree with where the sea defences are located, especially if it means the land in their community is not protected.
  • Some sea defences negatively impact tourism and reduce the amount of money coming into the area.
22
Q

What are the three consequences of coastal recession for communities?

A
  • Social: Impacts on people due to various emotional and financial stress.
  • Economic: Cost to businesses, property and jobs.
  • Environmental: Damage to ecosystems and coastal landscape.
23
Q

What are policy decisions?

A

Policy decisions (No Active Intervention, Strategic Realignment and Hold the Line Advance the Line) are based on complex judgements (engineering feasibility, environmental sensibility, land value and political and social reasons.). Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) and Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) are used as part of the decision-making process.

24
Q

What is EIA?

A

An EIA of any proposed coastal defence project should determine the potential impacts on the environment of each aspect of the project, including location and management. Careful scoping facilitates this process.

  • Coastal management usually requires an EIA to be carried out. This is quite separate from any CBA, although might inform the final CBA. EIA is a process that aims to identify:
  • The short-term impacts of construction on the coastal environment
  • The long-term impacts of building new sea defences or changing a policy from hold the line to no active intervention or managed realignment

EIA is wide-ranging and includes assessments of:
- Impacts on water movement (hydrology) and sediment flow, which can affect marine ecosystems because of changes in sediment load.
- Impacts on water quality, which can affect sensitive marine species.
- Possible changes to flora and fauna, including marine plants, fish, shellfish and marine mammals.
- Wider environmental impacts such as air quality and noise pollution, mainly during construction.

25
Q

What is holistic coastal management?

A

Coastal communities around the world face increasing threats from the sea such as rising sea levels and frequent storms. To cope with the start, communities need to adapt and employ sustainable coastal management. An example is the ICZM.

26
Q

Who is the decision maker for coastlines in the UK?

A

The DEFRA have four policies available for coastal management. These vary differently in terms of their costs and consequences.

27
Q

Making decisions about which policy to apply to a particular location is complex. It depends upon:

A
  • The economic value of the assets that could be protected, e.g. land.
  • The technical feasibility of engineering solutions: it may not be possible to ‘hold the line’ for mobile depositional features such as spits, or very unstable cliffs.
  • The cultural and ecological value of land: it may be desirable to protect historic sites and areas of unusual diversity.
  • Pressure from communities: vocal local political campaigning to get an area protected.
  • The social value of communities that have existed for centuries.
28
Q

What are shoreline management plan decisions?

A

Coastal engineers follow strict Criteria before deciding on a strategy. Each coastal strategy needs to be socially, economically and environmentally appropriate for that specific stretch of coastline, normally within a sediment cell.

29
Q

What are the 2 ways in which SMP can make their decisions?

A
  • Cost-benefit analysis: This compares the cost of coastal defences with the value of the land to be protected.
  • Environmental impact assessment (EIA): This aims to identify the environmental positives and negatives of development before it’s implemented.
30
Q

What are the three main ways for managing coastline sustainability?

A
  • ICZM: National and sometimes international scale policy for a large stretch of coastline.
  • Shoreline management plan: Regional scale management for a specific stretch of the coast. Normally within a sediment cell.
  • Management unit: local scale management for a small stretch of the coast within a sediment cell.
31
Q

What is ICZM?

A

Process for the management of the coast using an integrated approach, regarding all aspects of the coastal zone.

32
Q

What is advance the line?

A

Building new defences closer to the sea.

33
Q

What is hold the line?

A

Maintain existing in the building of new defences.

34
Q

What is managed retreat?

A

Allowing coastal processes to take over gradually.

35
Q

What is no active intervention?

A

No active intervention or monitoring of the coastline.

36
Q

Why might adopting sustainable coastal management might lead to conflict?

A
  • Coastal natural resources may have to be used less in order to protect them - so some people lose income.
  • Relocation may be needed where engineering solutions are too costly or not technically feasible.
  • Some erosion and/or flooding will always occur, as engineering schemes cannot protect against all threats.
  • Future trends, such as rising sea levels, may create uncertainty and the need to change plans.
37
Q

What is sustainable coastal management?

A
  • Managing natural resources (fish, farmland, water supply) to ensure long-term productivity.
  • Managing flood and erosion risk where possible, or relocating to safe areas.
  • Creating alternative livelihoods before existing ones are lost to the sea.
  • Adapting to sea level rise by relocating, alternative building methods and water supplies .
  • Educating communities to understand why change is needed and how to adapt.
  • Monitoring coastal change and adapting to unexpected trends.
38
Q

What is the definition of sustainable management?

A

Sustainable management is designed to cope with future threats (increased storm events, rising sea levels) but its implementation can lead to local conflicts in many countries.

39
Q

What is the evaluation for SMP coastal defences?

A
  • Appropriate for the physical processes in operation in the cell.
  • Environmentally acceptable.
  • Feasible to build. Economically (cost-benefit analysis), socially and politically viable.
  • Sustainable in the long term.
40
Q

What is the cost-benefit analysis?

A

Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is used to help decide if defending a coastline from erosion and/or flooding is economically justifiable.

  • An example is Happisburgh in North Norfolk:
    The policy adapted in this area is ‘no active intervention’
    This is because to defend the village would have an impact on the wider coastal management plan.
    Happisburgh would end up as a promontory, blocking longshore drift and causing further erosion downdrift.
    Longer term, the plan is managed realignment, although this would still involve property being lost to the sea by erosion.
  • Costs of erosion:
    £160,000 could be available to Manor Caravan Park to assist in relocating to a new site
    Affected residents could get up to £2000 each (a total costs of £40-70,000) in relocation expenses plus the cost to the council of finding plots of land on which to build new houses.
    Grade 1 listed St Mary’s Church and Grade 2 listed Manor House would be lost.
    Social costs as the village is slowly degraded, including health effects and loss of jobs.
  • Benefits of erosion:
    By 2105, between 20 and 35 houses would be ‘saved’ from erosion, with a combined value of £4 million - 7 million
    45 hectares of farmland would be saved, with a value of £945,000
    The Manor Caravan Park would be saved, which employs local people.

The cost of building coastal defences at Happisburgh is around £6 million, very close to the value of property that could be saved, and much higher than the compensation cost payable to local residents.
Coastal managers argue that Happisburgh must be seen in the wider context of the whole SMP, further justifying the decision not to defend the village.

41
Q

What is taking place at Happisburgh?

A

This is an example of policy decisions leading to conflict in a developed country:

  • The SMP policy decision in Happisburgh is no active intervention.
  • This was against the wishes of local residents, especially those on Beach Road where several houses have been lost.
  • House values are very low, which has meant residents are unable to afford to move to less at-risk locations.
  • Campaigning by the CCAG raised awareness nationally. A council bid for government money led to a £3 million grant.
  • The grant was spent in giving Beach Road residence grants to help them move.
  • Beach Road houses were demolished to make a buffer zone between the village and the cliffs. The council constructed new homes nearby farmland, so the community could stay the same size.
  • Profits for the sale of the new houses will be used to buy more properties when they become at risk from coastal erosion.
42
Q

What is taking place in Bangladesh Chittagong (developing policy conflicts)?

A

A coastal climate resilient infrastructure project (2012) funded a range of small schemes for Chittagong, a port city on the Bay of Bengal.

  • Embankments raised roads above normal flood levels to 60cm above normal flood levels.
  • 25 tropical cyclone shelters
  • Newmarket areas with sheds raised on platforms above the predicted 2050 sea level.

+ Reduction in road flooding to 5 days a year instead of 20, generation of jobs.
- 200 people were relocated due to road realignment, embankments were slow to be constructed, and natural habitats were disturbed.