Clinical Flashcards
What is Medical Student Syndrome? What does it trigger?
a condition whereby many medical students self-report having an assortment of problems and diseases after learning about them in school.
Triggers confirmation bias
What are 3 things to keep in mind when learning about disorders?
- Most symptoms of disorders are also present in everyday normal functioning.
- The prevalence of most disorders is low.
- Only a trained clinical psychologist can diagnose you with a clinical disorder, and self- diagnosis ability is quite poor (even amongst trained professionals!).
What is mental health stigma? how does this effect the experience of having a mental health disorder? What does it make us accept? What does it lead to?
a culturally-specific negative belief and attitude towards those who are seen as suffering from a mental health problem.
Stigma makes the experience of having a mental disorder even worse and more difficult to treat.
But it also makes us accept myths about how mental disorders work, that lead to people being harmed even if they do not actually have a disorder.
leads to people magnifying or minimizing their experiences.
Are there correlations between people who commit acts of violence and people with mental health issues?
there are very weak correlations between people who commit acts of violence and people with mental health issues.
Why can we not define a mental disorder as “when a behaviour is rare or atypical”?
Problem: many atypical/rare things are not disorders (e.g., happiness).
Problem: is atypical always bad?
Problem: some psychological disorders are surprisingly common.
Why can we not define mental health problems as “When normal psychological functions biology malfunction”?
Problem: what is “normal psychological function”?
Problem: psychological traits show very high variability.
Problem: can we apply psychological findings universally?
Why can we not define mental health problems as “condition that causes harm to self and others”?
Problem: lots of things cause harm but shouldn’t be considered psychologically “dysfunctional” (e.g., racism, aging).
Problem: some things that seem to be disorders don’t cause any harm to others (e.g., auditory hallucinations, some personality disorders).
Why can we not define mental health problems as “Behaviour that is in conflict with societal norms”?
e.g., Thomas Szasz: mental illness is a cultural myth we use to attach stigma, filter people, and put them “in their place”.
Problem: many people diagnosed with a disorder are really suffering independent of society and want to find help and treatment.
Why can we not define mental health problems as “ A condition that causes distress and significant problems in everyday function (e.g., social, work, school, etc.)”?
Problem: though many disorders lead to people self-reporting impairment in everyday function, not all of them do (e.g., developmental disorders, many forms of addiction).
Problem: what about significant problems caused by natural variability?
Problem: what about significant problems caused by sociocultural factors (e.g.,
poverty)?
What does clinical psychology allow for in regards to our definition of mental disorders?
Clinical psychology allows our definition of mental disorder to change as we
understand more about their causes and consequences.
What is the current definition of a mental disorder?
a) Cognitive/emotional distress.
b) Significant impairment in daily function.
c) Underlying psychobiological dysfunction and not only environmental factors.
d) That is not primarily the result of social deviance or societal conflict.
e) Is usually long-term (i.e., weeks to months to years).
What is the medical model of disorders?
all psychological disorders are due to physical/biological causes, have clear and identifiable symptoms, and can be cured like any other disease.
What is the bio psycho social model in terms of mental health?
psychological disorders are caused by a complex network of biological, psychological, and social factors.
When was the DSM 5 last updated?
Last updated in March 2022 with very minor changes.
What are the features of the DSM?
- Developed by researchers: the DSM-5-TR is made by psychiatrists and psychologists who research the disorders they diagnose. (It is sensitive to the evolution of scientific research.
- “Atheoretical”: the DSM-5 is a tool for categorizing, not for telling you why somebody is experiencing a disorder. (it does not abide by models (biopsych social etc))
- Impairment in everyday functioning: most disorders can only be diagnosed if symptoms are causing significant problems in everyday functioning. (this is mandatory)
- Medical, environmental, and deviancy exclusions: clinicians are instructed to make sure that the problem is truly psychobiological in origin, and not caused by medical problems or societal conflicts or purely environmental effects.
- Criteria and Decision Rules: each disorder has a set of clearly defined features with
some degree of flexibility. (allows for some differences in presentation from person to person. )
What is the DSM 5? Is it the standard?
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual 5th Edition Text Revision (DSM-5-TR): a classification system for diagnosing recognized 150+ disorders, indicating how they can be distinguished from other, similar problems and describing their typical presentation.
Though not without its problems, the DSM-5-TR is considered the standard in
diagnosing clinical disorders.
How frequently is the DSM updated? What does this allow us to do? (3 things)
DSM is updated every 8 – 12 years by a team of psychologists and
psychiatrists.
This allows us to:
- Identify new disorders (e.g., hoarding): especially those that may have been considered typical in the past due to cultural or social biases.
- Update existing disorders (e.g., autism, schizophrenia): especially when new research has drastically changed how we think about them.
- Remove previous disorders (e.g., Asperger’s, homosexuality): often because of better understanding of disorders and shifts in cultural norms.
What are some key things to note about the DSM diagnostic for ASD? (4 things) How does this relate to the general criteria for mental disorders?
The problems must be persistent (longterm criteria)
not accounted for by general developmental delays (not only environmental factors)
it must have been present in early childhood (not primarily the result of social conflict)
the symptoms must limit and impair everyday functioning. (significant impairment in daily function)
What are some key things to note about the DSM diagnostic for mild neuro-cognitive disorder? (7 things)
must have evidence of modest cognitive decline from a previous level of performance
information must have been collected by a knowlegeable informant
cognitive impairment must be documented by standardized neuropsychological testing
Cognitive deficits do not interfere with capacity for independence.
cognitive deficits can’t interfere with capacity for independence
cannot exclusively occur n the context of delirium
cannot be better explained by another mental disorder
Where in the world is the DSM 5 most frequently used?
the global north
What are 3 things that the DSM 5 is criticized for?
Ties With Insurance: when the DSM changes, people might suddenly lose their diagnosis and therefore no longer have access to treatment. (mental health care is primarily tied to insurance which requires a diagnosis, this is concerning. Can cause lots of harm to individuals.)
Comorbidity: co-occurrence/correlation of two or more diagnoses within the same person. If we properly categorize disorders, comorbidity should be zero (e.g., having a cold is not correlated with having insomnia). However, the DSM-5-TR disorders show widespread comorbidity. (as many as 50% of people diagnosed with 1 disorder within the DSM also meet the criteria for another. This means that the DSM 5 is not cutting up disorders in the way its says it is. This may imply that the disorders it is capturing is not actually a good fit for the underlying causes.)
Categorical disorders: the DSM treats most disorders as categorical (you have it or you do not), when in reality there are clearly variations in severity. (the vast majority of these disorders actually occur as a spectrum. )
Can the problems with the DSM be fixed? Why?
these problems will not be fixed by the DSM because they are built in.
What is the hierarchical Taxonomy of psychopathology (HiTOP)
a research-informed manual that adopts a multi-dimensional approach that focuses on problems in specific psychological functions across different levels that might lead to overlapping conditions.
this is not a labelling manual. It is a guide that assesses specific functions
if we care more about the underlying causes of these symptoms we can help them better
What are 3 questions that summarize why diagnosing clinical disorders is hard?
Diagnosing clinical disorders is hard.
What is abnormal?
What causes disorders?
How do we diagnose fairly and adaptively?