Clinical Flashcards
A neurotransmitter is
A chemical which carries messages between nerve cells
Which is the main neurotransmitter linked to Schizophrenia?
Dopamine
The orignal hypothesis said the levels of Dopamine in the synpase are…
Too high/too much activity at the receptor sites (hyper dopaminergia)
Why does the neurotransmitter level cause problems for people with Schizophrenia
There is too much action in the synapse/too many signals/too much activity
Which receptor is usually the one linked to Schizophrenia
D2
What is happening in the mesolimbic system?
Too much Dopamine (hyperdopaminergia), causes positive symptoms
What is happening in the mesocortical system?
Too little Dopamine (hypodopaminergia), causes negative symptoms
What else is tied to Schizophrenia as it controls Dopamine levels
Glutamate
What is the effect of this neurotransmitter on Dopamine?
Lower levels (hypoglutamatergia) lead to an increase in Dopamine
An increase in which other Neurotransmitter has been linked to both positive and negative symptoms
Serotonin
What did Carlsson find?
dopamine, glutamate and serotonin are all implicated in the development of schizophrenia showing that neurotransmitters can explain the development of Schizophrenia (but it isn’t just Dopamine)
What did the Liverpool universty study find?
found that childhood trauma makes you three times more likely to develop schizophrenia, suggesting that there is a strong relationship between the environment and the development of schizophrenia and it is not just due to neurotransmitters.
What did the Lindstroem study find?
found that schizophrenics used L-DOPA faster than the control group, suggesting they were producing more dopamine at a quicker rate, and the excess dopamine can explain how schizophrenia is caused
What did the Depatie & Lal study find?
found that giving people drugs that increase their production of dopamine does not create the symptoms of schizophrenia as would be expected if excess dopamine caused it, so it is not the only explanation of the causes of schizophrenia.
What did the Seeman study find?
they have a higher number of D2 receptors
Why is this a useful theory?
It has lead to drug treatments which work to lower symptoms- suggesting that this theory is credible
What is a problem in suggesting the drugs ‘prove’ this theory correct?
The drugs don’t work for everyone and don’t act instantaneously
Which of these is true and suggests the dopamine theory is valid/credible?
Amphetamines raise Dopamine levels and causes similar ‘symptoms’ to Schizophrenia
What is an issue with using Amphetamines as evidence?
They only cause the positive symptoms so don’t provide a complete explanation
What is a strength of using a biological explanation to describe Schizophrenia?
Empirical- you can measure neurotransmitters directly
A weakness of saying neurotransmitters cause schizophrenia is?
It has issues with cause and effect as most of the research is correlational
Why might genetics be a better explanation?
Genetics provide an underlying cause to explain why the neurotransmitters are different- giving better cause and effect
Why is this theory reductionist?
It ignores environmental factors like early childhood expereicnes influencing cognitive processes
Which of the 4Ds show that culture does effect diagnosis?
Deviance from social norms
Why is Ethnocentrism an issue?
Diagnosis as it downplays and ignores differences between cultures?
Why might the existence usage of the DSM and ICD cause issues for diagnoses across cultures?
They have different criteria/illnesses and are used in different countries
What are Dhat and Koro?
Culturally bound illnesses which are only found in one culture and so shows culture might effect illness
What is an issue if doctor and patient come from different cultures?
Language barriers or not communicating about illness the same way
What did Malgady find?
demonstrated there is a difference in the interpretation of hearing voiced between Costa Rican culture where it is interpreted as spirits talking to an individual and the USA where the same phenomenon is interpreted as a symptom of schizophrenia
What did Sato find/say?
Clinicians may be unwilling to give culturally sensitive diagnoses e.g. schizophrenia in Japan
What did Lopez find/say?
claimed trying to redress cultural bias in DSM by taking cultural beliefs into account can lead to missing some diagnoses as symptoms are dismissed as cultural norms.
What did Kastrup find/say?
argues that as not all cultures see the separation of mind and body prevalent in Western society if the patient and clinician do not share an understanding of how problems are described faulty diagnoses are likely to occur
What did Lin find/say?
Schizophrenia around the world shares more symptoms than it differs in- its the same mostly (with availability of treatment being the major factor in many differences
What did Banyard find/say?
5% population is black but 25% of psychiatric patients- showing a cultural bias
What did Escobar and Vega find/say?
The DSM-IV is unsatisfactory in terms of cross cultural applicability because of its strong western bias
What did Chandresa find/say?
shows that there are more rates of catatonia 21% in Sri Lanka than in British white people (5%)- though this is mostly due to treatment options.
What did Lee find/say?
showed that the DSM was valid in Korea for ADHD as the criteria matched with those diagnosed with the disorder
What did Burham find/say?
Mexican born Americans have more auditory hallucinations than American with Mexican origins. White Americans were reported to show more grandiosity in delusions- showing cultural issues in diagnosis
What did Cinerella and Lowenthal find?
ethnic group and religious faith had a marked effect on perceptions of mental illness so such factors need to be taken into account during diagnosis
What are the 4Ds
Deviance, Danger, Dysfunction and Distress
What does the deviance explanation of abnormality say about abnormality?
You are abnormal if you break social norms, agreed ways of behaving
What are the things which might impact social norms
Age, Sex, Culture, Context
What is statistical deviance?
When a behaviour is infrequent it becomes abnormal, when only a small % of people show a behaviour
What infrequency is suggested to make something deviant?
If it as over 2 standard deviations away from the mean
What does the Danger explanation of abnormality say about abnormality?
You are abnormal if your behaviour makes you a risk to yourself or others, this is subjective and on a continuum
What does the Dysfunction explanation of abnormality say about abnormality?
You are abnormal if you cannot function or live successfully e.g. go to work or have relationships, this is subjective and can be on a continuum
What would someone who has a dysfunction have difficulties doing?
Maintaining a job or going to college
What does the Distress explanation of abnormality say about abnormality?
You are abnormal if your behaviour makes you upset, this is subjective and on a continuum
Which axis on the DSM-IV took distress, danger and dysfunction into account to make a global decision?
5
Which of these is true for all 4 Ds?
They are subjective- due to personal interpretation/opinions of the doctor
What did Thomas Szasz say?
Deviance is socially controlling due to the myth of mental illness
What is a weakness of statistical deviance?
It uses arbritrary cut off of frequency so might not be valid
What is a weakness about frequency being used to diagnose people?
Behaviours can be infrequent without indicating abnormality and disorder
Why is Deviance worse then the other definitions?
It doesn’t deal with the wellbeing and quality of their lives whereas the others do
Despite being largely reductionist (only looking at social norms and ignoring the other Ds) how could you argue it might be holistic?
It looks at many factors like gender etc
What is a problem with using so many factors in Deviance?
It lowers the validity of disorder because there are so many possible definitions
What is a problem all of the Ds share?
You can be dangerous, distressed etc without it being classed as a disorder i.e. speeding or criminal behaviour
What is the fifth D which these all fail to address?
Duration- the length of time you show a certain behaviour is important
Why are the 4 Ds good?
They can and have been used to help in the diagnosis/defining of mental health issues
Describe the DSM
Has standardised symptoms for each illness, Updated regularly, Only focuses on mental illness, Created by the APA, Contains things like comorbidity, prevelance, differential diagnosis for each illness
What are the sections of the DSM?
Section 1 is the introduction, with section 2 having the classification of the main mental health disorders. Within section 3, there is a cultural formulation interview guide to help with diagnosis of the disorder and emerging disorders
Describe the ICD
Created by WHO, Is used worldwide, Updated regularly, Features all illnesses not just mental illness, Contains things like incedence, prevalence and mortality for each illness, Is used more commonly around the world
How would you diagnose an illness using the ICD?
You would go to the section about mental and behavioural disorders. You would look at the symptoms and criteria under each mental illness and find the relevant one to the patient
What about the diagnostic systems makes diagnosis more reliable?
They have standardised symptoms that everyone uses
What about the diagnostic systems makes diagnosis less reliable?
Bias in diagnosis (cultural, gender etc) by the doctor
What did Rosenhan find about validity of diagnosis?
Diagnosis might not be valid because patients can lie and be given the wrong diagnosis
What did Rosenhan find about reliablity of diagnosis?
Diagnosis is reliable because all but one were given the same diagnosis of Schizophrenia when presenting the same symptoms
What did Ford and Widiger find?
males and females diagnosed differently with same symptoms (doctor bias)
What did Ward et al find?
False diagnosis was caused 32.5% inconsistency with the interpretation of symptoms and 62.5% was due to the inadequacy of the classification system
What did Lee find?
Found good concurrent validity between ADHD diagnosis in Korea using DSM criteria
What did Jakobsen et al find?
An ICD-10 diagnosis showed 93% sensitivity and 87% predictive value when diagnosing schizophrenia
What did Goldstein find?
found that 169 of the 199 patients were rediagnosed with Schizophrenia when DSM was updated
What did Stinchfield find?
91% accuracy on diagnosing gambling disorder when using DSM 5
What did Cheniaux find?
They found that schizophrenia was more common when using ICD-10 rather than DSM-IV
What did Brown 2001 find?
Brown found good-to-excellent reliability for most of the DSM-IV categories. However, they found some boundary problems with certain disorders
What did Nicholls find?
ICD 10 was used it was found to be only a 36% agreement for eating disorders
What did Powers find?
women who had suffered complex post traumatic disorder also had higher levels of alcohol and substance misuse as predicted by ICD 11, showing that ICD 11 does have good predictive validity
What is a patient factor effecting diagnosis?
They may give faulty information due to stigma
What did Kim-Cohen find?
found that the DSM has predictive validity for conduct disorders in children (1) as a larger majority of children who had at least three conduct disorder symptoms at five years old according to DSM had at least one educational difficulty two years later
What did Morey find?
found that DSM 5 was more reliable than DSM IV in diagnosing borderline personality disorder so diagnosis of mental health disorders should be reliable if DSM V was used
What did Reiger find?
DSM 5 had a concordance rate of 0.46 for schizophrenia so might not be reliable
What would it mean if a diagnosis was valid?
A patient was given the correct diagnosis of an illness for the one they have
What would it mean if a diagnosis was reliable?
You would get the same diagnosis is rediagnosed
What is construct validity?
The diagnostic manual is operationalised correctly and has the correct symptoms for each illnes
What is concurrent validity?
Two different diagnostic methods e.g. the two manuals agree