Civ Pro MBE Flashcards
Subject-Matter Jurisdiction
1) Diversity of Citizenship 2) Federal Question
Amount in Controversy
Must be in excess of $75K • Court must have “legal certainty”
Adding Claims
Plaintiff can ADD claims if one exceeds $75K Single Plaintiff can ADD claims against Single Defendant to reach $75K Multiple Plaintiffs via Supplemental Jurisdiction If Single Plaintiff meets $75K then other plaintiffs can join Cannot join if no single claim exceeds $75K
Class Action
One named member must meet $75K
Diversity Jurisdiction
1) Case exceeds $75K 2) Complete Diversity of Citizenship - No plaintiff may be a citizen of the same state as any defendant
Citizenship - Domicile
Present location & Intent to stay
US Citizen + Foreign Citizen
Diversity
Two Foreign Citizens
NO Diversity
Corporation - Domicile
State of incorporation AND • Principal place of business
Joining Parties
CANNOT join a party just to obtain Diversity
Federal Question
1) Plaintiff’s claim must be based on federal law 2) Well-Pleaded Complaint Rule: Federal issue must be obvious Federal Issue as a defense is NOT a federal question
Federal Question Cases
1) Admiralty 2) Maritime 3) Intellectual Property
Supplemental Jurisdiction
May add claims without subject-matter jurisdiction if they arise from a “common nucleus of facts”
Supplemental Jurisdiction - Allowed
1) Compulsory Counterclaim 2) Joinder in Compulsory Counterclaim 3) Cross-claim 4) Impleader of 3rd Party Defendants
Supplemental Jurisdiction - NOT Allowed
1) Original Plaintiff vs. 3rd Party Defendant 2) Compulsory Joinder 3) Joinder of Defendants 4) Intervention
Supplemental Jurisdiction & Discretion
Court has DISCRETION to apply Supplemental Jurisdiction
Personal Jurisdiction
In personem • Ability to bring the individual into court
Personal JX General Rules
1) Present/ Personally Served 2) Domiciled 3) Consent
Long-Arm Statute
Gives courts the power to reach out-of-state persons
Minimum Contacts Standard
1) Suit does not offend traditional notions of Fair Play & Justice 2) Defendant could Reasonably Anticipate litigation
Minimum Contacts - Corporations
Purposeful Availment • Systematic & Continuous Activities
IN REM JURISDICTION
Jurisdiction over an object/property
QUASI IN REM JURISDICTION
Going after property to satisfy a judgment against an individual
Service of Process
1) Only in the state where district court sits OR 2) Anywhere allowed by long-arm statute
100 Mile Bulge Rule
1) Out-of-state service allowed within 100 mile radius 2) Only for out-of-state 3rd party defendants/indispensable parties
Service of Process & Notice
Method must give adequate NOTICE
Proper Ways to Serve Process
1) Personal Service by non-party over 18 2) At Home with person of suitable age 3) First Class Mail 4) Authorized Agent 5) State Law Methods A - Abode W - Waiver A - Agent S - State method P - Personal service
Out-of-State Service of Process
1) Mail 2) Newspaper if no other reasonable way
Service of Process - Corporations
1) Officer or Designated Agent 2) Anyone of sufficiently high placement
Removal
When a State Court case could have originally been brought in Federal Court
Who Can Remove
1) Only DEFENDANT may remove 2) ALL defendants must agree
Removal - Timing
Filed within 30 DAYS of service of Complaint
Removal - Diversity Cases
1) Case cannot be removed more than 1 year after start 2) Defendant cannot remove if he is a citizen of forum state
Removal Multiple Claims
If one claim is removable, then the entire case can be removed
Remand
Plaintiff wants to bring case back to State Court after improper Removal
Remand - Timing
Within 30 DAYS of filing of Notice of Removal • Defendant has burden to show Removal was proper
Venue
The proper Federal District Court for the case Venue is based on where DEFENDANT resides
Proper Venue
1) Where any defendant resides, if all defendants reside in same state 2) Where substantial part of events took place ONLY IF 1 & 2 DON’T APPLY - 3) Where there is Personal Jurisdiction over defendant
Venue - Corporations
1) Principal place of business 2) Any district in state of incorporation
Transfer of Venue - Proper Venue
1) Court may TRANSFER to another district 2) For the convenience of parties & interest of justice 3) Law of original venue will apply
Transfer of Venue - Improper Venue
1) Judge must dismiss OR transfer in the interest of justice 2) Transfer to any district where the case could have originally been brought
Transfer by Consent
Both parties must consent
Dismissal for Improper Venue
If the more convenient forum is a foreign country
Complaint
Filing of Complaint commences Statute of Limitations Service of the Complaint within 90 days
Elements of the Complaint
1) Statement of Jurisdiction 2) Statement of Facts (not theory) 3) Demand for Relief
Answer
1) Signed by lawyer 2) Whatever is not denied is admitted 3) Served within 21 days of service of Complaint
Affirmative Defense
Pled in Answer Contributory Negligence • Statute of Frauds • Statute of Limitations • Illegality
Amendment as of Right
Once within 21 days of service of pleading
After 21 Days Amendment
Need Court’s permission • “When justice so requires”
Relation Back
Arose out of the same conduct, transaction, or occurrence
Relation Back (for PARTIES)
1) Same conduct, transaction, or occurrence 2) Within 90 days of filing the party had notice 3) Knew/should have known but for mistake of ID
Rule 11
Attorney signs to best of “knowledge, information, and belief” there is a basis for the claim Key Words
Counterclaim
Defendant raises a claim back at the plaintiff
Compulsory Counterclaim
1) Same transaction or occurrence 2) Supplemental jurisdiction
Permissive Counterclaim
1) NOT same transaction or occurrence 2) Needs independent jurisdiction
Permissive Joinder
1) Single transaction or occurrence 2) Common questions of law/fact
Compulsory Joinder
Party needs to be joined or unfair
1) Necessary Party
Impair Interest • If cannot join due to jurisdiction - Case may STILL PROCEED
2) Indispensable Party
Prejudice • If cannot join due to jurisdiction - Case must be DISMISSED
Class Certification
1) Size 2) Common Question 3) Typical 4) Representation/Conflict
Types of Class Actions
B1 = Impairment of Interests • B2 = Injunctive Relief • B3 = Common Question (the superior method)