Civil Liability Book Flashcards
Civil suits increased by ___ from 1967-71
124%
During a 5 year period, at least ___ of ___ officers were sanctioned for misconduct (theft - sexual assault)
3,000 of 600,000
Some conclude that no other government group is more exposed to civil liability than who?
Police officers
Annually, how many civil actions brought against police depts, cities, officers?
30,000
What % of officers from multiple agencies within a single county had been sued during their careers?
27%
Police lose about __% of the federal case brought against them. A study done in Texas showed police losing __% of lawsuits.
8 / 22
The trend is that lawsuits are __ and police are losing more of them. Even win police win, it is __ for the agency.
increasing / expensive
Female officers showed __ anxiety over being sued than males and __ officers show more concern than do their chiefs
less / lower ranking
__ fears of civil liability can erode the necessary confidence and willingness to act. These views can foster __ , __, and __ between the police and the community
unrealistic / protectionism / coverups / division
of the __ police liability case decided by federal courts in __, only __ cases contained a claim of frivolous lawsuit against the police (less than __%)
658 / 2004 / 6 / 9
How much of all police encounters with those suspected of committing a crime resulted in civil litigation?
1/10th of 1%
Civil liability is an extremely expensive proposition for officers, agencies, gov’ts and taxpayers due to these 4 things
-cost of liability insurance
-litigation expenses
-out of court settlements
-punitive damage awards
The cost of an average jury award if liability against a municipality is reported to be about how much? None of these represent the growing trend of settling out of court which make up __% of the results per a Texas study
2 million / 25%
A __ survey found that __ was the biggest contributor to the rising cost of municipal liability
1996 / police liability
Allowing citizens to sue the police for misconduct has fostered these 2 things
-better police training
-more responsible LE practices
When police are held __ for their misconduct, the courts set standards for acceptable and unacceptable behavior and by doing so establish the bounds of what?
liable / professional police practice
In reviewing a motion to __, a court must construe the complaint in the light most favorable to the complainant and accept all well pleaded facts as __
dismiss / true
If a case survives motion to dismiss and/or a motion for summary judgement, then it will proceed to __
trial
The ability of the police to appeal a denial of summary judgement has been restricted by the Supreme court by what 2 case law cases?
-Johnson v Jones 1995
-Swint v Chambers County Comm 1995
The restriction to appeal a denial of summary judgement has had what 2 effects on police litigation?
-cases now move faster since police defendants can no longer file an automatic appeal of the denial
-more cases will be settled if the only alternative is to proceed to trial
In cases where there is complete lack of evidence the judge can enter a __ or __ that finds in favor of the officer even when jury has found against
directed verdict / judgement of law
It is not unusual for police cases to take __ from the event in question to final disposition
3-10 years
3 trends in police litigation
-has increased sharply since the 1960’s
-successful litigation against police has increased
-significant # of judgements handed down against police despite a good record of defending themselves
What is a civil legal action between private parties not arising from written contracts?
torts
Torts are not subject to __, but are addressed by what?
Some torts can be both __ and __
As opposed to criminal acts, 2 things:
-criminal punishment / monetary rewards
-torts / crime
-1. violations of explicit law
2. acts against not only the written law but the interests of the state and community
What are the 3 types of torts under state law?
-strict liability
-intentional
-negligence
Strict liability:
Behaviors __
Elements __
Plaintiff is not required to prove __, and the defendants mental state is not a __
-extremely dangerous
-specific conduct or damage
-fault / judicial consideration
Intentional tort:
Behaviors __
Elements__
Some of the most common examples filed against the police __
-Purposive behavior (intentional) likely to result in damage (does not mean an officer intended to inflict injury or damage)
-knowledge, foreseeability, damage or injury
-wrongful death, assault & battery, false arrest, invasion of privacy and false light, intentional infliction of emotional distress
Negligence
Behaviors __
Elements__
-inadvertent and unreasonable behaviors
-legal duty, breach, proximate cause, damage or injury
Court case that curtailed the use of deadly force by officers
2 instances when police may use deadly force
-Tenn v Garner
-1. Escape of dangerous felon
-2. protect themselves or others from serious physical harm
The threat to do serious bodily harm to another person with the ability to carry out the threat
assault
intentional, impermissible, and offensive contact with another is what?
battery
Plaintiff claiming __ must establish how many factors for successful civil litigation. Name them
-False arrest / 4
1. police willfully detained them
2. detention was against their will
3. detention was made without authority of law
4. person being detained was aware of their confinement
A successful claim of false imprisonment generally requires how many things?
Name them
3
1. intent to confine, restrain freedom of movement, restriction of personal liberty
2. unlawful act resulting in restriction of freedom or liberty of movement
3. knowledge of the harm
False imprisonment claims are usually based on what?
conduct of the officer following the arrest
1 way to limit the likelihood of a liability for false arrest is to what?
secure a warrant before the arrest
A simple invasion of privacy consists of how many parts?
Name them
3
1. an intrusion
2. that is highly offensive
3. into some matter where there is a legitimate expectation of privacy
What occurs then a police officer gives publicity to a private matter concerning a specific citizen in a fictitious and negative way?
false light invasion of privacy
4 elements to establish a case of negligence
- a legal duty
- a breach of duty
- proximate cause
- actual damage or injury
Most common legal doctrines barring police liability are what?
sovereign immunity and public duty