Class, power and crime Flashcards
What are the 4 explanations of Explaining class differences in crime?
Functionalism
Strain theory
Subcultural theories
Labeling theory
What is functionalist explanation of class differences in crime?
see crime as a product of inadequate socialization into a shared culture.Miller argues that the lower class has an independent subculture opposed to mainstream culture and this explains their higher crime rate.
What is Strain theorists explanation of class differences in crime?
People commit crime because they lack legitmate means to achieve socially approved goals.
What is Subcultural theories explanation of class differences in crime?
A.K Cohen sees working class youths as culturally deprived and unable to achieve in education. Failure gives them status frustration. As a solution they form delinquent subcultures in which they gain status from peers. Cloward and Ohlin identify three deviant subcultures.
What is Labelling theories explanation of class differences in crime?
They reject the view that official statistics are a valid picture of which class commits crime. They focus on the role of law enforcement agencies, which have the power to label the working class as criminals.
How do traditional marxists agree with Labelling theory?
that the law is enforced disproportionately against the W/C and therefore the official crime statistics cannot be taken at face value.
How do Traditional marxists disagree with Labelling theory?
for failing to examine wider structure of capitalism within which law making, law enforcement and offending takes place.
Marxists see capitalist society divided into what?
They see the capitalist society divided by capitalist class ( those who have means of production ) and the working class ( whose labour is exploited for profit.)
Why is Marxism a structural theory?
because society is a structure whose economic base determines the superstructure i.e all other institutions the state, CJS.
For Marxists is crime inevitable in capitalism?
Yes because crime is criminogenic ( its very nature causes crime.
How does Capitalism create poverty?
It creates poverty becuase crime is the only way the W/C can survive. Capitalism means that the rich can exploit the W/C for profit and give them low wages to settle with.
How does Capitalism create desire to steal consumer goods?
This is because of capitalist advertising, resulting in utilitarian crime ( theft)
How may Alienation and lack of control over lives lead to crime?
It may lead to frustration and aggression, resulting in non-utilitarian crimes such as violence and vandalism.
Is crime only confined to Working class?
NO
Why isn’t crime only confined to Working class?
Capitalism is a win-at-all costs system of competition, the profit motive encourages greed, encouraging corporate crime, such as tax evasion and breaking health and safety laws.
Who is the sociologists who says crime is a rational response to Capitalism?
Gordon (1976) he argues crime is a rational response to capitalism and thus is found in all classes.
How do Functionalists see law making as?
they see laws as reflecting value consensus and representing interests of society as a whole.
However who do Marxists see the State and law making?
Marxists see law making and law enforcement as only serving interests of capitalist class.
Who is the sociologists that argues that the laws protect private property?
Chambliss (1975)
What does Chambliss say ?
Laws to protect private property are the corner stone of the capitalist economy.
What are two examples of law making to benefit Working class ( A02)?
Vagrancy laws
Capital gains
What where Vagrancy laws?
( 1349) there was the plague and many workers died, workers demanded higher wages, this didn’t last as vagrancy laws were introduced meaning you cannot demand higher wages. This good for capitalist class because they can generate profit.
What was Capital gains?
Those who own bonds or stocks pay less tax than everyday individuals. Those with high investment in stocks and bonds were more powerful in society. Whereas WC pay moreo tax on little income.
What is Selective enforcement?
Powerless groups e,g WC and EMs are criminalized, police and courts tend to ignore crimes of powerful
What does these Health and Safety stats show and is an example of Selective enforcement e.g. 609,000 injuries occured at work according to labour force survey and 137 workers killed at work in 2016?
These may not be acted on as corporate crime meaning that it isn’t a big problem to Criminal justice system.
Who is the sociologist that studied a sample of 200 firms?
Carson ( 1971), in a sample of 200 firms, found all had broken health and safety laws, yet only 1.5 cases were prosecuted, by contrast, there is much higher rate of prosecutions for the crimes of the poor.
What is Ideological functions of crime all about?
Laws are passed that often benefit the w/c over capitalism, this creates false consciousness. such as Health and safety
How does Health and safety play an ideological function? including sociologist
Keeps workers fit to work given a caring face, creating false consciousness. This benefits capitalist class too.
How do welfare laws play an ideological function?
They are lower than wages to force people back to work serving ruling class.
What social agency plays an ideological function of crime?
Media portrays criminals as disturbed individuals, thereby concealing the fact that it is the nature of capitalism that makes people criminal e.g. Policing the crisis Hall.
What was Policing the crisis (1971 hall)
Moral panic developed over the crime of mugging in the 1970s. The moral panic over black criminality at the time created a divison in society away from wider economic crisis - black youths out of control’ being headlines rather than ‘capitalism in crisis.’
What was the overview of the story?
1) There was a major economic recession in the mid 1970, which increased unemployment
2) Capitalsim faced a legitmate crisis so the govt needed a scapegoat.
3) Fortunately the government the recession lead to further social marginalisation of black youth and lead to increase in street robbery
4) The media picked up on this creating a moral panic and the govt responsed by putting more police