CIB 012 - Arson Flashcards
Liability: arson (danger to life)
Section 267(1)(a)
1- Intentionally/recklessly
2- damages by fire/by explosive
3- any property
4- if he knows/ought to know danger to life likely to ensue
Liability: Arson (no interest in property)
Section 267(1)(b)
1- Intentionally/recklessly
2- without claim right
3- damages by fire or by means of any explosive
4- any immovable property/veh/ship/aircraft
5- in which that person has no interest
Liability: Arson (intent obtain benefit)
Section 267(1)(c)
1- Intentionally
2- damages by fire/by explosive
3- any immovable property/veh/ship/aircraft
4- with Intent
5- to obtain any benefit or cause loss to any other person
Liability: Arson (no interest lower value property)
Section 267(2)(a)
1- Intentionally/recklessly
2- w/o COR
3- damages by fire or explosive
4- any property
5- in which that person has no interest
Liability: Arson (obtain bene lower value)
Section 267(2)(b)
1- intentionally/recklessly
2- damages by fire/explosive
3- any property
4- with intent
5- to obtain any benefit/cause loss to other person
Liability: Arson (reckless disregard)
Section 267(3)
1- intentionally
2- damages by fire/explosive
3- any property
4- with reckless disregard for safety of any other property
What does benefit include under arson (267) and also intentional damage (269)?
Benefit means: “BPPPSV”
Any benefit
Pecuniary advantage
Property
Privilege
Service
Valuable consideration
What are the 2 specific types of intent to prove?
Intentions act
Intent to produce a specific result
Caselaw: R v COLLISTER?
Intent can be inferred from circumstantial evidences and inferred from:
1 - Offenders actions/words before or during and after
2 - the surrounding circumstances
3 - the nature of the act itself
Acting recklessly involves what?
Consciously and deliberately taking an unjustifiable risk
Caselaw: CAMERON v R?
“Recognise real”
Recklessness established if:
Recognised real possibility actions would bring a proscribed result and actions were unreasonable
What is part a of the CAMERON test?
Subjective test: “A real possibility”
Defendant recognised the risk the offence is possible
What is part b of the CAMERON test?
Obj test: were actions reasonable given risk understood.
If no social utility = unreasonable.
is social utility, objectively would reas prudent person taken risk
What must be proved in recklessness?
1- that the defendant consciously and deliberately ran risk (subj)
2- the risk was unreasonable in circ”s as known to defendant (obj)
What does damaged by fire include?
“BCMBS”
Burning, charring, melting, blistering smoke damage
Caselaw: R V ARCHER?
“Archer arrow damage perm/temp”
Property damaged if suffers perm/temp physical harm or impairment of use/value
What is fire a result of?
Process of combustion and a chemical reaction between fuel and oxygen triggered by heat
Def: explosive?
Any substance/mixture/combo substances which in normal state
capable of decomposition at such rapid rate to result in explosion or pyro effect
Def: property?
Real and personal property and any estate in interest in such
Def: what does knowing mean?
Knowing or correctly believing
Def: life?
Means human life
Def: claim of right?
At time of act, a belief in proprietary or possessory right in property to which offence alleged. Belief may be based on ignorance or mistake
In general what does immovable property relate to?
Buildings, land and things growing on land like forests
Def: vehicle?
Contrivance equipped with wheels tracks or runners on which it moves or is moved
Def: ship?
Every description of vessel used in navigation however propelled
Def: obtain?
Obtain or retain for himself