chapter seven Flashcards
chapter seven: family, school, peers and the youth crime problem
This chapter focuses on research findings pertaining to the factors indicated by theory as most relevant to understanding youth crime and delinquency—family, school and peers. In reading this chapter, students will:
Appreciate what we know about the effects of family structure and family relationships on youth crime and delinquency.
Know the individual, organizational, and structural factors that link school performance to youth crime and delinquency.
Understand how friends and peers impact on young peoples’ involvement in criminal, delinquent, and gang activity.
Appreciate the links among research, risk assessment, and crime prevention policy and practice.
for at least 100 years what has been identifief as a “casual” factor throughout Canadian history?
The family has been identified as a “causal” factor when theorizing about crime and delinquency throughout Canadian history, and youth gangs and peer influences have been linked to crime and delinquency for at least 100 years.
In addition, while schools were thought of at the turn of the 19th century as a “solution” to delinquency issues, this seemed to change in the 1980s,
schools are often presented as a source of what?
In addition, while schools were thought of at the turn of the 19th century as a “solution” to delinquency issues, this seemed to change in the 1980s, and schools are now often presented as a source of many youth crime issues.
These factors are also important in that they are the primary tools used today to determine if youth are at risk of delinquent and criminal behaviour
note:
Nonetheless, in spite of a consistent academic and professional focus on these factors, the interrelationships among family, school, and peer impacts on delinquency are complex and not easily understood, particularly when intersectionalities of race, class, and gender are added to the mix.
what does control theory and differential association implies?
Control theory, for example, argues that strong attachments even to delinquent friends will decrease delinquency (children not attached to parents will be more delinquent than children who are attached.), while differential association theory implies that strong attachments to delinquent peers will increase delinquent behaviour
(family)
during the Victorian era, who did they blame for the community’s greatest concern?
Reminiscent of concerns in the Victorian era, people at a Canadian town hall meeting with police officers identified “problem youth” as the community’s greatest concern and “blamed parents for the problem.”
Most research examining the relationship between family factors and youth crime has looked at either the structure of the family or family relationships.
these studies have taken a MICROSCOPIC PERSPECTIVE which refers to theoretical approaches that focus on individuals and behaviour in small social setting rather in the context of larger social structures
they also examine FAMILY STRUCTURE; this is how families are structured in terms of living arrangements or whether the family is “broken” (divorced or separated) or whether both parents are working.
TRADITIONAL WESTERN MODEL:
Much of the early research and conceptual understandings adopted a traditional Western model of the family as the “norm”—a “nuclear” family that consists of two heterosexual parents living with their own (birth) juvenile children.
what are the nine family “type”
In reality, families have many different structures, and the model of a traditional nuclear family just does not represent the structures of many families today
this includes single parents (both heterosexual and gay or lesbian) with adopted or birth children; elderly parents with married children; and blended families with married parents (heterosexual or gay or lesbian) living with their own juvenile children as well as children from previous marriages, to name just a few.
what is the problem with family structure studies?
Family structure studies have assumed a traditional model and begin their research with the premise that anything other than this model is a problem.
Family relationship studies are not as tied to these assumptions and look at such things as parenting skills, parental supervision of children, parenting styles, and young people’s attachments to parents.
> family structure
what is the broken homes hypothesis? and why is this an “intuitive” explanations as to why why one-parent families may be more likely than two-parent families to produce delinquent children?
broken-home hypothesis: the commonly held proposition that children from divorced and single-parent families are more likely to be delinquent
what gender-headed family is considered poorer than those in two-parent families?
One comes from the reality that children in one-parent families, particularly female-headed families, are considerably poorer than those in two-parent families.
While this in itself is not necessarily problematic, the additional fact that single parents do not have the support of another adult in the home to assist in child-rearing means a potential for less support and supervision for the child, particularly if the lone parent also has to work long hours to provide for the family.
A related assumption, derived from the traditional nuclear family model,
children need ___ discipline for healthy development?
A related assumption, derived from the traditional nuclear family model, is that children need paternal discipline and that boys especially need male (preferably father) role models for healthy development.
whar is the three major effects of divorce on women that may influence children’s behaviour?
(1) single mothers are overburdened from working in the labour force and caring for children;
(2) single mothers experience considerable financial stress in that female-headed households earn less than half the income of male-headed households; and
(3) single mothers experience social isolation, which means they have fewer social and emotional supports.
This of course does not mean that children from divorced homes are more problematic than other children, only that these are factors that can contribute to problems.
other examples:
- a related common belief is that mothers from two-parent families who work outside the home also contribute to delinquency in that they are overburdened and cannot provide the child-rearing supports and supervision that their children need.
- There is, however, very little evidence that working mothers produce more delinquency; less time spent with children does not necessarily mean less quality time.
what did Edward Wells and Joseph Rankin (1991) found about the impacts of broken homes on delinquency?
In the early 1990s, Edward Wells and Joseph Rankin (1991) conducted a meta-analysis of the research on the impact of broken homes on delinquency and found that the relationship between broken homes and delinquency is weak at best;
; this relationship has been empirically demonstrated consistently for more than 50 years; (3) the relationship is stronger for minor crimes than for serious ones; and (4) to the extent that there are negative effects on children, these effects are greater for boys than for girls. A major problem with much of the family structure research through the 1970s and 1980s is that it
what is a major problem with much of the family structure research through the 1970s and 1980s?
A major problem with much of the family structure research through the 1970s and 1980s is that it did not incorporate, for comparative purposes, a comparison group of families that were not divorced. Hence, we had no way of knowing if children from non-divorced families would also experience problems with delinquency.
On the other hand, some of the few studies that did use comparison groups are equally flawed in that they relied on what type of data?
official data - In so doing, they are just as likely to have measured the effect of police and judicial attitudes toward single-parent and female-headed households.
Johnson (1986), for example, found that even though girls from single-mother households were no more likely to self-report delinquent behaviour, they were more likely to be arrested and go to court than girls from traditional two-parent families.
there is also little research that has examined the positive effects of single-parenting on children
for example, it could be argued that these children are more independent and have a stronger sense of responsibility than children from two-parent homes.
Strohschein found that levels of depression and antisocial behaviour were very high in families where parents divorced, but, most important, she found that depression and antisocial behaviour levels for these children were already higher at the beginning of the study, compared with children whose parents did not divorce over the four-year period.
Conversely, she found that the mental health and behavioural problems of children with highly dysfunctional families actually improved after a divorce. Her conclusion with regard to “broken” families was that “most of the damages are done before the divorce”
similarly, what did Sigfusdottir, Farkas, and Silver (2004) found when they tested Agnew’s strain theory>
They tested Agnew’s strain theory, measured as stress on children from exposure to arguments and fights at home, and found that this type of exposure is related to depression and anger among adolescents.
However, depression had no effect on delinquency, while anger increased levels of adolescent delinquent behaviour.
from these evidence about single or working mothers, what could we say?
the bulk of the evidence suggests that single mothers and working mothers do not “cause” delinquent behaviour.
Parenting skills, parenting styles, and family dynamics, rather than family structure, might account for the weak relationship identified by some studies.
> parenting
what has been identified as significant factors for youth criminality?
Negative parent–child relationships and poor parenting skills have been identified as significant risk factors for youth criminality
Data from the NLSCY show that children whose parents engage in poor parenting practices are more likely to have behavioural problems than other children (
why is parenting skills programs a difficukt and complicated task to sort out empirically?
Parenting skills programs are commonly offered to parents whose children are experiencing behavioural difficulties, often as part of diversionary programs for young offenders.
Nonetheless, it is a difficult and complicated task to sort out empirically exactly what it is about parenting that contributes to problem behaviours in children and youth.
what are the two most important aspects of parenting behaviour according to Diana Baumrind?
(1) the extent to which parents are supportive of their children’s needs (parental responsiveness) and
(2) the extent to which parents are demanding of appropriate behaviour from their children (parental demandingness).
Hence, parents may be authoritative (i.e., supportive and demanding), authoritarian (rejecting and demanding), indulgent (supportive and not at all demanding), or indifferent (rejecting and not at all demanding).
parenting styles: (baumrind)
Authoritative parents set standards and have expectations that are consistent with their child’s age. Such parents discuss and explain disciplinary matters with their children.
Authoritarian parents value obedience and conformity. These parents tend to restrict children’s autonomy and to favour the use of punitive disciplinary measures.
Indulgent parents allow children considerable freedom, are opposed to control or disciplinary measures, and see themselves more as resources for their children than as disciplinarian
Indifferent parents spend little time with their children, know little about their children’s activities, and tend to put their own needs above those of their children. In extreme cases, indifferent parents neglect their children.