Classification and assessment in psychiatry Flashcards
Two major classificatory systems (+dates)
ICD-10 (WHO, 1992)
DSM-IV (American Psychiatric Association, 1994)
Operationalised approach (to classification)
Essentially a ‘checklist’ approach to diagnosis:
- Precise clinical descriptions of disorders
- Predefined exclusion and inclusion criteria
- Details of the number/duration of symptoms required for diagnosis
3 kinds of symptoms relevant to the operationalised approach to classification
Characteristic symptoms - pertinent to the diagnosis (e.g. the symptoms of depression are found in many different disorders)
Pathognomonic symptoms - strongly favour one diagnosis over another (e.g. flashbacks in PTSD)
Discriminating symptoms - necessary for a diagnosis (e.g. thought insertion)
‘CPD’
Atheoretical approach (to classification)
Diseases are described according to the observed phenomenology; NOT based on an understanding of what might be causing the disturbances
(no theory - e.g. behaviourism, psychoanalytic - forms the basis of the classifications, only neutral observations are taken into account)
Descriptive approach
Illnesses are classified on the basis of what constitutes the illness, not what causes them.
This forms the basis of the atheoretical approach.
Hierarchical organisation
Certain disorders take precedence over others when making a diagnosis.
If a disorder closer to the top of the hierarchy can explain the observed symptoms, then a diagnosis should not be entertained from below even if the constellation of symptoms are suggestive of such a diagnosis
Stems from the ideas of Karl Jaspers.
Largely abandoned in DSM but maintained in ICD-10’s organisation of chapters.
Organic disorders - Substance use disorders - Psychosis - Affective disorders - Neurotic disorders - Personality issues
ICD-10 Multiaxial approach
1 - mental disorder (including personality disorder and mental handicap)
2 - degree of disability
3 - current psychosocial problems
DSM-IV Multiaxial approach
1 - clinical disorders
2 - personality disorders/mental retardation
3 - general medical conditions
4 - psychosocial and environmental problems
5 - global assessment of functioning
DSM-V (updates from DSM-IV)
Published 2013
Abandoned use of multiaxial diagnosis and global assessment of functioning
Autistic disorder, Asperger’s, and pervasive developmental disorder were consolidated into one disorder: Autistic spectrum disorder.
Binge eating disorder, premenstrual dysphoric disorder, and hoarding disorder gained recognition as ‘real’ disorders.
DSM-V (modifications to psychosis)
Removal of ‘bizarre’ delusions
Removal of subtypes of schizophrenia
3 core symptoms recognised: delusions, hallucinations, disorganised speech
Changes in schizoaffective criteria
DSM-V (modifications to mood disorders)
Dysthymia and chronic depression merged
Bereavement no longer an exclusion for depression
Premenstrual dysphoric disorder added as a new diagnosis
DSM-V (modifications to developmental disorders)
Autistic disorder, Asperger’s, and pervasive developmental disorder were consolidated into one disorder: Autistic spectrum disorder.
ADHD age criteria relaxed
Anton’s syndrome
aka Anton-Babinski syndrome
Occurs following damage to the occipital lobe.
Affected individuals are cortically blind but are unaware of this and deny they have a problem (anosognosia). It often presents as the patient starts falling over furniture as they can’t see. Affected individuals believe they can still see and describe their environments in detail but are wrong in their description (confabulation).
Anosognosia
lack of insight
multiple choice questionnaire used to rate the severity of depression.
Depending on the version used there are either 17 or 21 items. Each item is scored out of between 3 and 5 points. The greater the total points scored the more severe the depression is.
For the 17 item version (the most commonly used) scores range between 0 and 54. Scores over 24 indicate a severe depression.
HAMD (Hamilton depression rating scale)
10-item diagnostic questionnaire used to measure the severity of depressive episodes.
It was designed to be more sensitive to the changes brought on by antidepressants and other forms of treatment.
MADRS (Montgomery-Asberg depression rating scale)
assesses the severity of depression.
There are 20 items on the scale, each one scored out of 1-4.
ZSRDS (Zung self rated depression scale)
assesses the severity of depression
21 items, each scored 0-3.
The scale was revised in 1966.
0-13 indicates minimal depression,
14-19 mild depression,
20-28 moderate,
29-63 severe depression.
BDI (Beck depression inventory)
30 item self-report scale used to screen for depression in the elderly.
Each question has either a yes or no response, making the total score out of 30.
0-9 is deemed normal,
10-19 is mild depression,
20-30 is severe depression.
GDS (geriatric depression scale)
screening test for depression.
It uses a deck of cards with statements such as ‘I’ve lost interest in things’ which are shown to the patient. In response to each card, the patient indicates whether the card is true or false by pointing to another card.
There are 19 cards with a maximum score of 21 (two cards carry 2 points each).
It is a quick test and takes less than 5 minutes to administer. A cut off score of 7 is generally used.
The test was developed for use on busy wards to introduce a degree of privacy as other tests involve questions being read out and someone in the next cubicle hearing everything.
BASDEC (Brief Assessment Schedule Depression Cards)
This test was developed specifically to screen for depression in dementia cases. It involves a 20 min interview with a carer and 10 mins with the patient.
A total of 19 items are rated as either ‘absent’, ‘mild / intermittent’, or ‘severe’.
Cornell Scale for Depression in Dementia
11-item instrument used to assess the severity of mania in patients with a diagnosis of bipolar disorder.
YMRS (Young mania rating scale)
14 item scale designed to measure the severity of anxiety.
HAMA (Hamilton anxiety rating scale)
used to measure both the severity of OCD and the response to treatment.
Y-BOCS (Yale-Brown Obsessive compulsive scale)