Christian moral principles - autonomous (agape)

Question 1

Basis

Answer 1

In Mark, Jesus summarised all the law as being about agape

Question 2

Tillich

Answer 2

Agape is the central precept
We should use the laws of the Bible to learn but keep agape as the centre for any moral decisions

Question 3

Fletcher

Answer 3

Situation ethics
Agape is the basis for all moral decisions - prevents an overly legalistic approach
Follow Bible rules unless it is more loving to do otherwise - because love is the greatest law
Person centred - like Jesus

Question 4

Robinson

Answer 4

Love has a built in moral compass
Sermon on the mount did not replace the decalogue put showed how to put agape into practice

Question 5

Strengths of autonomous ethics

Answer 5

Agape is the only force that can adapt to changing moral scenarios
Love is a fundamental and driving emotion anyway - by design that it should guide us?
Jesus himself kept returning to love in moral situations

Question 6

Weaknesses of autonomous ethics

Answer 6

Over-simplifies Jesus’ teachings
People interpret love differently in different situations
Love requires the use of reason too (although this is acknowledged)
Agape may be unachievable for many people
Love could be an excuse for doing what you want